User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
I'm having a problem with the rotation on a couple of my DEs. DE #1 and DE #3 are on the exact same rotation and DE #2 and DE #$. DE's 1 and 3 are in the RDE spot and DEs 2 and 4 are in the LDE spot. Both DE #3 and #4 are both on KO teams and both have a split with the starters on a 90/95 breath rotation.

DE#1 averages 45.3 plays per game
DE #3 averages 29.9 plays per game

DE #2 averages 51 plays per game
DE #4 averages 24.2 plays per game

DE #4 has worked on their build to get the start, and this last game got only 19 plays to the (now backup) DE #2s 40 plays. I had forgotten to take DE #4 off KO teams to boot.

I thought it may be their Stamina, but their stamina is like this

DE #3 has the most stamina
DE #1 has 1 less than #3
DE #4 has 2 less than #3
DE #2 has 3 less than #3

So not a big difference, specially because #3 is the backup to #1 and #4 has more than the backup #2.

I asked in our team forum and somebody mentions their Str can attribute to their breath and mess up the rotation. Except...

DE #4 has the most strength
DE #2 has 1 less than #4
DE #3 has 3 less than #4
DE #1 has 5 less than #4

So, how come the strongest DE with the most stamina on that side of the line, is getting so few plays when they are starting?
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Nobody knows? Am I the only one thats experiencing this?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Are the DE's getting less plays also in the ST's rotation?

Bort said he was 'ramping up' energy costs as the season went on to simulate wear and tear and encourage people to have solid backups.

My thinking though is that this ramping up is affecting special teams players especially hard as it already costs too much energy to play special teams.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
They are on the exact same rotation on STs too. Out at 35 in at 50. They have the exact same rotation everywhere they get in on the field. Basically I like to keep my players fresh so for the most part I try to get players with about the same builds and levels. Most of my team is on a tight rotation, other than the 1 DE averaging 24 plays per game and the kicker and punter, the rest of the team is 29+.

I mean, DE #3 and #4 are mirrored in rotation everywhere and their attributes are almost the exact same, yet one is getting more plays than the other.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Do you only have 10 players on the ST DC? If not, one could be getting sub'd out in ST, allowing more plays in defense...just a thought...
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I did only put 10 players on STs. But, even if DE #4 was pulled off STs, how come they only got 19 plays, while their backup got 40 plays and is not on STs?

Unless you're saying that the backup is getting subbed into STs while the starter is getting subbed out. Even still, why would the starter get so few plays on defense then and the backup so much more, when the backup on the other side of the line is getting fewer plays than the starter, while on the same rotation. Starter is also not in on STs.

I'm cofused as hell.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
A little confused....

If you only have 10 guys on the ST DC, then there is no sub out, so the numbers there mean nothing...

Whichever guys are on ST, should get fewer plays overall, based on the ST costing more energy. Based on your stamina/strength descriptions, they should all be similar, but a play on ST probably costs 3+ plays on defense (WAG).

If you're saying the guy playing ST is getting MORE snaps, then something is screwed up somewhere...suggest going through the pbp to see where your starter/backups are subbing in/out differently from LDE/RDE positions.

Try putting both LDE (or RDE) on ST and see if the # plays equalizes on both sides...

Another thought is the substitution over-rides...forcing starters/backups into the game based on score/down could change the rotation...not sure if this would affect your situation or not...
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
It had to have had something to do with STs. I pulled DE#4 off STs and they got 41 plays this time to DE #3 who got 32.

DE #1 is Dropping DaHammer as LDE #1 on depth chart and averages 45.3 plays per game
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=620258

who splits time on a 90/95 rotation with DE #3 Chris Ramsden as LDE #2 on the depth chart and on KO STs and averages 29.9 plays per game
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=28577

Those 2, are fine.


These are where the problems are.

DE #2 is Elmo Blatch as RDE #1 on the depth chart and averages 51 plays per game
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=621163

who splits time on a 90/95 rotation with DE #4 BIG THUD as RDE #2 on the depth chart and on KO STs and averages 24.4 plays per game
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=622873


Big Thud is the strongest out of all 4 and has the most stamina at the RDE position and has only 2 less stamina than the backup at the LDE position.



The question was...why was RDE BIG THUD getting so many fewer plays that LDE Chris Ramsden, when they are on the exact same rotation and both on the exact same STs?

I just cant buy that 2 points of stamina than Chris Ramsden is going to limit BIG THUD to 19 plays while Elmo Blatch gets 41 plays who has 1 point of Stamina less than Big Thud.
Last edited Dec 3, 2008 23:16:41
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Ok, its broken again. My starters are getting less plays than my backups again. One starter only got 13 plays at LB while her backup got 34 plays. Neither of them are on STs and their rotation is 90/95. This happened to her the last 2 games, last game she only had 18 plays. She was doing fine all season and all of a sudden, its not letting her play. She was averaging over 40 plays per game.

The game is sexist. Both the DE with the rotation issue and the LB with the rotation issue are women on my team.

BTW, there was no change in the last 2 games to cause this. In fact, no changes in the last 5-6 games at that position.

Anybody have any ideas as to why this is happening? Before you answer stamina or rotation or STs. I thought it was the STs thing, but apparently its not and the starters staminas are higher than the backups.
Last edited Dec 9, 2008 22:57:57
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
you said #3 and #4 are on special teams and #1 and #2 are not?

do you notice the guys on spec teams are the ones not getting the plays?


A special teams play takes up about the same amount of stamina as 4 regular plays, so if they have 10 special teams plays during a day they are as tired as having 40... so you have to subtract about 30 plays less total under the guy he is sharing time with.

seems like you are averaging them being on 8-9 special teams plays, so they are missing out on the extra snaps. THIS is why you have unbalanced numbers.

 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai
you said #3 and #4 are on special teams and #1 and #2 are not?

do you notice the guys on spec teams are the ones not getting the plays?


A special teams play takes up about the same amount of stamina as 4 regular plays, so if they have 10 special teams plays during a day they are as tired as having 40... so you have to subtract about 30 plays less total under the guy he is sharing time with.

seems like you are averaging them being on 8-9 special teams plays, so they are missing out on the extra snaps. THIS is why you have unbalanced numbers.



it might be 3 plays, all i know is special teams DRAINS energy bad and anyone who is on them is going to be REAL tired.
 
California
knows how to party
offline
Link
 
skills also drain energy. high strength/speed/agility does this, making tackles does this, getting pancaked, etc. Basically each play has a unique drain for each player based upon build and play result so... good luck figuring that out.
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Ok, so why does the starter have so many less plays when they arent on STs and dont even have 1 tackle, or anything? Benched for sucking?

I know I made it more confusing labeling the DEs 1-4.

Basically, I wanted to know why one guy was averaging so many plays less than the other guy on the opposite side of the line when they are both on STs and the exact same rotation with their starters. But the one getting less plays has better stamina and str than the other guy on the other side of the line. I didnt know about the agility, but hers was better too.

I just dont get it.

It was fine for 2 and a half seasons. Now all of a sudden I'm having rotation issues and players not getting plays even when they are the starter and not on STs.
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
I've been seeing this on a couple of teams...

Starters who with no changes have been getting less play time..and it doesn't hit all the players...so I'm not sure what it is.
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thebigcali
skills also drain energy. high strength/speed/agility does this, making tackles does this, getting pancaked, etc. Basically each play has a unique drain for each player based upon build and play result so... good luck figuring that out.


That's true...but watching your player's play count over the course of a season, you get an idea of what's expected...when you suddenly have a 30-50% change in that without adjusting settings against a variety of teams including cupcakes...something is wrong. Like I said, the weird part of it, is I don't see a consistency in the positions it affects.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.