User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
I've been thinking about making an All-Pro team for you guys. Before I decide, I got a couple Qs. Is there someone else that already does this? I don't want to if there is someone else. Also of great importance, do you think teams would participate in nominating players for every position? Cuz I'll need the help of plenty of league members or the voting will be lopsided.

I'm not saying I will do it quite yet, just getting a sense of what kind of work I'll have to put in. It shouldn't be too difficult, but who knows. Obviously this would be my first time.
 
BadAssMonroe
offline
Link
 
Now see if I like this idea but of course if I made this thread it would be a 'look at me' thread so ...yah...
 
xp0
offline
Link
 
Obviously I would handle the Masons' involvement in voting/nominating.

No one else has done an All-Pro team for SA AA#2 before, so it would be a welcome addition I believe.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BadAssMonroe
Now see if I like this idea but of course if I made this thread it would be a 'look at me' thread so ...yah...


uhh what? ok...
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
It would be good to have... But I don't think anyone should cast their votes until say after week 13 or 14. We are still pretty early in the season IMHO.

But yeah, it would be great to see an All Pro team voted on.
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
I know it's early but I'm not really starting it now...just seeing what everyone thinks. And do you think a Pro Bowl or All-Pro team be better? Pro Bowl would probably be harder work but teams would be familiar with who they pick since it's an Alpha and Zeta squad
 
rbfloyd
offline
Link
 
that would be cool.
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
I was actually planning on doing this as the season wound down, but would love to have someone to work with if you'd like to share the workload. I was personally thinking of doing nominations chosen by me and allowing anyone who would like to vote, to vote. I could even set up on online polls as those seem to get more participation for whatever reason. I think it's only fair to do an Alpha AND Zeta squad as comparing across Conferences is pretty much impossible because of the differences in schedule and sometimes one Conference will dominate the voting. I also like to include at least one player from every team (with possible exceptions for the CPU/gutted teams). So bigpimpin, would you like to collaborate on this?
 
rbfloyd
offline
Link
 
i would have to disagree with one player from each team.
This is not the baseball all-star game.
This is the All-Pro team, which in the NFL is just the best players.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
To make it easier and get rid of biased/tedious voting/tallying, use this script: Pro Bowl Score: http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/35527

adds justafish2002's Pro Bowl scores to full player stats and team leaders pages

Each player gets a hard-score tabulated based on their seasons performance...

Just a suggestion, of course. If you all want to do it by hand then go for it.
 
tntitans21399
offline
Link
 
I say each team can put 3-5 players out their, and then we can decide on how they did and how they look on the leader boards. Because some guy playing a team like the Golden Eagles is going to rack up a lot of stats in just 1 game, but might not be that great in the rest of the games. Everyone puts their players out their, and then we can copy all the players and start a new post, where each person replies with the copied players but puts a * next to his vote. And each person can only vote for 1 player at each position. Then we see who has the most * next to their name.
 
dirkthe1
offline
Link
 
gold stars!!
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbfloyd
i would have to disagree with one player from each team.
This is not the baseball all-star game.
This is the All-Pro team, which in the NFL is just the best players.


and this isn't the NFL, this is GLB. I'd rather have players from each team to get participation from ALL teams than run an elitist team filled with all players from the top teams. I believe the forums are about trying to maximize participation rather than accuracy in pro-bowl voting. But again, that's my opinion and you're welcome to your own as well.

irt Toriq, I personally don't like to rely solely on stats like that script does, but if someone wants to set it up and to it as well, they are more than welcome.
 
brigmar
offline
Link
 
The script is a great way to generate a shortlist, but I wouldn't go further than that with it.
 
rbfloyd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by rbfloyd

i would have to disagree with one player from each team.
This is not the baseball all-star game.
This is the All-Pro team, which in the NFL is just the best players.


and this isn't the NFL, this is GLB. I'd rather have players from each team to get participation from ALL teams than run an elitist team filled with all players from the top teams. I believe the forums are about trying to maximize participation rather than accuracy in pro-bowl voting. But again, that's my opinion and you're welcome to your own as well.

irt Toriq, I personally don't like to rely solely on stats like that script does, but if someone wants to set it up and to it as well, they are more than welcome.


I see both sides.
Maybe it should be called Pro-Bowl team.

and both our teams should get plenty of players!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.