Before anyone starts with it's user error in AI. It's not.
I have inputs for Shotgun 3WR by down and yardage. I even have the WR settings in the input set to 0-4 just for the heck of it even though there are no 4 WR sets.
I have a whole separate input for Shotgun 5WR sets. It has settings for 5-5 WR (yes I can likely fix it by going 4-5 or maybe 0-5 in that setting). Whenever there is a shotgun 5 WR set I have a 3-1-7 D formation set up on the inputs. That's the only formation set to be used vs. shotgun 5 WR.
For first time, in today's game I noticed that in 5WR sets it was throwing out a 4-1-6 (which is what I have set to sometimes use when facing the shotgun 3 WR offensive formations instead) of using the D AI specified setting of 3-1-7.
This manned the MLB against the #5 WR instead of my 5th CB as desired and specifically set-up in the AI.
An example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243592&pbp_id=8539025
Looking at the offense, their 5th WR is actually a TE. Apparently, the sim is counting the actual WRs playing on the field in the formation instead of the offense's actually selected shotgun 5WR formation to arrive at the D AI input choice. So, the sim sees 4WR/1TE and runs the input for shotgun 3 WR (because I do have it set to 0-4 WR, btw. I can fix that to 0-3, but that's not really the point here at all.)
That begs the question of why the D AI settings are keying off the players on the field (4WR/1TE) instead of keying off the actual offensive formation set selected. If an offense goes with shotgun 5 WR formation, the D AI input for shotgun 5 WR should be utilized...always.
I can see plenty of exploits here if someone were to use, say 2 WR/3TE in that formation, then the D AI would key on what? Use a 2 WR D AI set-up like a 4-3/4-2-5 since there are only 2 actual WRs on the field??? What if the offense throws in CBs to play a few WR slots? 1 WR/1TE/3CBs? How badly would that throw off the D AI if it is keying off of players positions in position slots instead of actual formations used?
This is a HUGE D AI bug and needs to be corrected ASAP. No way should the thing be keying off the player positions instead of the actual formation being called when the D AI inputs are set correctly.
I know others have encountered the same thing. The question is why the heck is it coded like this?
I have inputs for Shotgun 3WR by down and yardage. I even have the WR settings in the input set to 0-4 just for the heck of it even though there are no 4 WR sets.
I have a whole separate input for Shotgun 5WR sets. It has settings for 5-5 WR (yes I can likely fix it by going 4-5 or maybe 0-5 in that setting). Whenever there is a shotgun 5 WR set I have a 3-1-7 D formation set up on the inputs. That's the only formation set to be used vs. shotgun 5 WR.
For first time, in today's game I noticed that in 5WR sets it was throwing out a 4-1-6 (which is what I have set to sometimes use when facing the shotgun 3 WR offensive formations instead) of using the D AI specified setting of 3-1-7.
This manned the MLB against the #5 WR instead of my 5th CB as desired and specifically set-up in the AI.
An example:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=243592&pbp_id=8539025
Looking at the offense, their 5th WR is actually a TE. Apparently, the sim is counting the actual WRs playing on the field in the formation instead of the offense's actually selected shotgun 5WR formation to arrive at the D AI input choice. So, the sim sees 4WR/1TE and runs the input for shotgun 3 WR (because I do have it set to 0-4 WR, btw. I can fix that to 0-3, but that's not really the point here at all.)
That begs the question of why the D AI settings are keying off the players on the field (4WR/1TE) instead of keying off the actual offensive formation set selected. If an offense goes with shotgun 5 WR formation, the D AI input for shotgun 5 WR should be utilized...always.
I can see plenty of exploits here if someone were to use, say 2 WR/3TE in that formation, then the D AI would key on what? Use a 2 WR D AI set-up like a 4-3/4-2-5 since there are only 2 actual WRs on the field??? What if the offense throws in CBs to play a few WR slots? 1 WR/1TE/3CBs? How badly would that throw off the D AI if it is keying off of players positions in position slots instead of actual formations used?
This is a HUGE D AI bug and needs to be corrected ASAP. No way should the thing be keying off the player positions instead of the actual formation being called when the D AI inputs are set correctly.
I know others have encountered the same thing. The question is why the heck is it coded like this?
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 20:05:09






























