User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Has anybody tried simply demoralizing powerbacks this year?
Page:
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
I've never been a big fan of the "hard hitter" abilities on most of the trees... but that was mostly because we didn't know that they worked. Now that we know that they DO, and that they happen more often than we thought, has anybody had any success with snarl, big hit, and monster hit against powerbacks? The goal wouldn't really be to cause fumbles (although it'd be nice), but rather to try and lower the morale of the back with one of your more powerful defenders (whom wouldn't need to be very fast to catch the powerback, anyways), making things easier for the rest of your defense?

I wouldn't go overboard with it, but I think one LB (probably MLB?) and a SS with some decent investments in those skills should probably be able to lower the morale of the ball carrier enough that your other players at least stand a chance, right? Has anybody seen any results with this?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Demoralizing SA's are very ineffective from what I have seen.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
shhhhhh......already working on that.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Demoralizing SA's are very ineffective from what I have seen.


maybe from individual players but when you have several very high level players on the field at the same time with high confidence and significant points in those SAs, they can have a pretty decent cumulative effect. Throw in a couple of vets that have points in the Intimidation VA that increases the required confidence to resist those abilities and you have a good chance. However, that's a team concept and it requires several players building a specific way so not every team can approach it that way.
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
Originally posted by Deathblade

Demoralizing SA's are very ineffective from what I have seen.


maybe from individual players but when you have several very high level players on the field at the same time with high confidence and significant points in those SAs, they can have a pretty decent cumulative effect. Throw in a couple of vets that have points in the Intimidation VA that increases the required confidence to resist those abilities and you have a good chance. However, that's a team concept and it requires several players building a specific way so not every team can approach it that way.


right well going by what you said i assume high confidence is what triggers demoralize SA's is that confirmed or just assumed but nobody knows for sure?
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch

right well going by what you said i assume high confidence is what triggers demoralize SA's is that confirmed or just assumed but nobody knows for sure?


Nothing is needed to "trigger" SA's unless it says it is needed.

Pretty sure Bort got snappy once when someone asked what was needed to trigger the demoralizing SA's, saying something like "Some SA's can't just work?".
Last edited Jan 18, 2009 00:17:44
 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
yeah thats what i thought but hydroshock made it sound like high confidence was a requirement so i was just asking.
 
boondocksaint
offline
Link
 
You need 72.93+ conf
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Demoralizing SA's are very ineffective from what I have seen.


Well, I think ones like Aura of Int and Glare and ones like that don't seem very effective... but what about the ones like Big and Monster Hit? I'd like to see a game where players with a couple of those SAs jacked up play against a good powerback. The key would be to see if he gets tackled behind the line more, breaks less tackles as the game goes on, etc. it would be something that would (hopefully) have a cumulative effect throughout the course of the game... So you might be getting trucked in the first and second quarter, but hopefully you'd slow him down by the time the third and fourth quarter roll around, which might end up causing a few more 3 and outs and failed third down conversions... Maybe even a fumble or two if you're lucky?

I have always been pretty against those SA's... but now that we can at least see when SOME of them work, it would become a lot easier to measure any positive effect they may have. And if it was viable for stopping anybody, it'd be powerbacks.

Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Mordaloch


right well going by what you said i assume high confidence is what triggers demoralize SA's is that confirmed or just assumed but nobody knows for sure?


Nothing is needed to "trigger" SA's unless it says it is needed.

Pretty sure Bort got snappy once when someone asked what was needed to trigger the demoralizing SA's, saying something like "Some SA's can't just work?".


Yeah, he did say something pretty similar to that.


edit: And if you were going to try and go that route, it'd be much better IMO to try and stock up on strength and tackling than confidence. That way you A) Make sure you're making the tackles and B) increase the chance of actually forcing a fumble (Bort himself even said that if tackling numbers were higher, we'd probably see a more realistic number of fumbles).
Last edited Jan 18, 2009 00:24:51
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
bump for actually being an intelligent theory

Blamo, you're not the only one that is thinking along these lines. We haven't played a lot of power backs yet but the odds increase exponentially that we will, and probably sooner rather than later. I've already started fortifying my defense for the inevitable. We may suffer the same fate as the others complaining in these forums, but that's not going to stop us from finding a solution.

There are some teams that are fortunate enough to control the majority of their key player positions, as unpopular as that may be to some. Say what you want about owners using a large majority of their own resources for their own teams and not relying on the ridiculous FA market, but there is a certain continuity for teams that have that luxury because it allows them to adapt to situations such as the one you mention in the OP, by focusing on the problem as a team. Boosting one individuals intimidation and tackling abilities may help him improve his stats, but overcoming an "exploit" requires multiple players.

only thing I know at this point is if we see a power back in the playoffs, I want to be as prepared as possible to limit the damage. Check back with me at the end of the season and I'll let you know if it worked.

 
Mordaloch
offline
Link
 
hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
I know of one pro team that decided to heavily invest in the hard hitters tree for their LBs after the beginning of the season, when they missed a lot of tackles. Said pro team isn't doing too well, but their missed tackles are way down over the last 4 games.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
hey Blamo, so you saying, say people 3x capped tackling for example got it like 70's 80's with equipment that increases chance of fumbles forced according to bort?


According to Bort? Yes
According to the sim? No, not really.

I'm looking at a player with 73 tackling and 65 strength who hasn't forced a fumble for two seasons, in around 70 tackles.
Last edited Jan 18, 2009 00:30:40
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mordaloch
Originally posted by HydrOshocK

Originally posted by Deathblade


Demoralizing SA's are very ineffective from what I have seen.


maybe from individual players but when you have several very high level players on the field at the same time with high confidence and significant points in those SAs, they can have a pretty decent cumulative effect. Throw in a couple of vets that have points in the Intimidation VA that increases the required confidence to resist those abilities and you have a good chance. However, that's a team concept and it requires several players building a specific way so not every team can approach it that way.


right well going by what you said i assume high confidence is what triggers demoralize SA's is that confirmed or just assumed but nobody knows for sure?


very little in GLB is confirmed. Anyone that has been around since season 1 will tell you the same. There is no guide book for this game, only what we've been able to piece together form Bort's drive by posts. He has said that confidence is one of the most underrated skills in the game, and we've taken that for face value. I would hope that the game designer would not deliberately lead us into investing hard earned income on a wild goose chase.

See, the problem that most people run into is that they've been trying to shift player focus from exploit to exploit, and in the long run that has stunted their growth in other areas, such as confidence. Those that decided to invest training and extra SP on those skills a long time ago are starting to see much better results. Can I prove it? Not really, because we haven't had a stable sample to draw our results from because of all of the random changes. Each one creates a new problem that needs to be addressed, and you end up chasing the white rabbit, but we continue to follow the clues and try to stay as much ahead of the curve as possible. The result has been a roster full of outstanding players that never win individual trophies but play pretty damn good as a team.

.02
 
Blamo
offline
Link
 
My only suggestion, like I said, would be to try and jack your strength/tackling up as high as possible for the players that you DO decide to try this with. I think MLB is probably the position I'd try it with, since I think you lose the least there from having a slower player and I think from the MLB position is where you'd get to the powerback most often... Not to mention if you want D-General, you have to travel down that path anyways. I don't know if I'd shift more than that into it, though. Even if your OLBs are speed heavy, they should be able to "drag" the HB long enough for the MLB to get there and hopefully lay the beef onto the back. I think that SS's have the best SAs to get this kind of thing done, but I don't know if that's a position where I'd want to consistently sacrifice that much speed/utility to try and stop powerbacks. It's too bad the defense doesn't have anything like the TE1/2 for certain play packages to give the defense that kind of flexibility.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.