User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
I don't know if you guys have done them here in AA3 before, but we used to have a Coach's Poll and it was a lot of fun. Hedgehog, an old GM from QC used to do a great job on them. After the game, the owners (or elegible representitive) PM whoever's doing it, their top 5 teams in the league. It's based solely on votes, rather that stats like a power ranking, but is a good way to get the pulse of the league.

Any interest in this guys?
Last edited Jan 3, 2009 20:10:25
 
Padre
offline
Link
 
I am down for it.
 
TheRooster
offline
Link
 
Hmm, sounds interesting. I'll represent the Heads.
 
BigDunc55
offline
Link
 
Im in
 
HoustonMark
offline
Link
 
I'm all about anything that adds to positive forum activity. Might I suggest doing just the top 5 from the conference from which your team resides? If not, I'm still all about this.
 
TheRooster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HoustonMark
I'm all about anything that adds to positive forum activity. Might I suggest doing just the top 5 from the conference from which your team resides? If not, I'm still all about this.


That's a good idea too. Being out of conference makes it difficult to judge your non-opponents well, mostly because you never play them so you get no appreciation for how good, bad, overrated or underrated they are.

A Top 5 for the East and Top 5 for the West.
Last edited Jan 4, 2009 02:19:49
 
BigDunc55
offline
Link
 
Let me start by saying Rooster I have always loved your avatar!!

ok Coaches poll... top 5?? Top 5 teams what?? this week next week?? Is it going to be a revolving door. The NCAA Coaches poll is represented by all. Not sure they all play each other?
I think all should be represented. All should have a voice. Those that dont get there picks in that week... guess they dont vote.
I could maybe see voting for your own conference? But why not get everyone involved? Everyone pays their dues
 
Link
 
I'm willing to do the math if someone else wants to do the writeups...I just figure those may be done better by someone that knows AA3 and the history here more than I. Any volunteers?
 
TheRooster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BigDunc55
Let me start by saying Rooster I have always loved your avatar!!

ok Coaches poll... top 5?? Top 5 teams what?? this week next week?? Is it going to be a revolving door. The NCAA Coaches poll is represented by all. Not sure they all play each other?
I think all should be represented. All should have a voice. Those that dont get there picks in that week... guess they dont vote.
I could maybe see voting for your own conference? But why not get everyone involved? Everyone pays their dues


I think everyone is invited to represent by voting, but obviously not everyone will make the top teams list. 5 of 32 is what 16% of teams? There's something like 119 college teams, and in a top 25 poll, 21% of teams are represented in the poll. If we did a top 10, 31% of teams would be represented, so maybe a top 10 coaches poll would be best, so long as it included everyone. Top 5's if you want to keep it separate.

You make a good point about coaches voting for all teams, even if they don't know them well.
 
HoustonMark
offline
Link
 
Another reason I say that the owners/team reps should only vote for the top 5 in their conference is that you want to make this as easy as possible for the voters. I've seen the Coach's Poll work great for 2-3 weeks or so and then fall off because well...for some owners, getting them to even post in the forums is a chore.
 
Ramius7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HoustonMark
Another reason I say that the owners/team reps should only vote for the top 5 in their conference is that you want to make this as easy as possible for the voters. I've seen the Coach's Poll work great for 2-3 weeks or so and then fall off because well...for some owners, getting them to even post in the forums is a chore.


+87
 
FLGator
offline
Link
 
Agreed...Top 5 in each conference would be not only easier, but more accurate. I'm in.
 
ploije
offline
Link
 
Im in
 
BigDunc55
offline
Link
 
So every team votes but we just vote our top 5?

Ok I am down with that. Well how about top 8. Now we are talking possible playoff teams. Would be neat to see if our Coaches poll matches Playoff teams at the end of the season.

Also we all know the top 4 prob 5 will be moving on next year. If we start including the teams that will be the cornerstone of this division next season it will give them something to build on? Just a thought.

But Im in
 
HoustonMark
offline
Link
 
Well, chances are, if we vote on our Top 5, we won't all have the same Top 5...so, after the Top 5 are listed, you could have a "Also Receiving Votes" and list how many votes they got. That would get ya close to a Top 8 or even beyond if it gets pretty tight in a particular conference where opinion is spread out a bit more.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.