User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New OFFENSIVE and DEFENSIVE Simulation Breakdowns
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Kept noticing threads, have been watching replays and so on. Came up with my own little something.

These would be in-game simulations between the OT and DE to determine the Broken Block or Block.

New and Improved Way for Simulation Breakdowns

Ball Carrier vs. Defender
Obviously a big issue this season, Power Backs/Broken Tackles and Elusive/Lack of Production.

Momentum – Mixture of Spd/Agl/Size combination.

For Offense:
”Combined Offense” – Strength/Speed [decided by run style] with Momentum along with technique/SAs [Spinning, Juke, Power Through ect] going against the defenders “Combined Defense”. Add in confidence/stamina ect.

For Defense:
”Combined Defense” – Momentum with Strength/Tackling and technique/SAs [Low tackling for Small Defenders and Body Tackling for Large]. Add in stamina/confidence ect.

Angles could be added to either equation.

Initial Contact – This is where Combined Offense goes against the Combined Defense. If multiple defenders join in, the offensive players chances drop considerably. Throw the randomness that is a simulation into the formula. This will allow for the better player move on by comparing builds, styles and techniques but not guarantee victory every time for the better player. Chances would be increased based on how much better the build is.


The Defensive End vs. OT Discussion

Occasionally you see a DE get a good step and blow right by nearly untouched for the big sack. However, this type of sack isn't common.

Initial Step from Line – Determines if the DE blows off the line or makes contact with the OT. Occasionally the DE will blow by if far superior, but rare. However, if the OT is far inferior and the DE is great, the chances would rise.

Initial Contact – This is where the DE and OT originally clash. The DE will attempt to get by with a combination of Spd/Agl/SAs/Moves while the OT goes through a similar check down to defend him.

Continued Contact – The players pin their abilities against each other if the DE doesn't originally break through or get pancaked.

As for the initial contact, this is where great DEs make their money.
Defensive Check - Here, truly elite Des use their Spd/Agl/Str/SAs to get by their Ots. The side attributes like confidence, stamina and vision all kick in here but with a lesser effect.
Offensive Check – Strength, agility, speed, blocking along with Sas and the lesser attributes give you a value. The offense originally has a chance of pancaking based on strength/SAs vs. defenders Strength/SAs.

The above comes in play during Initial and Continued contact. With each interaction, a new sim occurs. Chances change based on stamina/confidence and the above %s.

This will allow for the better build to have a higher %, but the lesser build still have a small chance [based on how bad their odds are] with the randomness.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

By comparing strength, agility, speed and other attributes to the other players it won't give Speed or Strength or Agility more value over one or the other.

It also takes away what appears to be an inhibitor on the defensive players [when he gets by but suddenly freezes].
Last edited Jan 3, 2009 14:40:29
 
Loganrobert85
offline
Link
 
+1. probably alot of work, but if you wanted the game to be more realistic then yea.
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
why didnt ur CB sign with my team?
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by loganrobert85
+1. probably alot of work, but if you wanted the game to be more realistic then yea.

A lot of work needs to be done with all of the band aids placed on this game.

Originally posted by imnotthatstupid
why didnt ur CB sign with my team?

Was sick and never got around to the actual recruiting thing.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Explain better plz. Are these like practices? Or are these in game statistical analyses? If the latter, how are the results shown?
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
They would replace the current sim interaction between the players.

As in, when the DE met an OT, the above took place to determine what went on during the play.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
How do you know what the current checks are?
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Does anyone know other then Bort? This is a suggestion of what COULD take place.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Does anyone know other then Bort? This is a suggestion of what COULD take place.


I'd take that up with game designer himself. For all we know, this already happens.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
And for all we know, they pit strength against agility. If no one makes suggestions, the game never improves. That is why I posted it here.
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
Bump.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.