User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > RB decides waiting for block to avoid two yard loss is irrelevant
Page:
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Instead of seeing the pulling RG, the HB thinks he is in punt return mode and tries to find the nearest defender to get tackled, resulting in, at best, no gain.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7283498
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7283992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7284254

These all appear to be the weak pitch from the I formation. Take your pick on what the bug could be:
1] HB doesn't wait for pulling guard to get block
2] Guard doesn't recognize defender that he's supposed to block
3] Pathing on play is borked
4] Speed DEs are still too effective against the run
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 11:52:06
 
slashxtreme
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Wonder what the builds of the players involved are...


 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by slashxtreme
Wonder what the builds of the players involved are...



In regards to the HB:
Speed 78/Agility 63/Vision 48

For the RG:
Speed 45/Agility 50/Vision 48

I figure those are the important attributes for this particular scenario.
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
RG is too slow. What is his speed and agility?

RT can't block agile DEs. What is his speed and agility?
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
RG is too slow. What is his speed and agility?

RT can't block agile DEs. What is his speed and agility?


See above post, as it was there before your reply. Plus, if the RG is too slow, then that still doesn't eliminate possibilities 1, 3, and 4.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 12:08:30
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Originally posted by supgreg

RG is too slow. What is his speed and agility?

RT can't block agile DEs. What is his speed and agility?


See above post, as it was there before your reply. Plus, if the RG is too slow, then that still doesn't eliminate possibilities 1, 3, and 4.


It wasn't there when I was typing, you just clicked submit 1st. Don't be a dick.

Observation:

1)Your offensive line sucks. That's why your guard isn't getting ahead of the RB.
2)Your tackle sucks. That's why he is getting demolished by the DE.
3)You tactics suck. Nobody intelligent runs the weak I weak toss play.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
That lvl 34 RG has less speed than my lvl 26 RG. It's hard to find a fault with a play when his build is simply not very good.

That play is not meant to be a bread and butter type of play, but rather a play to use against a defense that stacks the strong side every time. Against that cover 0, strong shift, it's a decent play call, but you still have to have the personnel to pull it off.
 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
Originally posted by sully

Originally posted by supgreg


RG is too slow. What is his speed and agility?

RT can't block agile DEs. What is his speed and agility?


See above post, as it was there before your reply. Plus, if the RG is too slow, then that still doesn't eliminate possibilities 1, 3, and 4.


It wasn't there when I was typing, you just clicked submit 1st. Don't be a dick.

Observation:

1)Your offensive line sucks. That's why your guard isn't getting ahead of the RB.
2)Your tackle sucks. That's why he is getting demolished by the DE.
3)You tactics suck. Nobody intelligent runs the weak I weak toss play.


Wasn't trying to be an ass. I realize that many people read the first post and ignore anything afterward, happens all the time on forums.

Anyway, I'm glad to see the game is perfectly perfect in every way, there are no such thing as "bugs", and all of the ills of the game can be 100% attributed to build. Let's just get rid of the bugs forum, since the problems with the game are nonexistant, deal?

Oh wait, you just tacitly stated that there is a bug with the Weak I pitch. I guess my post was warranted.

 
sully
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
That lvl 34 RG has less speed than my lvl 26 RG. It's hard to find a fault with a play when his build is simply not very good.

That play is not meant to be a bread and butter type of play, but rather a play to use against a defense that stacks the strong side every time. Against that cover 0, strong shift, it's a decent play call, but you still have to have the personnel to pull it off.


It's not a play that showed up often in my OC's AI. That said, even if the RG is allegedly slow, shouldn't the HB, whose vision is softcapped, be able to wait for his blockers?
 
Mithra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by supgreg
Don't be a dick.

1)Your offensive line sucks.
2)Your tackle sucks.
3)You tactics suck. Nobody intelligent runs the weak I weak toss play.


Says the jerk.

 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
Shouldn't the LT block the DE... ?
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
RB tactics set to power run, instead of combo or elusive?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
That play is poor for your team's O-line...I would pull it. You need a guard with better speed and agility and possibly better at some other things as well, and you need a better LOT (or maybe that RDE was a mack).


edit: Just from the scouting bars I can tell your LOT is not up to that play against a quality RDE. Also, if you increase your HB's agility dramatically he *might* cut inside that RDE...but the real problem is at LOT imo.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 13:46:47
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Originally posted by Forbin

That lvl 34 RG has less speed than my lvl 26 RG. It's hard to find a fault with a play when his build is simply not very good.

That play is not meant to be a bread and butter type of play, but rather a play to use against a defense that stacks the strong side every time. Against that cover 0, strong shift, it's a decent play call, but you still have to have the personnel to pull it off.


It's not a play that showed up often in my OC's AI. That said, even if the RG is allegedly slow, shouldn't the HB, whose vision is softcapped, be able to wait for his blockers?


That depends.


1) Did Bort fix the HB vision issue? Last season, high vision was a detriment for HBs.
2) Is the HB on elusive, combo or power?
3) Honestly, the RG needs 60 speed, and they might get there in time. It would be close, though. It's not a great play, regardless, unless your LOT can make that block himself.
 
bacardi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sully
Instead of seeing the pulling RG, the HB thinks he is in punt return mode and tries to find the nearest defender to get tackled, resulting in, at best, no gain.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7283498
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7283992
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=272237&pbp_id=7284254

These all appear to be the weak pitch from the I formation. Take your pick on what the bug could be:
1] HB doesn't wait for pulling guard to get block
2] Guard doesn't recognize defender that he's supposed to block
3] Pathing on play is borked
4] Speed DEs are still too effective against the run


1] theres nothing to wait for. i've never seen a HB, no matter how high his vision/agility is, take a handoff and just wait. regardless, your HB is getting tackled almost immediately after he gets the handoff.
2] it seems like he recognizes it, but is just too slow to get there.
3] nothings wrong with the pathing. the HB is supposed to go outside, and he does.
4] you need a better LOT

theres no "bug" with that play. it just requires a very fast pulling G and a LOT capable of holding the block on the RDE.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.