User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Team ran same play over and over and OVERPOWERED US!
Page:
 
Link
 
And we couldn't beat it. It isn't fair. *cries*


No, I'm not whining about an offense. I'm whining about a defense. Why should a defense be allowed to call the same coverage over and over again?

If a defense calls the same defense over and over, then the offense should get a boost to vision also since in real life if the defense never changed, then the offense would keep adjusting.

Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


End of Thread


(In before the Lock)
 
Link
 
FYI - we won today. I was just making a point.
 
Darkstrand
offline
Link
 
that's actually a pretty good argument at exposing how ridiculous the "penalize offenses for running the same play" people are

p.s. do you recognize my av subject?
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


Ultimately, it's Bort's decision to what degree this is true, but GLB is a simulation of American football. And in American football, you can't win (barring a radical disparity in the quality of the teams) by calling the dame play 90% of the time. Can you win with a one dimensional offense? Absolutely. But calling the same play over and over is not the same as a one dimensional offense. How realistic the game will be is up to Bort. But this is one area where the realism could be improved.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkstrand


p.s. do you recognize my av subject?


should I?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


Ultimately, it's Bort's decision to what degree this is true, but GLB is a simulation of American football. And in American football, you can't win (barring a radical disparity in the quality of the teams) by calling the dame play 90% of the time. Can you win with a one dimensional offense? Absolutely. But calling the same play over and over is not the same as a one dimensional offense. How realistic the game will be is up to Bort. But this is one area where the realism could be improved.


There also isn't a NFL team that doesn't have 300 plays and multiple variations of the same play. We don't have that in GLB yet.

If teams only had 8-12 plays that consistently worked, they would consider using the same play 50% of the game against certain teams.
 
sam_acw
offline
Link
 
Maybe you should scout them?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
And we couldn't beat it. It isn't fair. *cries*


No, I'm not whining about an offense. I'm whining about a defense. Why should a defense be allowed to call the same coverage over and over again?

If a defense calls the same defense over and over, then the offense should get a boost to vision also since in real life if the defense never changed, then the offense would keep adjusting.

Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


End of Thread


(In before the Lock)


Not a totally unreasonable argument, but remember that defenses are reactive by nature...the defensive call is primarily one of initial positioning and perhaps initial movement. What happens after tick 2 or 3 is largely dependent on the offensive movement.
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

There also isn't a NFL team that doesn't have 300 plays and multiple variations of the same play. We don't have that in GLB yet.

If teams only had 8-12 plays that consistently worked, they would consider using the same play 50% of the game against certain teams.


Point taken, but it doesn't seem that we disagree: a team running the same play over and over is a sign of a fundamental design flaw in the sim.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


Certainly nothing wrong for it, except that any decent offense/defense compared to their opponents would exploit the daylights out of the other team. Look at the Oakland Raiders, of course.

Not only this, it's a design flaw in the SIM.

Thanks for being constructive. NOT.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


There also isn't a NFL team that doesn't have 300 plays and multiple variations of the same play. We don't have that in GLB yet.

If teams only had 8-12 plays that consistently worked, they would consider using the same play 50% of the game against certain teams.


Point taken, but it doesn't seem that we disagree: a team running the same play over and over is a sign of a fundamental design flaw in the sim.



The game isn't done yet. No one ever said it was.

I know I had a hell of alot of fun with Tecmo Bowl and it only had 4 plays. Defense only had 4 plays to pick as well. It isn't about the number of plays. It's about the competition.

Some people just aren't ever going to be happy until they are on top.

Any way Bort does it, 31 out of 32 teams aren't going to be 100% happy.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Nothing wrong with someone running the same play over and over again imo (offense or defense).


Certainly nothing wrong for it, except that any decent offense/defense compared to their opponents would exploit the daylights out of the other team. Look at the Oakland Raiders, of course.

Not only this, it's a design flaw in the SIM.

Thanks for being constructive. NOT.



People used to bitch that they couldn't call specific plays and now people bitch that they can. I'm fine with either way.

Bort makes the rules, and I play by them - whatever they are.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 01:56:43
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

The game isn't done yet. No one ever said it was.

I know I had a hell of alot of fun with Tecmo Bowl and it only had 4 plays. Defense only had 4 plays to pick as well. It isn't about the number of plays. It's about the competition.

Some people just aren't ever going to be happy until they are on top.

Any way Bort does it, 31 out of 32 teams aren't going to be 100% happy.


Temco Bowl was also designed to run on a system with the processing power of my wristwatch. I hope things have advanced since then, and it certainly isn't processing power that's holding Bort back.

And I'd be 100% happy losing in a complicated and robust sim. Winning all the time is no fun.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Temco Bowl was also designed to run on a system with the processing power of my wristwatch. I hope things have advanced since then, and it certainly isn't processing power that's holding Bort back.

And I'd be 100% happy losing in a complicated and robust sim. Winning all the time is no fun.


Thank you. Pretty much hits the nail on the head.
 
Link
 
lol @ you 2 agreeing with each other over and over.


Listen-

EVERYONE agrees on the issue - the game needs to keep improving.

The only thing that is in question is the TIMING.

This game (and each one of these plays) is ALOT MORE COMPLICATED than you guys think it is. You just don't program this shit in 5 minutes, take 15 minutes to test it, then put it in the game 20 minutes later.

Bort is doing all this BY HIMSELF! Have either of you ever wrote a program before? Do you have any idea that this is no small feat?

Give the man some time. He knows what needs "improved".

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 02:23:41
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.