User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Jed edit: Bort's comment on this topic: Originally posted by Bort
Don't like it. Creates more of a divide between the haves and have nots.



------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The biggest problem right now is no matter how well laid out the attributes for players are in order to excel at any aspect of the game a player needs to focus on that. This leads to running backs that can't catch or block, receivers that have amazing speed but can't catch and quarterbacks that right now need to be balanced backwards because all of them have 90+ throw and very high vision and strength.

Allow people when they create a player to flag them as a superstar where they gain 8 skill points per level, a 50% bonus from training. The stipulation? you can only create 2 superstars on your account and teams can only have a max of 5. Do you want a star quarterback, tight end and 3 star receivers but risk having a poor defense or do you try and sign superstars at quarterback, receiver, running back and corner and defensive end on defense?

The superstars cost 3x normal flex to create and boost so they are very expensive to maintain which will make some people shy away from them, but with a limit on your account you don't feel the need to have every player a superstar.

The All-Pro simply gains 6sp per level and a 20% training bonus. The All-Pro's are not limited per team or account but do cost twice the normal level to create and maintain in flex. This then makes it very pricey to fill your team with them and it's also possible to have contracts forced to double the regular amount to hold teams hands tight on just how many they can sign.

Obviously the All-Pro is only going to be slightly better than a regular role player but that's how it is in real life, the difference between a very good player and a good or average one is minimal and usually just comes down to being able to leave the guy in on all 3 downs or in the case of a corner rely on him to stop the run as well as defend the pass effectively.

This of course would combine with the GLB wide restructure I posted on the main forums for discussion purposes.

It is my feeling that the game gets saturated because right now nobody can be a true superstar, the only way to be great is to focus your player on certain area's but that leaves him vulnerable in others.

It also opens up some interesting idea's like having a superstar LT that can block almost anybody, but is it worth it to the team to have that guy taking up a superstar spot on their roster? I'd think so, but a lot would not.

Imagine gearing up against a team that has a ton of talent at receiver and quarterback and hoping your star defensive end can blow apart their offensive tackle to slow down the passing attack, or that your star free safety can make a big play or two to turn the tide of the game.
Edited by Jed on Aug 28, 2009 12:52:57
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see the limit on AllPros set at around 5 per agent and maybe 10 per team.

However I like this idea.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 00:38:07
 
DevilDogJAL
offline
Link
 
Interesting idea, and something new. That's a lot of money to spend on a player, but I know that's intended to be the built-in buffer.

Overall, I like it.
 
Link
 
I'm +1ing flames, I dissected this idea, and couldn't find much wrong with it.
 
Thunder39
offline
Link
 
It's good, I like it. How well it's received by cheap bastards who don't buy flex (me) is yet to be seen.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
I dunno... Could bring a little too much unbalance to the game, don't you think?
 
trazer
offline
Link
 
Only thing i can see is you would HAVE to have it obvious on your character that he was an all pro or superstar.

I mean so everyone else could see it. Otherwise people would claim to be one just to get paid more blah blah blah.

Bort would have to put something on the character so people know.

IE

Trazer Adept 31 ($$All-Pro$$) TE

Stile Adept 11 ($$Superstar$$) LB

something like that...no not that specifically, but something that they couldnt just re-create with their names.
 
SportsFrk
offline
Link
 
I love you flames.

At first I was like "wow what a dumb idea" but I was smart enough to read on and see it was a good idea.

Good idea or not, I don't see it happening.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
ehhh I think we'd end up w/ too many people building superstars/all pros, no matter what the cost. Also, the limit on the superstars is only going to spur multi-accounting.
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think it would get out of balance after a while... You'll eventually have more all pros than you will teams that can sign them.
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
It's a good idea I think, but obviously the details would have to be ironed out a little more if it was going to happen (Skill Points given, training bonus percent, cost).

I wouldn't ever create an All Pro or Superstar, and I buy Flex Points (albeit a bit more conservatively than some of the people here).

The thing I can see now (and I find it pretty funny) would be if there were so many of these players (I think a lot of people will bite the bullet and pay the extra) that there aren't enough spaces on teams for them all, and we get an influx of "I can't get my Superstar signed!!!!!!" threads
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
Yeah, I think it would get out of balance after a while... You'll eventually have more all pros than you will teams that can sign them.


Superstars maybe, All-Pros will probably be in the most demand. When you think about it though that's realistic.

The Detroit Lions have a couple superstars but the surrounding talent is god awful.

Look at the Giants and you see again a couple superstars but a ton of all-pros that play well together.

I don't think finding a place to play for superstars will be too tough, maybe if you make a quarterback or a guard that nobody at that time needs or wants but that isn't all that different from now.
 
joeami
offline
Link
 
Awesome idea

Originally posted by christianhall
The thing I can see now (and I find it pretty funny) would be if there were so many of these players (I think a lot of people will bite the bullet and pay the extra) that there aren't enough spaces on teams for them all, and we get an influx of "I can't get my Superstar signed!!!!!!" threads


Possibly the only downside
 
HerrWuff
offline
Link
 
Now what would happen:
I'm going to retire my player, because they cannot be superstars
I will build just one superstar and that's it
If more people do it, the players pool will reduce by 2/3
Most of the players on the market will be superstars, but teams can only sign 5 of them
Teams will have a difficult time finding players
 
John Waylon
offline
Link
 
Actually, the Superstar idea shoots itself in the foot...

Think about it... You create a SS QB. It's going to take 2700 FP to boost, which basic math tells us is about 27 dollars, and that is simply too much for one player in one season. That means the boosting of other players is going to fall by the wayside, because you naturally want to boost your stat maker, and not the FS who gets 3 tackles a game.

But with his SP and training advantage, you can still keep him unboosted, and be on par with other players in your league due to the bonuses.

It could actually lead to the game making LESS money, because like I said, if there is no penalty at all for me not boosting my SS QB at the end of the season, then I am NOT going to be buying 2700 FP to do it, and I am also going to be buying 900 LESS to boost my other players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.