User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Wrap up tackling....still overpowered
Page:
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Any chance we'll ever see a reason to use something other than wrap up?

This isn't a new issue, just wondering if it will ever be addressed.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
I don't get what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against them.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
I don't get what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up tackling is the lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making a tackle and a lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't out of hand vs. even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing that most people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be occurring at a lower rate.
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by mocfam10

I don't get what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up tackling is the lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making a tackle and a lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't out of hand vs. even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing that most people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be occurring at a lower rate.


There are far too many variables in this assumption to validate your claim...

For instance:

-Who is fumbling?
-What is the carrying ability of the fumbler?
-How sure are you that the defense is playing exclusively on Wrap-Up?
-What are the builds of the defenders?
-What is the ratio of missed tackles by those playing on wrap-up compared to fumbles by RBs with low carrying?

And the beat goes on...
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
All of the backs that fumble a lot that I've seen have been elusive backs. Power backs put a lot of points in Str and carrying and obviously fumble less. It's just like in Madden when you spin a ton in one play you're going to fumble.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

Canada PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.79 fumbles lost per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Africa PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.78 fumbles lost per game

South America PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.75 fumbles lost per game

Western Europe Pro - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.70 fumbles lost per game

Oceania PRO - 1.05 fumbles per game, 0.74 fumbles lost per game

Eastern Europe PRO - 1.04 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

South East Asia PRO - 0.98 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

I'll get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from the setting.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 20:17:31
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by mocfam10

I don't get
what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game
while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against
them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up tackling is the
lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making a tackle and a
lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't out of hand vs.
even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing that most
people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be occurring at a
lower rate.


Exactly.

I do know that my team plays exclusively wrap-up on defense, and we cause a fumble a game or thereabouts.

A team playing Wrap-Up should basically never cause a fumble.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by mocfam10


I don't get
what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10 tackles a game
while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no good against
them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up tackling is the
lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making a tackle and a
lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't out of hand vs.
even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing that most
people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be occurring at a
lower rate.


Exactly.

I do know that my team plays exclusively wrap-up on defense, and we cause a fumble a game or thereabouts.

A team playing Wrap-Up should basically never cause a fumble.


I won't as far as saying never, but it should be much less frequent -- that is the trade-off for playing on the wrap up setting and missing less tackles.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GOLee
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by mocfam10


I
don't get what you're saying. I know some backs that break over 10
tackles a game while everyone is set to wrap-up tackling. It doesn't no
good against them.


Sorry, let me clarify. Wrap Up
tackling is the lowest setting, meant to mean a better chance of making
a tackle and a lower chance of causing a fumble. Broken tackles aren't
out of hand vs. even competition. Fumbles however appear to be. Knowing
that most people play on wrap up, one would think fumbles would be
occurring at a lower rate.


There are far too many variables in this assumption to validate your claim...

For instance:

-Who is fumbling?
-What is the carrying ability of the fumbler?
-How sure are you that the defense is playing exclusively on Wrap-Up?
-What are the builds of the defenders?
-What is the ratio of missed tackles by those playing on wrap-up compared to fumbles by RBs with low carrying?

And the beat goes on...



My team's defense plays on Wrap-Up, and we cause about a fumble a game. My team causes way too many fumbles, which should be basically unheard of if playing Wrap-Up. It should be part of the trade off.

Also, some successful low Tackling, low Strength LB's exist in GLB. That shouldn't be possible. I would guess Wrap up is helping them too much.
 
Schaffer05
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Canada PRO - 0.79 fumbles lost per game

I'll get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from the setting.


Although the pro teams are Pro, they're still in the junior stages so comparing them to an NFL team is inaccurate. You're basically saying that the Pro players will not get better as time goes on like the NFL players are. I'd rate the Pro teams on a junior college level right now.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by SCACE

NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Canada PRO - 0.79 fumbles lost per game

I'll
get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority
of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed
tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All
I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on
wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason
to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from
the setting.


Although the pro teams are Pro, they're
still in the junior stages so comparing them to an NFL team is
inaccurate. You're basically saying that the Pro players will not get
better as time goes on like the NFL players are. I'd rate the Pro teams
on a junior college level right now.


Fumbles went up as player levels went up, to the point people thought Bort did something and he hadn't, so the fact that levels aren't yet at their peak suggests that there are even more fumbles than there should be when playing Wrap-Up.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Schaffer05

Originally posted by SCACE


NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Canada PRO - 0.79 fumbles lost per game

I'll
get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority
of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed
tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All
I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on
wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason
to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from
the setting.


Although the pro teams are Pro, they're
still in the junior stages so comparing them to an NFL team is
inaccurate. You're basically saying that the Pro players will not get
better as time goes on like the NFL players are. I'd rate the Pro teams
on a junior college level right now.


Fumbles went up as player levels went up, to the point people thought Bort did something and he hadn't, so the fact that levels aren't yet at their peak suggests that there are even more fumbles than there should be when playing Wrap-Up.


This is the truth. My team both causes too many fumbles and has been victim of the fumble bug. Wrap up is too powerful, its the best of both worlds right now, so why offer a choice?
 
secondeye
offline
Link
 
I think I agree with the OP. Wrap up should cause very minimal fumbles, yet significantly increase the tackle chance, but still respect a players ability to break tackles.

It does make sense. Some of my high strength high tackle guys are causing a fumble every few games always on wrap-up.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
NFL - less than 0.5 fumbles per game

Canada PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.79 fumbles lost per game

USA PRO - 1.15 fumbles per game, 0.73 fumbles lost per game

Africa PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.78 fumbles lost per game

South America PRO - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.75 fumbles lost per game

Western Europe Pro - 1.13 fumbles per game, 0.70 fumbles lost per game

Oceania PRO - 1.05 fumbles per game, 0.74 fumbles lost per game

Eastern Europe PRO - 1.04 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

South East Asia PRO - 0.98 fumbles per game, 0.63 fumbles lost per game

I'll get the other PRO leagues later -- it is well known that the majority of players play on wrap up because it is the safest (least missed tackles) while still providing a very good chance of forcing a fumble.

All I am saying is that there needs to be a trade-off between playing on wrap-up, combo or power, because right now there really isn't a reason to play on anything but wrap up -- you get the best of both worlds from the setting.


All 8 PRO leagues, and a definite trend.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by secondeye
I think I agree with the OP. Wrap up should cause very minimal fumbles,
yet significantly increase the tackle chance, but still respect a
players ability to break tackles.

It does make sense. Some of my high strength high tackle guys are causing a fumble every few games always on wrap-up.


No, it should cause very few fumbles and give a very minimal increase to the tackle chance.

Tackle chances happen much more often than fumbles, so anything else is unbalanced. Players with low Strength and Tackling should be missing tackles all over the place-- the end to super-fast players.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.