User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The fix for powerbacks.... without taking away from their abilities
Page:
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=289337&pbp_id=1873575

Plays like this are just ridiculous, and completely unrealistic...

In my opinion, power backs should still be able to run people over. That's not the issue. That's their build, let them have success with it too. The thing is, they should enjoy the majority of their success during the actual playmaking phase of the run, not in the open field.

I've never seen a player in real life break 3 tackles from behind on one run without ever missing a step.

There should be a MAJOR boost to tackling when coming from behind. Outside of that, welcome to the season of isolating a power back in the flats and watching him run at full speed into the endzone.

That being said, to do it right though, you should still be able to drag out a few extra yards when being tackled from behind.


+1 all the way
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


CB and S's just dumpa all points into speed. No-one gives a fuck about "football" skills
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
The very simple and realistic fix is to bump the balance penalty Bort was talking about where it's supposedly harder to break a second tackle after breaking a first. If you increase that penalty, then power runners still gain yardage after contact as intended, but don't become unstoppable tanks that mow through entire defenses.
 
Mathias82
offline
Link
 
All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.


You already had it.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
Originally posted by jktooley

The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


CB and S's just dumpa all points into speed. No-one gives a fuck about "football" skills


yes... because CB's and S's in real life should be linebackers first and coverage guys second.. right?
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jktooley
Originally posted by imnotthatstupid

Originally posted by jktooley


The main issue is, when getting into the flats, you're usually facing one lb, and the rest of the players are cornerbacks and safeties. Yeah, strength and tackling would be nice for your secondary to have... Unfortunately, that would leave you completely unable to cover any WR or TE in the game.


CB and S's just dumpa all points into speed. No-one gives a fuck about "football" skills


yes... because CB's and S's in real life should be linebackers first and coverage guys second.. right?


This guy is missing the point. Is that why a lot of TEs are as fast as WRs?
 
Gart888
things!
offline
Link
 
+1

power backs shouldn't be 'nerfed', but they should be losing more speed when breaking tackles, and shouldn't be so dominant on the open field
 
Mathias82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Homsar16
Originally posted by Mathias82

All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.


You already had it.


Yes yes I heard about it way back in season one or two. I unfortunately started right at the end of season 2 so I missed it. I agree with the op as long as it not boosted for diving tackles, but seriously why do we have to go through this ever season. The only nerf I have agreed with is tieing agi to speed.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
Originally posted by Homsar16

Originally posted by Mathias82


All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.


You already had it.


Yes yes I heard about it way back in season one or two. I unfortunately started right at the end of season 2 so I missed it. I agree with the op as long as it not boosted for diving tackles, but seriously why do we have to go through this ever season. The only nerf I have agreed with is tieing agi to speed.


We're going through it because power backs are averaging 9 YPC against similarly leveled defenses. These guys have 2-capped strength and tackling that are getting run over. You can't expect them to get 80 of both in a matter of 3 days.
 
jktooley
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mathias82
All I want is one season. One season of being better then the elusive HB its all I ask. But because all this whinning has almost reached Bort critical mass nerf. I doupt I get that.


and that's why my proposal isn't really a nerf to the powerback. Rather, it's a booster to one phase of tackling for the defense. I'm pretty much against reducing abilities on a player.
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
my powerback ( on my team, not mine ) got like 4 broken tackles a run. now he gets like 10 a game. i dont get what your crying about.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
my powerback ( on my team, not mine ) got like 4 broken tackles a run. now he gets like 10 a game. i dont get what your crying about.


Just because your guy's build regressed doesn't mean everyone else's isn't thriving.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.