Originally posted by Paratroopa1
The problem with trying to build a player that forces fumbles is that's just... well, it's a bad idea, to put it bluntly. Forced fumbles aren't something that you go out and try to get, they're something that just happen. If the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (as in, properly covering up the ball) and the guy tackling the guy carrying the ball is playing properly (going for the tackle first and the strip second, not the other way around - and I HATE it when players do it the other way around in non-desperation situations), then forced fumbles just don't happen too frequently. A lot of "forced" fumbles are half hard hits but half freak accidents. Even then, you gotta be in the right place at the right time. You only make so many tackles in one game. Like maybe 6-7 at most (if you make any more than that chances are you're not playing particularly well). So... yeah, no. And definitely just saying "well I have 60 strength and tackling" doesn't cut it, you gotta have like 100 strength and 10 in Monster Hit before I go "yeah, you have a point," 60 in a stat really isn't a lot. And think about it, if lots of strength and lots of Big/Monster Hit were a surefire way to see an increased production in forced fumbles... then fumbles would be happening a LOT and this game would become an exploitable mess. I think the forced fumble rate is PERFECT as it stands, and players shouldn't be striving to try to force them. They just happen.
I pretty much agree with this, but there are three different tackling settings, and they should mean something. At the very least, power tackling should bring with it a significant increase in fumbling and missed tackles. Not necessarily a fumble per game against equal competition, but something close to the high-end of the rate of fumbles per tackle in the NFL (if the player otherwise has a build to support forcing fumbles).
Last edited Jan 20, 2009 06:58:24