User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #1 > Question on Scouting bars?
Page:
 
staggart
offline
Link
 
I know they have no practical use than to just see if it will be a blow out, but what decides them?

For instance http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=122&team2=1296

Notice the rushing bar. How is that score assigned? Is it just the rb and fb or is the oline added in? What makes TCC's score higher than Perfection when their running back and fb are both higher level and builds appear not to be the issue?
 
brownryango
offline
Link
 
i know that SAs are not taken into account for the scouting bars...don't know if that helps.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by staggart
I know they have no practical use than to just see if it will be a blow out, but what decides them?

For instance http://goallineblitz.com/game/compare_teams.pl?team1=122&team2=1296

Notice the rushing bar. How is that score assigned? Is it just the rb and fb or is the oline added in? What makes TCC's score higher than Perfection when their running back and fb are both higher level and builds appear not to be the issue?


Equipment is not considered either, I've heard that SAs aren't taken into account either but I don't know. brownryango said he knew it so I'll take his word for it.

It's because the scouting bars have a set formula to increase it, it doesn't matter how successful your player is... It's just if you put your points to help increase the scouting bar according to the formula.

This is why the scouting bar is useless, IMO.
 
slimjimzv
offline
Link
 
I wonder why Bort doesn't fix this. Unless it would take an inordinate amount of work, but it doesn't seem like it would be that difficult.
 
Luzod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by staggart
Notice the rushing bar. How is that score assigned? Is it just the rb and fb or is the oline added in? What makes TCC's score higher than Perfection when their running back and fb are both higher level and builds appear not to be the issue?


HB, FB and QB for rushing bar.

Also... Elusive HBs get better rushing bar, so powerback won't give the team any super rushing bar even if he gets 50 yards/run
 
Admerylous
offline
Link
 
Actually I am fairly certain SAs are taken into account for scouting bars on players to generate their overall score. They do not have nearly the impact that the actual skill points do, however.
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Luzod


HB, FB and QB for rushing bar


You are correct sir


 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Admerylous
Actually I am fairly certain SAs are taken into account for scouting bars on players to generate their overall score. They do not have nearly the impact that the actual skill points do, however.


WOW, I think I agree with Brownryango...but still not Admerylous, even when you agree with one Cap, theres another to disagree with...

And its too quiet without the other Caps in here...Although hatred was thick, they made it interesting. I ain't no cheese eater, so don't know why they are gone. (anything more than day bans aren't necessary imo).

Edit: OK, I lied - Alfies can stay gone if he is gone. I forgot about that dude.
Last edited Feb 2, 2009 17:41:20
 
Admerylous
offline
Link
 
Hmm. Well...
I had a player that invested 100% of my skill points into special attributes exclusively with a set of boosts.
My scouting bars went up.

Take that anecdotal evidence whichever way you want to.
 
cliff
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Pariah


And its too quiet without the other Caps in here...Although hatred was thick, they made it interesting. I ain't no cheese eater, so don't know why they are gone. (anything more than day bans aren't necessary imo).



I would rather it be quiet than read one more "caps are great" post. Those things are so boring and repetitive that they might as well be nothing anyway.

That's like asking to be punched in the face because you're bored and at least then you'd be doing *something* ... no thanks.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Admerylous
Hmm. Well...
I had a player that invested 100% of my skill points into special attributes exclusively with a set of boosts.
My scouting bars went up.

Take that anecdotal evidence whichever way you want to.


Did you look at the bars before you put those points into the SAs after you boosted?

You have 2 points or something go into major attributes and 1 point or something go into minor attributes every time you gain a level.

That increase could have triggered the scouting bars going up... Following me here?
 
Admerylous
offline
Link
 
I'm well aware of the marginal increases from leveling.
All I recall is investing heavily in SAs and having a notable increase in the scouting bars.
Like I said, take my anecdotal evidence however you wish. It's feasible that I hadn't noticed a jump prior to the SA investment.

Guys, can you keep this on stag's topic? If you want to discuss how great the Caps are feel free to make another thread for that.
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slimjimzv
I wonder why Bort doesn't fix this. Unless it would take an inordinate amount of work, but it doesn't seem like it would be that difficult.


More important things to work on. I mean, even if they were more accurate, so what, right? We all know who the solid, middle of the pack, and weak teams in the league are.

You still have to scout, and you still have to game plan, because you can exploit weaknesses in teams who are better on paper. I'd put that very low on the priority compared to some of the cool stuff he's working on.
Last edited Feb 2, 2009 20:40:07
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by slimjimzv

I wonder why Bort doesn't fix this. Unless it would take an inordinate amount of work, but it doesn't seem like it would be that difficult.


More important things to work on. I mean, even if they were more accurate, so what, right? We all know who the solid, middle of the pack, and weak teams in the league are.

You still have to scout, and you still have to game plan, because you can exploit weaknesses in teams who are better on paper. I'd put that very low on the priority compared to some of the cool stuff he's working on.


lol @ the Honky Tonk Man
 
brownryango
offline
Link
 
i say that SAs don't count towards the scouting bars because bort said it somewhere. basically there were CPU players that had insanely high ratings on the scouting bars, and people were freaking out, because it looked like they were going to overpower the league, and bort made a post that said something like "CPU players only get stats in regular attributes and not SAs and that is why their bars appear so high compared to human controlled players"

it was a couple months ago, so i can't recall the exact post or where i saw it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.