User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania A Leagues > Oceania A #6 > LUElinks vs. Melbourne - Week 16
Page:
 
Species
offline
Link
 
It all comes down to this! If Melbourne wins, playoff seeding at the top more or less stays where it is now: Melbourne #1, Mobile Bay #2 and LUElinks #3. But if the Llamas can pull out the victory (I won't call it an upset, we are evenly matched), then you will have a Big 12 South-like 3-way tie, with each team having lost to a different member of the three-way tie!

Can Melbourne do anything to stop Beanie Wells? Can the Llamas take down Melbourne's stiff 1-2 HB punch, while not ignoring the most efficient passing game (in yards per attempt) and 148.3 passer rating on our QB?

Tune in on Thursday to find out! I can't wait for the game.
 
Maverick1968
offline
Link
 
One difference from the Big 12 South is you won't be waiting for pollsters to break your tie. That was such a stupid way to break a tie. No other conference allows anyone else to have a say so in who their conference champion is. Of course, it is the Big 12, not a conference used to good competitive teams where such a scenario is possible. They are used to 1 team dominating each division.
 
Gunner65
offline
Link
 
I'll make the first prediction:

73 - 24 Melbourne
 
runia24
offline
Link
 
50-20 Melbourne
 
joebus36
offline
Link
 
negative 48 melbourne to negative 48 Llamas
 
BrickHouse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maverick1968
One difference from the Big 12 South is you won't be waiting for pollsters to break your tie. That was such a stupid way to break a tie. No other conference allows anyone else to have a say so in who their conference champion is. Of course, it is the Big 12, not a conference used to good competitive teams where such a scenario is possible. They are used to 1 team dominating each division.


You are wrong.

The SEC has the same type of tiebreaker, the team lowest in the BCS of the three gets thrown out then it goes back to head to head. I don't see how a team can just be thrown out when they have the same record and beat one of the other teams. So I think that way is dumber.
 
big dawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BrickHouse


The SEC has the same type of tiebreaker, the team lowest in the BCS of the three gets thrown out then it goes back to head to head. I don't see how a team can just be thrown out when they have the same record and beat one of the other teams. So I think that way is dumber.


what would your idea be then? i have never heard of a fair way to break a three way tie. one team gets screwed and then it goes back to the head to head. it sucks for the odd man out but that is life.

Last edited Dec 9, 2008 20:58:47
 
BrickHouse
offline
Link
 
I guess it just doesn't make sense to me to discount 1 team based on outside rankings when you are criticizing doing the same thing only to two teams. IMO it should come down to point differential between the H2H games or something of that nature.

I think the right team got the nod from the big 12.
 
Species
offline
Link
 
LOL I guess I started a BCS discussion!

Melbourne 42, LUElinks 24
 
RossT Rucker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by big dawg
Originally posted by BrickHouse



The SEC has the same type of tiebreaker, the team lowest in the BCS of the three gets thrown out then it goes back to head to head. I don't see how a team can just be thrown out when they have the same record and beat one of the other teams. So I think that way is dumber.


what would your idea be then? i have never heard of a fair way to break a three way tie. one team gets screwed and then it goes back to the head to head. it sucks for the odd man out but that is life.



Duh, just have all three teams play in the championship game against each other. create a special triangular field and have all three duke it out at once. That seems the only real logical solution.
 
joebus36
offline
Link
 
BCS sucks balls but I don't care because Penn State is in the Rose Bowl
Last edited Dec 10, 2008 14:43:37
 
big dawg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RossT Rucker


Duh, just have all three teams play in the championship game against each other. create a special triangular field and have all three duke it out at once. That seems the only real logical solution.


that is an excellent idea. i could actually see having both your offense and defense on the field at the same time playing a different opponent.

 
SmikingBlunts
offline
Link
 
Under Dog pick here, 27-24 LUElinks.
 
gramz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maverick1968
One difference from the Big 12 South is you won't be waiting for pollsters to break your tie. That was such a stupid way to break a tie. No other conference allows anyone else to have a say so in who their conference champion is. Of course, it is the Big 12, not a conference used to good competitive teams where such a scenario is possible. They are used to 1 team dominating each division.


At least all 3 teams still got a chance to become champions. I think thats the big difference here and the big 12 south.
 
qjam6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gramz

At least all 3 teams still got a chance to become champions. I think thats the big difference here and the big 12 south.

Amen.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.