User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Too many deflections being caught for completions
Page:
 
Kobra22
offline
Link
 
I'm sure the WR's are all working on the tip drill religiously, but this is getting ridiculous. Only the rarest of deflection actually changes direction- the rest seem to continue into the hands of the WR. It's not realistic, and it's not right. Please address and repair.

I looked for a post on this but didn't see it. Sorry if I missed it.
 
JokersWild
offline
Link
 
EXTREMELY RIDICULOUS is more like it. Unbelievable. How often in a real game do deflections get caught, yet in GLB it seems to be a huge %.

This needs to be addressed quick.
 
Kobra22
offline
Link
 
Thank goodness other people are seeing this- it's getting out of hand and has already cost me enough as it is. Thanks for agreeing.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
It's the season of offense and big plays... what'd you expect?

Season 4 - Strong I Off-Tackle
Season 5 - (Fill in the blank)
Season 6 - High Scoring Offenses and Big Plays
 
Kobra22
offline
Link
 
I guess it worked for Oklahoma last night as well, so then it must be fine for the game! If it was once in awhile I could handle it better. But when it's happening over 6 times a game, it's out of hand.

But I agree with your post about the seasons!
 
Duo
offline
Link
 
Bort fixed it alittle a season or two ago, but its definately back to rear its ugly freaking head unfortunately :-/.
 
Kobra22
offline
Link
 
cost us a touchdown on this play. We still won, so I know the football Gods will be punishing me for complaining, but damn, this is getting out of hand.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=239019&pbp_id=7524107

 
Firewings
offline
Link
 
The dropped passes have gotten a lot better from last season, but I agree these deflections are getting out of hand. I realize that a deflected pass is sometimes caught, but only maybe 1/10 times. Seems like this is happening at least half the time currently. Just frustrating to have a defender in great position, he makes a play on the ball, and then the WR picks it out of the air after the ball has bounced around for several seconds.
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
they say deflections just mean the cb got a hand or touched the ball which is reallistic in nfl standards because not alot of catches are clean
 
Firewings
offline
Link
 
Ugh, not sure what NFL game you're watching, but if a guy gets a hand on a ball its almost never completed. Sure, a WR might have a CB grabbing him and hand-fighting and still make the catch, but if a ball is deflected in real life its not going to be completed most of the time.


This catch bother me, and its even one of my players who got credit for the catch :

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=238397&pbp_id=7507503
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 22:12:30
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
they say deflections just mean the cb got a hand or touched the ball which is reallistic in nfl standards because not alot of catches are clean


Deflections in GLB are a lot more than just clean deflections...watch the sim closely and you start to get the idea (imo, at least).
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
A PD defined by NFL standards is when a CB actually knocks the ball away from a WR, preventing a catch.

A PD defined by GLB standards is just when a CB gets a finger tip on the ball at any point in it's path. He might barely touch it, he might touch it after the WR actually catches it but before full control is made.

I agree that it should really only be called a PD if it gets knocked down, but i dont think it's a bug. PDs in the NFL happen at a much, much lower rate than they do in GLB anyway.
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
This has been bad for me for a long time, please fix it. Batted passes being caught are a rare fluke, not 5+ times a game. Maybe 2 times including all games in the league for that day of games.

Remember people pay money for this game. If you let it get too stupid like this people will stop playing/paying.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Okay, let's take a look at numbers:

Today in the NFL there were 12 games. In those 12 games, there were 88 total PDs. That equates to 7.33 PDs per game, so we'll go ahead and round that down to a nice even 7.

In a sampling of the USA Pro League's top 12 games on their league page, there were 260 PDs. That comes out to 21.6 total PDs per game.

It doesn't take a degree in statistics to see that pass deflections happen at a much higher rate than in the NFL. The NFL only counts a Pass Deflection if the ball is knocked away from a receiver and hits the ground, whereas GLB counts ANY ball a DB gets a piece of as a Pass Deflection.

So let's say that 50% of GLB PDs end up getting caught by a WR, that's still roughly 10 combined PDs per game, which is MORE than the NFL average.

If anything should be changed, it should be that GLB counts a Pass Deflection only if the pass is knocked to the ground.

Yes, it's annoying to see that your CB got 9 PDs in one game and 4 of them ended up getting caught, but keep in mind that your player is getting his hands on the ball WAY more often than a real NFL cornerback would.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Would you rather just have the WR catch the ball with no indication that your CB was even there? I think it's comforting to know your guy was there and making a play for the ball...sometimes the WR just makes the catch.

I'd say my CBs get a hand on 50% of the balls that come their way...if the WR had no chance to catch those, completion percentages would be miserable and the game would not be fun.

You can't make a change to one thing without considering the overall game balance.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.