User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #2 > Official SA AA2 Pro Bowl Voting
Page:
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Ok this is how this is going down. I will begin taking nominations after week 13 (Dec. 6) so not yet lol.

1. I will be taking 7 (or less if you choose) nominations from each team and will compile two lists (Alpha & Zeta) using them. INCLUDE CONFERENCE NAME IN PM.

I ask that you do not just nominate players in star positions (i.e. QB, HB, WR) but also those underrated positions like the O-line, DT/NT, etc. INCLUDE PLAYER POSITION IN PM.

You are welcome to include special team players, but I will only include P, K, KR, and PR. Sorry to the rest but I don't want to have too much work.

2. I will post the nominations in organized fashion after week 16 (Dec. 12). Each team will discuss and vote for each position in their forums (or the owner by himself), send them to me, and I will add everything up. You CANNOT vote for players on your team. I'll try to get the final tally up before the championship. Key word: TRY. No guarantees = ]

Here's some examples to help explain:

Nominations

Subject: Peru Piranha Alpha Nominations
Body:
QB Kurt Warner
WR Larry Fitzgerald (my WR!)
WR Anquan Boldin
DT Darnell Dockett
SS Adrian Wilson
DE Bertrand Berry
PR Steve Breaston

*Just an example lol I know more players on the Cards than any other so there


OK then later on you will get another PM from me looking like this:

Subject: SA AA2 All-Star Voting
Body:
OK since you are a Zeta team you will be voting for the Zeta Conference. Here are the nominations:

QB
X

HB
X

WR
X

etc.

The only rule is that you cannot vote for your own players. Please post this ballot in your forum and select players for each position. Here is what I am looking for:

2 QBs
2 HBs
2 FBs
3 WRs
2 TEs
3 OTs
2 Cs
3 Gs
etc.

*Numbers are not official. Up for debate if anyone disagrees with this.


That's just about it. Stay tuned. No need to keep up with this on the forum if you are an owner, I will PM you all the way through with reminders.


This is what the roster should look like:
3 QB
4 HB
2 FB
7 WR
3 TE
4 G,OT
2 C

2 DT, NT
4 DE
7 LB
7 CB
2 SS, FS

2 P, K, KR, PR
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 15:30:05
 
BadAssMonroe
offline
Link
 
cant vote for your own players?? that = whack ...sorry. Not saying i'm gonna vote every position but I might feel that one of my players is better than the rest and I'm not gonna vote for just some guy thats not on my team just to vote and my player that I feel is the best loses out on a vote because I cant vote for him? that = whack.
 
packers0491
offline
Link
 
Niko Ryan for MVP!!

BULLSEYE!!!
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadAssMonroe
cant vote for your own players?? that = whack ...sorry. Not saying i'm gonna vote every position but I might feel that one of my players is better than the rest and I'm not gonna vote for just some guy thats not on my team just to vote and my player that I feel is the best loses out on a vote because I cant vote for him? that = whack.


If your players are really pro-bowl material then they should have no problem getting voted in.

I'll listen to arguments about this. I originally made it so there was a limit for how many of your own players you could vote for, but I changed it because many times the votes will be biased. If you are voting only for players on other teams there is hardly any (if any) bias, which would make results more accurate. And I don't want to have a bunch of players with one votes that only got that vote from their own team, so I decided this was best. You can try and convince me though. I might agree, but probably would limit everyone to only 2 or 3 own votes.
Last edited Dec 3, 2008 22:24:12
 
Chg91
offline
Link
 
I approve of the Card love.
 
BadAssMonroe
offline
Link
 
Not much to argue about. Doesn't make sense that we go and nominate players but then can't support them in the voting process. It's only natural that some players will only get 1 vote. It happens.
 
kmart
Mod
offline
Link
 
What is the last day to nominate/vote?
Last edited Dec 3, 2008 22:49:02
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
I'm with Monroe unless there's some stipulations made. For instance, if your team does not vote, then it cannot have any players elected to the pro bowl. This is because voting is actually making it tougher for your own players to get into the pro bowl because you're voting for other teams players under the hope that they do the same in return. You've already limited the amount of nominations per team to a somewhat low number. Hell, just by using the statistics, 5 teams have more than 7 players that are deserving of nominations in Alpha alone. That's almost half the Conference. Nazca had 13. They have to whittle that down to 7? I've actually seen leagues do nominations based on order of finish. I.e. #1 team gets 16 noms, #2 team gets 15, etc. You could do something similar or not at all, but to limit the nominations AND you still can't vote for your guys, seems like overkill.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kmart
What is the last day to nominate/vote?


Nominations begin the 8th and end the after the season, probably the 12th or 13th. Voting will go on during the playoffs and I hope to have the results before the championship game but it might depend on how quickly everyone votes.

Originally posted by BadAssMonroe
Not much to argue about. Doesn't make sense that we go and nominate players but then can't support them in the voting process. It's only natural that some players will only get 1 vote. It happens.


OK I have been convinced by Mathias. The roster will be fairly large so voting for some of your players would fit. There will definitely be a limit though. I could just leave it at 7 since that's the # of nominations or I could lower it. What do you guys think?

Originally posted by GMathiasf
I'm with Monroe unless there's some stipulations made. For instance, if your team does not vote, then it cannot have any players elected to the pro bowl. This is because voting is actually making it tougher for your own players to get into the pro bowl because you're voting for other teams players under the hope that they do the same in return. You've already limited the amount of nominations per team to a somewhat low number. Hell, just by using the statistics, 5 teams have more than 7 players that are deserving of nominations in Alpha alone. That's almost half the Conference. Nazca had 13. They have to whittle that down to 7? I've actually seen leagues do nominations based on order of finish. I.e. #1 team gets 16 noms, #2 team gets 15, etc. You could do something similar or not at all, but to limit the nominations AND you still can't vote for your guys, seems like overkill.


Why did you not suggest this before? Too late now. Besides, I think that might be bad in a way because the top few teams would get a large % of nominations and wouldn't get anyone else a great shot. 7 nominations seems pretty good to me.
 
tntitans21399
offline
Link
 
I think it is a good idea. I get not letting you vote for your players then makes it a little more even, because if your team is very active on the forums and they vote for their players then they will get more votes then a player a team that isn't as active but has a good player. Like us, I post and reply and the owner post some, but that's about it on our team. I think we have 3 pro bowl type players (2 for sore), not going to name them yet because we are suppose to wait. But I think ass a group we can vote on the best players and if your player is really Pro Bowl caliber then he will get votes.
 
BadAssMonroe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tntitans21399
I think it is a good idea. I get not letting you vote for your players then makes it a little more even, because if your team is very active on the forums and they vote for their players then they will get more votes then a player a team that isn't as active but has a good player. Like us, I post and reply and the owner post some, but that's about it on our team. I think we have 3 pro bowl type players (2 for sore), not going to name them yet because we are suppose to wait. But I think ass a group we can vote on the best players and if your player is really Pro Bowl caliber then he will get votes.


That's life though. If your team is active and posts then you're gonna get some votes. If your team isn't active and won't support your player then tough.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Well, judging by the OP, we're only getting one vote per team.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Forget it you can vote for your own teammates...as many as you want (obviously no more than 7). I added what I hope to be the Pro Bowl roster #s. First, I'll need enough nominations and enough voting but I think Ill get it.

Originally posted by bigpimpin123

This is what the roster should look like:
3 QB
4 HB
2 FB
7 WR
3 TE
4 G,OT
2 C

2 DT, NT
4 DE
7 LB
7 CB
2 SS, FS

2 P, K, KR, PR


27 Offense - 28 Defense - 8 Special Teams
Last edited Dec 4, 2008 15:01:07
 
BadAssMonroe
offline
Link
 
ok so owners just sit back and wait for a pm right? just checkin
 
bluprintkok
offline
Link
 
now is this just open to gm's and owners? or can anyone in the league participate in the nomination/ voting process.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.