User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > ReProgram the Simulation - Redo The Game
Page:
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
NOT A WIPE! - Keep all of the data and player builds. Just do this with the Simulation and Game for Season 8 and let the players run wild.

Redo all of the mechanics of the game to adapt to what you've learned over the last 7 seasons. I'd say this is what you need to add:

1) Differentiate the mechanics used for Pass Blocking and Run Blocking.

-Pass Blocking will require more Speed/Agility to do well and to get around.
-Run Blocking will require more Strength to do and get through.

2) Momentum and directional vectors.

-No more monster tackles on players running away from you.
-Higher propensity for Power Thru, Monster Hit when players have a head of steam.
-Slowing down after a Power Thru to lessen ability to do it again and make tackling possible.

3) Match Ups and Situation Dept Charts on BOTH SIDES OF THE BALL

-Certain DE is in? A certain OT lines up in front of him.
-Certain RB is in? A certain set of LBs come in for him.
-Certain WR is in? A certain DB lines up on him.
-- You can set it like WR - Chad Johnson -- Matchup CB1 - Champ Bailey, Terrence Newman, Deion Sanders. Basically so if Champ is tired its Terrence's job and if he's tired it's Deion's. It'd be an override, just like the AIs and Depth Chart settings we have.

4) Roster Maximum. Unpopular but with the increased depth chart flexibility pick a relatively high number and stick to it. 2 QBs, 4 RBs, 8 WRs, etc. add that all up and make a max roster size. This will also encourage the spreading of talent and development of balanced players who can fill multiple roles while taking up one roster spot.

5) Dots need to take up the space around them, like they do in the replays. That way when a hole is present its actually there and the players can go through them instead of suffering a ridiculous slow down every time they hit the line of scrimmage.

6) Special teams from kick coverage to returning needs to be reworked. Players running down the field, stopping, turning, running horizontally, then resuming their vertical run is so stupid it makes me want to pull my hair out. Likewise with returners plowing into the first guy coming at them. Do they even know how to run diagonally in this game? If not, well, damn..

7) Ability to tell the Defenders who are covering the HB, FB or TE that stays in to block what to do. Blitz? Double a WR? Play a Deep Zone? Play a Short Zone? QB Spy? The Chicken Dance? Let us pick in the AI.

8) Anything else that comes up while you're programming away and all the stuff that still needs work but has been getting moderately better over time like Zone Coverage.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense. Forget it, we'll just implement weight classes, positional soft caps, nerf-hammers and automatic slowdown/speedups to compensate for the mechanics.

Seriously people, its the mechanics that are the core of the game and I think that's really what Bort got a chance to learn about. When he sits there and says "I wish I had put in an acceleration attribute" it shows that there are things he didn't consider when he built the game (Which is totally understandable, he had no way to know until he tested it and he really did a great job considering all the things he did get.). I think with these focuses on a rewrite of the mechanics he could enrich the experience and get rid of a lot of the unbalanced portions of the game without having to nerf builds left and right.
 
Link
 
+1

To the op, not your second post.
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
+1
 
slydersneak
offline
Link
 
+1both points make sense
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheInfinity
Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...


I see this. I think it would require a whole lot of work.

I think it needs to be done..but the chances of this coming to fruition are slim to none..
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Game needs to be overhauled no question about it.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
There have been a multitude of bigtime ideas that would mean completely changing most of this game's base...they won't be done basically because Bort's stated in the past on some of them that he has his own vision and this is it.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Season 7 has been arguably the season with the most changes to the sim...and resulted in tons of complaints (this is broken, stop making changes, etc).

It's taken us months to get where we are (personally I think it's mostly getting better...sometimes 2 steps foward, 1 step back, though), and redoing the sim would take too long.
Last edited Jan 11, 2009 23:08:50
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
There have been a multitude of bigtime ideas that would mean completely changing most of this game's base...they won't be done basically because Bort's stated in the past on some of them that he has his own vision and this is it.


However, he has stated he wishes he could change things...but doesn't due to the fact too many people are going to cry and whine about it.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Some facets have gotten better, no doubt about it...I think the running game's better personally, while others disagree entirely. I think the special teams coverage lanes and routes they take are slightly better...and I think the kicking is somewhat better, but now a tad behind what it should be hehe...

Everybody's got their own take on what's what around here, Bort just needs to figure out who to listen to the most...those who make the most noise, or those who put the most thought into it...
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Should have figured this would get no responses, its an actual suggestion that makes sense.


And involves making a completely new game...


Considering how much has changed from Season 1 - Day 1 to Today, its hard to say GLB is the same game it was. Different positions and builds have had periods of dominance. Speed DEs, Speed Rushers, Power Rushers, Speed DTs, Speed WRs, Possession WRs have all gone around the carousel for dominance. Attributes have changed in importance many times from people needing more carrying to needing more strength/tackling on defense.

The thing is that these have all been piecemeal changes and usually band-aid fixes to cover up slight flaws that show that the core logic needs reworking. We need the overhaul and I believe the eight points above give Bort good places to focus while doing that overhaul.

Its like a constant redesign on a car model. Eventually you realize its not even the same car anymore.. and I think we're there and have to start from scratch with a new design for a new model.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
Some facets have gotten better, no doubt about it...I think the running game's better personally, while others disagree entirely. I think the special teams coverage lanes and routes they take are slightly better...and I think the kicking is somewhat better, but now a tad behind what it should be hehe...

Everybody's got their own take on what's what around here, Bort just needs to figure out who to listen to the most...those who make the most noise, or those who put the most thought into it...


The squeeky wheel gets the grease applies to GLB more than almost any thing else I've ever seen.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
You and GG are gonna have fun here...that I can assure you...

Now about these changes...well, I wish you luck, but I highly doubt it...unfortunately. I agree, though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.