User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
HANDSaLIVE
offline
Link
 
I lost a game recently where the team ran this play every pass play(33times, 30completions). I personally to help prove that this play is too powerful ran it every pass play two games ago(62/68, 490yards, 9tds). I ran it 5times my last game and scored 2tds with it. Something is wrong with this play. People keep saying that you have to run a 3-1-7 to stop it. If you have to stack 4cb's on the line to stop one dude on a short yardage pass then that's pretty obvious something isn't right. I could understand if the WR was so good he's breaking all these tackles but that's not what's happening. The CB's either freeze or they all run into the blocker and get stuck. Here's a prime example and I have dozens just like this:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=252552&pbp_id=6319498
The blocker on that play has 8blocking and 17strength. All 3cb's on that side have vision of 44+. This play needs to be fixed or thrown out. Because my league is turning into who can run this play the best as opposed to which team is better.


I also have sent SUPPORT 4PM's and have received no response concerning this issue. I'm not spending anymore money on GLB until this and other money plays are addressed.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 03:12:15
 
Link
 
There are plenty of times when this happens too:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=211362&pbp_id=6742525 (0 yards)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=211362&pbp_id=6744250 (incomplete)

The WR doing the blocking has blocking and strength over 30, yet still couldn't block a 25 strength CB for an instant?

I don't think vision is the CB's problem (you said your guy has 44). I think the CB's need more speed and agility to get around the block instead of through it. Plus, if a 17 strength WR is blocking them, then the CB's probably also need more STRENGTH if not speed/agility.

Why don't you switch up the equipment and run a scrimmage game to try to find what defenses work well against that play?


What defenses have you tried? Just because you put a 3-1-7 on the field doesn't mean it can magically stop that play.

Do your homework before you call for a nerf. Look at upper leagues and see how they are stopping it. Go to the most elite teams and watch their defenses stop it.

I think people call on Bort to give them the answers for their offensive and defensive problems too early. Supposedly the off tackle run was too powerful, then it was a couple other runs. Then the goal line defense was too powerful, then people gradually found the plays and defenses to stop those "exploits" and aren't complaining any more.

Look around a little more before you quit. I know you didn't try everything.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 03:48:36
 
UnsaidPlayer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
There are plenty of times when this happens too:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=211362&pbp_id=6742525 (0 yards)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=211362&pbp_id=6744250 (incomplete)

The WR doing the blocking has blocking and strength over 30, yet still couldn't block a 25 strength CB for an instant?

I don't think vision is the CB's problem (you said your guy has 44). I think the CB's need more speed and agility to get around the block instead of through it. Plus, if a 17 strength WR is blocking them, then the CB's probably also need more STRENGTH if not speed/agility.

Why don't you switch up the equipment and run a scrimmage game to try to find what defenses work well against that play?


What defenses have you tried? Just because you put a 3-1-7 on the field doesn't mean it can magically stop that play.

Do your homework before you call for a nerf. Look at upper leagues and see how they are stopping it. Go to the most elite teams and watch their defenses stop it.

I think people call on Bort to give them the answers for their offensive and defensive problems too early. Supposedly the off tackle run was too powerful, then it was a couple other runs. Then the goal line defense was too powerful, then people gradually found the plays and defenses to stop those "exploits" and aren't complaining any more.

Look around a little more before you quit. I know you didn't try everything.


Bump
 
maitey
offline
Link
 
Look its a good play, but obviously its too out of whack or unbalanced when teams run this play over and over again. Obviously its being exploited, at the detriment to the game. Just like any MMO game, people find an exploit and use it over and over and over until it gets fixed.

Yes you can stop the WR screen but it leaves you very vulnerable to other plays etc. This SINGLE play is clearly being exploited, bottom line.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maitey
Look its a good play, but obviously its too out of whack or unbalanced when teams run this play over and over again. Obviously its being exploited, at the detriment to the game. Just like any MMO game, people find an exploit and use it over and over and over until it gets fixed.


That's actually how games get improved. Some people find something that works really well and use it a lot, and some others try to find what stops it, and the metagame moves along.

Still too early to answer if this is a true overpowered play or something that will simply shift the metagame. I think, though, that the play trades on the fact that run blocking is too good right now. What this means is that most DCs feel they need to sell out to run stop - which leaves the perimeter wide open.

If sweep/pitches worked more smoothly (and there were more truly fast HBs), you'd see those type of run plays violating the plethora of inside run blitzes rampant in the game, (which is basically what the WR screen is exposing).
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 08:38:51
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
I should say that inside run blocking is too good. Overall, Str-based gap-plugging defensive linemen simply don't work well enough right now imo.
 
damnedin82
offline
Link
 
Hey, back in the day the Green Bay Packers ran the sweep over, and over again, because nobody could stop it. Think the NFL Commissioner called Vince Lombardi, and asked him to chill out??????????


 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by damnedin82
Hey, back in the day the Green Bay Packers ran the sweep over, and over again, because nobody could stop it. Think the NFL Commissioner called Vince Lombardi, and asked him to chill out??????????




Kind of funny you compare a real NFL game where the D can adjust on the fly as needed to a MMO sim where you can not. But hey whatever fantasies float your boat.
 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
People should not have to adjust their builds for one play.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supersoul
People should not have to adjust their builds for one play.


No, but DCs may have to accept that one build is not a catch all in the secondary. Perhaps CB#3 needs a different build in the defensive scheme.
 
rRedruMm
offline
Link
 
how bout adjusting the D? LOL, just a thought??? jeez.
 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
kurie: you just said, "No, but they do." You agree with me, then say we need different builds.

rRedruMm: do you have a suggestion?
 
Link
 
The play can be stopped. And if you are facing a team that runs it every time they pass, and you still can't stop it, you need a new defensive coordinator.
Last edited Dec 2, 2008 09:05:53
 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
Regardless of the past few posts, it's ridiculous to think one WR can block 2-3 CBs at the same time.
 
Pensfan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Eric the Great of Antarctica
The play can be stopped. And if you are facing a team that runs it every time they pass, and you still can't stop it, you need a new defensive coordinator.


That is not the problem... I can not run that play at all for every game in a row for 3-4 games against gutted/weak teams. Then when it comes time for a good team, completely switch it out and run that single play all game and almost guarantee a win.

Why? Cause dots can't adjust like a real thinking player can. That is the real problem with plays like this.

I can manipulate the situation all I want.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.