User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Teams Attempting to Exploit the System
Page:
 
GoVikings16
offline
Link
 
I don't know what needs to be done, but SOMETHING needs to be done. My team (well the only team I care about) has never been faced with it, and I just feel that it is unfair. This is a very rough suggestion, but here is a start.



If a team runs the same play 3 out of 4 times - 25% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 6 out of 8 times - 50% boost to the defense
If a team runs the same play 9 out of 12 times - 75% boost to the defense...

Any time a team runs a play 5 times in a row, the defense get an automatic 15% boost for the rest of the game.



Thoughts? Suggestions?
 
Falseelk
offline
Link
 
Exploit the system by running the same play over and over you mean?
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Exploits are the name of the game. Either it gets fixed or the song remains the same...
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
LOVE the basic premise, and we've talked about it at some length. I'm not as much a numbers guy, so I'm a bit limited as to what would achieve the desired effect: blanketing a team that runs the same plays over and over again. A sliding scale might work better, with a raise in defensive boost every time a team runs that same play.

It incorporates RL principles, as well. Having dabbled on defense myself, if I see a team run the same play over and over, I'm pinning my ears back and charging through my assigned gap like a steam engine. The more they run it, the more confident I am in hitting my gap and attacking the ball-carrier.

This also has a GOOD, unintended consequence: setting up play-action passes (as the pass mimics a common run, of course). That is, if Bort adds these plays, and he should, because any level of football from middle-school up runs a play action.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Falseelk
Exploit the system by running the same play over and over you mean?


Yes.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
I like the idea....
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Though I think you're on to something, those percentages are WAY too high. Perhaps when a play is run back-back the defense recieves a 10% boost (on that play) mimicing some sort of play recognition.

If a play is run 5 times in a drive, the defense recieves a 5% boost. Something like that just to give a little edge. I mean an offense is certainly going to take consistent yards if they can get them even if the defense knows it's coming. It's kind of like on 3rd and inches you know the ball is going up the gut, as does the defense. Doesn't mean the offense won't get those yards, but the defense has some sort of an edge as compared to a run up the gut on 1st and 10.
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Teams running the same play over and over are the EASIEST teams to game plan for - whats the problem?

If my guys properly places aren't good enough to stop the same play over and over - maybe I need to get better players......
 
GG
offline
Link
 
+1
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Though I think you're on to something, those percentages are WAY too high. Perhaps when a play is run back-back the defense recieves a 10% boost (on that play) mimicing some sort of play recognition.

If a play is run 5 times in a drive, the defense recieves a 5% boost. Something like that just to give a little edge. I mean an offense is certainly going to take consistent yards if they can get them even if the defense knows it's coming. It's kind of like on 3rd and inches you know the ball is going up the gut, as does the defense. Doesn't mean the offense won't get those yards, but the defense has some sort of an edge as compared to a run up the gut on 1st and 10.


Completely agree with McrBriar here. Those %s are WAY too high and too unrealistic
 
Link
 
not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Yeah the #'s are certainly up to Bort as only he knows and can tweak them but the premise seems excellent. Adds some more depth to the sim.
Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:13:16
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
not a new idea, but a good one.

the %'s are WAAAAAAAAAY too high though.

All the messing around with the chemistry bar only has a total effect of 6% I think. I don't think it should even be 10% to attributes. In fact, it should be limited to VISION increase.

Something like a 1% increase in vision for all defenders each time a play is run sounds like the best way.


Fully agree. It should be a Vision increase only.

If it's a Vision increase only, then the numbers are reasonable (as long as the "boost for the rest of the game" means only against that play).
 
5STAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Teams running the same play over and over are the EASIEST teams to game plan for - whats the problem?

If my guys properly places aren't good enough to stop the same play over and over - maybe I need to get better players......


+1
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
I've never understood this argument - if anything you'd want the computer to adjust your players to get them in a better position - thats called auto adjust.

If you players aren't good enough - why should you get the equivalent of a Steroid cycle of Temp Boosts during a game just because you can't stop a play?

It's crazy - it's like saying because my LOT keeps getting beat by the RDE that each time he beats me I get a boost to my stats to the point I can stop him because he's using the same rush technique every time.

Thats like trying to make Jeff Backus into Anthony Munoz over the course of a game just because he's facing Lawrence Taylor. If you need Anthony Munoz to stop Lawrence Taylor then go sign Munoz before the game.

Last edited Dec 5, 2008 00:19:04
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.