User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Fumbles and INT's (moreso the # of INT's returned for TD's) are out of control in the SIM right now. That is my stance anyways, feel free to agree or disagree. From my other thread:

Originally posted by SCACE
NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

Canada PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.79 fumbles lost per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Africa PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.78 fumbles lost per game

South America PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.75 fumbles lost per game

Western Europe Pro - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.70 fumbles lost per game

Oceania PRO - 1.05 fumbles per game, 0.74 fumbles lost per game

Eastern Europe PRO - 1.04 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

South East Asia PRO - 0.98 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

It is well known that the majority of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from the setting.


Now, to INT's. Again, I'll use the PRO leagues now for the evidence.

NFL - 0.91 interceptions per game, 0.11 returned for TD's

South America PRO - 1.26 interceptions per game, 0.4 returned for TD

South East Asia PRO - 1.17 interceptions per game, 0.30 returned for TD

Eastern Europe PRO - 1.21 interceptions per game, 0.28 returned for TD

USA PRO - 1.18 interceptions per game, 0.28 returned for TD

Western Europe Pro - 1.11 interceptions per game, 0.28 returned for TD

Canada PRO - 1.28 interceptions per game, 0.25 returned for TD

Africa PRO - 1.29 interceptions per game, 0.22 returned for TD

Oceania PRO - 1.13 interceptions per game, 0.20 returned for TD

So far, interceptions appear to be within the norm, but the number of interceptions returned for TD's are way too high, at the very least double the norm, and up to 4-times the norm.

Again, you can agree or disagree, just throwing this stuff out for review.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 08:50:10
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Hope your ignoring CPU teams padding the stats

Seriously though, yes there are too many turnovers, but just looking at stats is not going to help understand why.

I think your thread about Wrap Up Tckling is a good start.

Then I'd look at the effect of Velocity in the Force Fumble equation, as its just perpetuating the Speed kills ethos.

Then I would like to know how many Fumbles happen as a result of the HB Juking into a Defender (Sudden burst of speed increasing the collision impact).

INTs I believe are a symptom of the QB check down issues and poor timing of some plays and lack of options in some pass distance groups.

Its pretty clear that QBs are often making decisions that most would consider too risky, because of the checkdown protocal.

Finally I would like to look at the ST turnovers as that has always been a bit too high across the board.
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 08:20:31
 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
My team has had no problem with INTs, IMO.

4 INTs on the year. (244 attempts)

Fumbles, on the other hand, do seem rather out of control. 3 fumbles by a power back (70 strength, 40 carrying, 202 attempts), 1 lost. 1 fumble by a speed back (52 str, 16 carrying, but only 65 attempts), none lost.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Matt, look at Spicewood's friendly with Samoa if you want to see some turnovers.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Hope your ignoring CPU teams padding the stats

Seriously though, yes there are too many turnovers, but just looking at stats is not going to help understand why.

I think your thread about Wrap Up Tckling is a good start.

Then I'd look at the effect of Velocity in the Force Fumble equation, as its just perpetuating the Speed kills ethos.

Then I would like to know how many Fumbles happen as a result of the HB Juking into a Defender (Sudden burst of speed increasing the collision impact).

INTs I believe are a symptom of the QB check down issues and poor timing of some plays and lack of options in some pass distance groups.

Its pretty clear that QBs are often making decisions that most would consider too risky, because of the checkdown protocal.

Finally I would like to look at the ST turnovers as that has always been a bit too high across the board.


The funny thing is, in most cases, from a quick stat review, the CPU teams aren't the worst off!

Right now, I'm just doing an overall review. I think INT's on their own aren't an issue -- they seem to be relatively in line with real-life. INT's being returned for TD's, however, appear to be way too high. Again, I think this is the "speed kills" argument, as well as the fact that players react immediately when something happens, regardless of what is going on -- defenders will immediately start blocking offensive players as soon as the pick happens.

Personally, I'd like to see strength & tackling abilities have a lot more to do with forcing fumbles than just pure velocity, which is leading to the increased number of CB and Safety caused fumbles, at least that is my best guess based on film review.

I'd like to see defenders have to make a vision check (tougher the farther you are from the interception) before they start blocking the offense...the offense, esp. anyone who was pass blocking, should see the INT right away and be moving to get into position to stop the INT from being returned -- offense receivers should have to pass a vision check before chasing the guy who intercepted the ball.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Matt, look at Spicewood's friendly with Samoa if you want to see some turnovers.


Already did...crazy game. We've had a few crazy ones ourselves up in Oceania PRO.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
My team has had no problem with INTs, IMO.

4 INTs on the year. (244 attempts)

Fumbles, on the other hand, do seem rather out of control. 3 fumbles by a power back (70 strength, 40 carrying, 202 attempts), 1 lost. 1 fumble by a speed back (52 str, 16 carrying, but only 65 attempts), none lost.


1 team isn't enough of a sample. Especially when it is a BBB league with low levels. The issues appear to be magnified at higher levels.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Modok

Matt, look at Spicewood's friendly with Samoa if you want to see some turnovers.


Already did...crazy game. We've had a few crazy ones ourselves up in Oceania PRO.


I got up this morning, saw that game, and was in awe. That is the most TO's returned for TDs in one game that I have ever seen.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
NFL - 10 to 11% chance you'll get an INT return TD in a game

GLB PRO Leagues - 20-40% chance you'll get an INT return TD in a game

Again, not really an issue with the number of INT's, which are relatively in-line given CPU clubs, lower level clubs, etc.

The number returned for TD's is the issue.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Part of the reason for all the returns is the CB's have gotten so fast and agile. If a CB and a WR are battling 1 v 1 on one side of the field, its a good chance an INT will be returned. The WRs do not concentrate on STR nor tackling while the CBs do to a certain extent. Normally, the only players on the field with as much/more speed than corners are the WRs. If they dont make the play, who will?
Last edited Nov 27, 2008 08:57:16
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Now this one I'll agree with. Our QB threw just 5 INTs last season. This season against mostly the same competition he's thrown around 3 INTs a game. Even against teams that are much worse than use he's throwing a lot of INTs.

Granted he does lead the league in TDs and yards, but he did last season as well and only threw the 5.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Part of the reason for more INTS is this cookie cutter all throwing/vision QB everyone is making.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Part of the reason for all the returns is the CB's have gotten so fast and agile. If a CB and a WR are battling 1 v 1 on one side of the field, its a good chance an INT will be returned. The WRs do not concentrate on STR nor tackling while the CBs do to a certain extent. Normally, the only players on the field with as much/more speed than corners are the WRs. If they dont make the play, who will?


I agree, its the "speed kills" philosophy. There should be a chance to return a pick for six, but right now its happening too often. Generally, when you watch a real football game, the CB makes the pick and has to work through traffic to score -- it generally isn't a free pass to the endzone.

I'm not sure what the right fix is, but a vision check for d-linemen to realize there has been a pick while any blockers should see it right away and start getting in position for the tackle would likely be helpful.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Part of the reason for more INTS is this cookie cutter all throwing/vision QB everyone is making.


Those are your primaries -- sure you need other stuff, but if you want to be a pocket passer, you need both of those before anything else. I will agree that most QB's have too little in their secondary stats, esp. in the speed/agility department.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Modok

Part of the reason for all the returns is the CB's have gotten so fast and agile. If a CB and a WR are battling 1 v 1 on one side of the field, its a good chance an INT will be returned. The WRs do not concentrate on STR nor tackling while the CBs do to a certain extent. Normally, the only players on the field with as much/more speed than corners are the WRs. If they dont make the play, who will?


I agree, its the "speed kills" philosophy. There should be a chance to return a pick for six, but right now its happening too often. Generally, when you watch a real football game, the CB makes the pick and has to work through traffic to score -- it generally isn't a free pass to the endzone.

I'm not sure what the right fix is, but a vision check for d-linemen to realize there has been a pick while any blockers should see it right away and start getting in position for the tackle would likely be helpful.


On the Wollgong Hammers (sp?) From Oceania A1 Zeta, I'm pretty sure their CB has 7 pics on the season for 7 TDs
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.