User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > BUG: sub in/out doesn't follow stamina setting
Page:
 
Link
 
In our last game (http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=11961 ), the 1st and 2nd string LBs started to take turn on defensive plays in the beginning of 3rd quarter. Starting LBs played one snap, 2nd strings played the next snap, and then starters came in and played the next one, and so on.

Our 3rd string LBs didn't play any snap in this game and finished the game with 99 or 100 energy. Also, the difference between sub-out and sub-in is 6 to 10, for example, 70/80. Thus, unless a player can recover 6 to 10 energy in one snap, there is a bug here.

The explanation of both 1st and 2nd LBs are under 'sub-out' requirement doesn't apply. Because in this case, the 3rd string should come in.

No force starter setting was enabled for 3rd quarter.
Last edited May 7, 2008 18:45:46
 
Link
 
Bort? DD? moderators? Please take a look at this bug.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
It is possible for a player to recover 6 energy on the bench, depending on his stamina, what he did, and how long the play went on. If a bunch of time ran off the clock, or a timeout was called, a player can gains back more than if a little time ran off.

If you really want them to split evenly, and further down the DC, you should set the settings higher and closer, like 98/99 or so.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
It'd be nice to be able to set play % instead of having to guess all the time

Like have the depth chart with 3 players on it and have a text box where we can type 60,30,10 in order next to the 3 players such that the top player will tend to get around 60% of the plays, the second will tend around 30% and the bottom player to tend around 10% of them

Dropping the energy requirements has seemed to result in 70/2/0 turning into 30/30/20 but i don't weight the #3 player as highly as the 1 and 2 and it would be nice to be able to indicate that somehow.
 
insect
offline
Link
 
..your entire defense was switching every play, not just the LBs. Looks like for most positions it started after the Storm's punt at two minutes left in the first quarter.

Only question I would have is if you didn't have the sub settings reversed accidentally? A lower requirement to come in than to be taken out would make them trade off like that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It is possible for a player to recover 6 energy on the bench, depending on his stamina, what he did, and how long the play went on. If a bunch of time ran off the clock, or a timeout was called, a player can gains back more than if a little time ran off.

If you really want them to split evenly, and further down the DC, you should set the settings higher and closer, like 98/99 or so.


Maybe a player can recover 6 to 10 energy in a snap once in a while, but six players (3 starters and 3 backups) on every snap after half time? This is a serious bug that can affect game plan.

No, I don't want them split evenly. I want my 3rd string come in when 1st and 2nd strings are tired.

Please take a more closer look, this explanation doesn't sound right. It is possible for a player to recover 6 to 10 energy, but is it possible for six players to recover 6 to 10 energy on every snaps after halftime? I'd guess that one of the if-statements still checks the default stamina setting instead of the advanced stamina setting of each LB position.
Last edited May 7, 2008 22:10:33
 
Link
 
Originally posted by insect
..your entire defense was switching every play, not just the LBs. Looks like for most positions it started after the Storm's punt at two minutes left in the first quarter.

Only question I would have is if you didn't have the sub settings reversed accidentally? A lower requirement to come in than to be taken out would make them trade off like that.


No, I'm sure about it. The settings are like 70/80, not 80/70.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by Bort

It is possible for a player to recover 6 energy on the bench, depending on his stamina, what he did, and how long the play went on. If a bunch of time ran off the clock, or a timeout was called, a player can gains back more than if a little time ran off.

If you really want them to split evenly, and further down the DC, you should set the settings higher and closer, like 98/99 or so.


Maybe a player can recover 6 to 10 energy in a snap once in a while, but six players (3 starters and 3 backups) on every snap after half time? This is a serious bug that can affect game plan.

No, I don't want them split evenly. I want my 3rd string come in when 1st and 2nd strings are tired.

Please take a more closer look, this explanation doesn't sound right. I'd guess that one of the if-statements still checks the default stamina setting instead of the advanced stamina setting of each LB position.


Do you really think you are going to get a better explanation? You got it from the guy that wrote the code.
 
Link
 
I know, I was suggesting that there was a bug and hoping he could check the codes. If I could convince him that his explanation doesn't stand, maybe he'll believe there is really a bug in the program.

I know what writing codes is like, I do that everyday. There are things you expect your programs do, and there are things the programs actually do. Sometimes a simple typo could make a big difference.
Last edited May 7, 2008 22:23:14
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
It is possible for a player to recover 6 energy on the bench, depending on his stamina, what he did, and how long the play went on. If a bunch of time ran off the clock, or a timeout was called, a player can gains back more than if a little time ran off.

If you really want them to split evenly, and further down the DC, you should set the settings higher and closer, like 98/99 or so.



Bort,

Does that 98/99 really help with rotating players who are 3rd or possibly 4th on your depth chart????

Say like at WR & CB where most teams run 4 or 5 deep... some run 6 or 7 deep...

Just curious...
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
I also had a similar problem, but our %s are 20 apart (and yes, sub-out % is lower than sub-in). At several different positions the starter would sub out and back in the next play alternating even though we have a third string at those positions (one of which got 0 plays).

The most obvious position where this was occurring for is our running backs as you can see in play-by-play that RB#1 runs, RB#2 runs, RB#1 runs, RB#2 runs etc. Our third string HB is in the depth chart, so there is no way this should be happening.

This was happening to OTs and Gs as well, but I am sure other positions also (these are just the ones I happened to notice).

Link to the game: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=23737&mode=pbp
Last edited May 8, 2008 10:09:51
 
Link
 
Bort, this also happened to TreMetal's team, not just one team. This is a seriuos bug, please check your source codes regarding this issue. If you don't have time, please at least let us know this is really a bug.

Thanks
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Do you have any of these third string players playing special teams as well? That can drain them to where they are lower on energy than the 2nd string guy.

I'm running some tests with your setups, but so far everything looks correct.

It's really not all that complicated of code - just a couple sorted arrays.
 
Link
 
All 3rd string LBs had zero snaps in the game. One of the 3rd string LBs is in special team but he is near the bottom of special team depth chart. He had zero snap in the game as well.

All the 3rd string LBs ended the game with exactly same energy as before the game (99 or 100).

Regarding the source codes, one area to look at is whether the program uses the advanced sub-out/sub-in settings all the time if being set. Maybe somehow it uses the default sub-out/sub-in values in certain conditions. Just my guess.

Thanks for looking into this issue, right now, I'm kind of confused on how to prepare for next game.
Last edited May 8, 2008 14:00:10
 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
My third string HB literally got 0 plays that game, he is deep on the ST lists and did not get in on plays there either. Half of my second string guys got almost no playtime, a lot of which are not on STs.

Thanks for checking this out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.