User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Linked attributes, new attributes - follow up to Flames54 suggestion on reworking attributes
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
this was inspired by Flames54 suggestion on re-doing attributes - some of this is new thinking but most of it itsn't - consider this a repackaging of some ideas I've seen that I really like, in addition to some of my own.

Here are my suggestions for existing attributes one-by-one:

Strengh - change this to upper body strength and lower body strength as has been suggested elsewhere

Speed - change this to a new attribute called "running", I'll explain more later

agility - revert this to ability to change direction quickly, as GLB originally built

jumping - remains the same, but actual ability to jump will depend on this attribute, player weight, lower body strength, and agility.

stamina - same

vision - same, but it should go up automatically every level up for every player.

confidence - this attribute shouldn't be changeable with skill points. It should go up based on # of games played, started, playoff games played, big plays, etc, etc. Might actually drop in blowouts, etc. Confidence is important, and could be used as a means to prevent slow build teams (confidence would be destroyed). This definately needs further discussion, though.

Blocking - change to run blocking technique and pass blocking technique. Actual performance would be based in part on strength and agility, with lower body strength being especially required for run blocking, upper body and lower body for pass blocking.

tackling - keep it basically the same, although it could be split into wrap up tackling and power tackling. Wrap up tackling would work even better with a lot of agility, power tackling would work better with lots of strength and/or speed

throwing - keep it basically the same

catching - keep it basically the same

carrying - I'd want to hear opinions on this one

kicking and punting - separate skills for kicking for distance and kicking for accuracy?

Now, onto some new stuff:

1. definately base soft caps on player weight. A 300 pound frame grows muscle/strength more easily than a 180 pound frame. Speed gets the same treatment. A 300 pounder might hit the running soft cap at 42.



2. Agility could get the same treatment. And, there would be a new attribute for acceleration.

3. Speed would be a complex formula - based on the "running" attribute I mention above, but also a new attribute for acceleration, but also bring lower body strength and weight into the equation. The fastest speed build would come from maximum running, acceleration, lower body strength (with a smaller speed boost based on upper body strength and agility. Strength would be particularly important for the first five yards. But remember, the lower the player's weight, the easier it is to get fast due to higher soft caps for running and acceleration.

4. also in the speed area, the lower a players weight, the less strength they need to go really fast. The higher a players weight, the more strength they need to go fast.

5. repackage the SAs - make it a buffet where players can have up to "x" number of SAs. This is critical to avoiding cookie cutters. But, if some SAs would be too strong like this, we could go to the chinese restaurant approach - choose any four from column A, any three from column B, etc.


I think this approach would do several things:

1. greatly reduce the effectiveness of one-dimensional builds, mainly through greater recognition that certain acts on the football field require a number of different physical attributes and football skills to be executed.

2. recognize that small guys get faster easier than big guys, and that big guys get stronger easier than small guys. Its physics.

3. reduce cookie cutters (perhaps)

Now, I suspect this would require players to have more skill points available to them to work - but hey, its fun to spread around points, and anything that makes the game more fun for users is a good thing.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
<3 this idea.

Would require that complete wipe flames was talking about (Since respec isn't really an option) but im 100% Ok with that
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 14:53:47
 
Link
 
+1, for carrying i'd say split it between not fumbling and breakin tackles
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by imwatchingespn
+1, for carrying i'd say split it between not fumbling and breakin tackles


Player Tactic would be better...
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
i disagree with agility. that is why some big guys have speed. because they have good acceleration and footwork.
 
catabowl
offline
Link
 
I like these ideas... but lets not hope for all of them at once.

I'd be up for splitting up Strength and blocking.

Lower and Uppper sounds good for strength

Run Blocking and Pass blocking for Lineman sound good


How about for D-Line: Make Strength be like: Upperbody is for reducing push back and Lowerbody helps reduce getting pancaked

And blocking for D-Line should impact how they shed blocks.

Elusive: Better chance of spinning off a tackle to get to the QB sooner: Higher pancake chance though
Power: Better chance of driving Tackle into backfield: High chance the QB makes a "hurried" pass

Balanced: Mix of both

Just suggesstions at this point
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Confidence is a sticky issue - because while it is an individual attribute it's derivative (Morale) is mostly influenced by things outside of the individuals control.

You can take Julius Dee and put him on the worst team in GLB - he'll still be a beast (and very confident in his abilities) but his Morale will fall through the floor no matter how many sacks he gets if the team continues to lose (despite his prowess).

There needs to be a better correlation between the teams success/failure and an individuals morale - especially if the player is otherwise dominant in his role game in game out despite the outcome.

Frustrated <> lost morale <> lower performance.

Think Calvin Johnson (Detroit Lions) - if GLB's morale formula were applied to him he'd be the equivalent of the Cowardly Lion by now instead of one of the top 5 threats in all of the NFL at WR.
 
dkmfan
offline
Link
 
IMO there are a few problems with this, but they are largely correctable. The goal of more connected stats should be 1 of the main goals for the game today.

However, I completely disagree on a new acceleration stat. Agility is perfectly acceptable for handling "straight ahead" acceleration especially once the upper/lower body divide is in (an acceleration value would be mix of lower body, agi and weight).

If you're thinking "haha it'll still be easy to make a guy fast" you're right, but that is all you'll be. I'd split vision to "reading" and playbook knowledge. Recievers will need both, playbook for running routes and reading to make catches. And while catching (still a stat, although I'd prefer the term technique) would use "reading" and agility, carrying would require upper body strength. In the end vision, in a seperated form becomes a much more signifigent stat, with Offense more focused on playbook and Defense more concerned with reads. Agility remains a major stat (probably more important than now), but it's handling is very different as it is a minor modifier for most actions.

This could get way too long if fully explained (wait it is already). So I'll end with 1 more thought: SA's should be completely revamped. They should include several football moves. Ball carriers should have SA's for specific actions or techniques (drop the shoulder, stiffarm and such) for example. SA's would become trainable position centric techniques instead of what they are now. Those proc style effects would be more a fame/prestige type of thing.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
All good thoughts, and I definately think that veteran status should open up new columns on the SA chinese menu.
I especially like splitting vision into playbook knowledge and play reading ability.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 17:03:25
 
george
offline
Link
 
Great idea this deserves a sticky
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by george
Great idea this deserves a move


fyp
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by george

Great idea this deserves a move


epic


this
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by george


Great idea this deserves a move


epic


this


No. It involves a wipe, and that needs to be off the table.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1

No. It involves a wipe, and that needs to be off the table.


Why no wipe?
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
I think bort dismissed a lot of ideas too quickly as soon as he read "wipe" - and there were perfectly reasonable suggestions on how to re-do attributes without wiping current teams/players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.