User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > Canada AAA #1 East Power Rankings
Page:
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Week 12
R=Power Ranking; P=Team Point Rating; C= Current Record

Team-----------------R--------P------------C------W3---W4---W5---W6---W7---W8---W9---W10---W11---W12---W13---W14---W15---W16
Wall-------------------1--------109.76---(15-1)---1------1------1------1------1------1------1------1------1-----1-----1-----1-----1
OOTP-----------------2--------108.60---(13-3)---4------4------4------3------3------2------2------2------2-----2-----2-----2-----2
Labrador-------------3--------99.91---(13-3)----6------5------5------5------4------5------5------5------5-----5-----4-----3-----3
Nova Scotia---------4--------99.36---(10-6)----7------7------7------8------7------8------8------6------8-----7-----8-----5-----4
Ottawa----------------5--------98.08----(14-2)---2------3------3------2------2------3------3------3------3-----6-----6-----6-----5
Springfield-----------6--------95.24---(10-6)----8------8------8------7------5------4------4------4------4-----3-----5-----4-----6
Hamilton-------------7--------93.53---(11-5)----3------2------2------4------6------6------6------7------6-----4-----3-----9-----8
Bushwood----------8--------93.41---(10-6)----5------6------6------6------8------7------7------8------7-----8-----7-----7-----7
New Foundland----9------91.68----(8-8)-----10----10----10----10-----10----10----10-----10----10----10-----9-----8-----9
Collinsville---------10--------83.66----(7-9)-----9------9------9------9------9------9------9------9------9-----9----10----10----10
Westside------------11------73.69---(6-10)----11----11----11----11-----11----11----11-----11----11----11----11----11----11
NLS-------------------12------66.36---(4-12)----12----12----12----12-----12----12----12-----12----12----12----12----12----12
Las Vegas----------13------60.91---(3-13)----13----13----13----13-----13----13----13-----13----13----13----13----13----13
Montreal-------------14------52.89---(2-14)----14----14----14----14-----14----14----14-----14----14----14----14----14----14
Concordia----------15------42.56---(1-15)----16----16----16----15-----15----15----15-----15----15----15----15----15----15
Boston---------------16------38.41---(0-16)----15----15----15----16-----16----16----16-----16----16----16----16----16----16

Last edited May 28, 2008 08:46:30
 
Spacecataz
offline
Link
 
Ottawa*
 
Stinky
offline
Link
 
Kewl.

If I understand the system correctly, this is a rating of each team's roster strength? It doesn't take into account actual yardage or point totals, or won/loss record, just the levels of players at designated positions?
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
It does take into effect game outcomes though. If you beat a higher ranked team (or lose to a lower ranked one), it's going to take that into account and add or subtract points based on each teams ranking.

From the originator of this.

"Adjustments: The power ranking is obviously not perfect. It will change each week as rosters change and players level up, but it also has systematic flaws that will get exposed when teams are "upset" by lower rated teams. To adjust for these upsets, any team that defeats a higher rated team (based on roster ratings AT GAME TIME) will receive an "upset bonus" equal to the difference in roster ratings. The higher rated team will receive an equal "upset penalty". These bonuses and penalties will be capped at 5-10, I'm not sure yet. Teams that are overrated in the roster ratings (because they lack depth, or their starters are poorly built and perform below their level, or because of poor game planning and tactics, or whatever other reason) will see their ranking drop, even as their roster rating remains high, as they lose games they "shouldn't" have. Underrated teams, with positive intangibles, will similarly see their ranking rise. "

I capped the upset penalties & bonus' at 5.
Last edited May 1, 2008 18:29:44
 
Stinky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Varmintcong
It does take into effect game outcomes though. If you beat a higher ranked team (or lose to a lower ranked one), it's going to take that into account and add or subtract points based on each teams ranking.


Ok, but "Higher Ranked" still uses roster strength as its basis?

Not complaining at all, just making sure I understand the algo. I always like a new way of looking at data.

 
BusuB
offline
Link
 
This would work as a static ranking, but I thought the purpose of a power ranking was to measure the dynamic changes throughout a season.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
For the record, the official method I decided on for upset adjustments in my rankings is as follows:

When an upset occurs, the "upset factor" for the game is equal to the log(10) of the difference in roster strength, times 10. Half of the upset factor is subtracted from the loser, and half is added to the winner. Keep in mind that "upsets" are always defined by the base, unadjusted, roster ratings.

In theory this makes it a dynamic system, rather than a static one, because "paper tiger" teams who have a flaw such as poor depth or poor game planning will eventually get upset by lower ranked teams, and see their rating fall as a result.
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
For the record, the official method I decided on for upset adjustments in my rankings is as follows:

When an upset occurs, the "upset factor" for the game is equal to the log(10) of the difference in roster strength, times 10. Half of the upset factor is subtracted from the loser, and half is added to the winner. Keep in mind that "upsets" are always defined by the base, unadjusted, roster ratings.

In theory this makes it a dynamic system, rather than a static one, because "paper tiger" teams who have a flaw such as poor depth or poor game planning will eventually get upset by lower ranked teams, and see their rating fall as a result.



Thanks for that, updated.
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BusuB
This would work as a static ranking, but I thought the purpose of a power ranking was to measure the dynamic changes throughout a season.


Based on what would have been "pre-season" rankings, it went

Wall
OOTP
Hamilton
Springfield
Bushwood
Ottawa
...

So there has been some movement.
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Okay, so I updated these a little. I added some numbers to account for wins/losses & margin of victory/defeat. Also, unlike BobJoeJim's I'm going to define upsets based on the previous rankings, not the base.
Last edited May 2, 2008 11:40:49
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Updated for WK 4
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
wheres the update? ... never mind...
Last edited May 2, 2008 17:23:06
 
Stinky
offline
Link
 
Week #5 against OOTP is going to tell us just how well we're doing, or if we're just beating the teams we're supposed to be beating.

Looking forward to to the game.
 
BusuB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Varmintcong
Originally posted by BusuB

This would work as a static ranking, but I thought the purpose of a power ranking was to measure the dynamic changes throughout a season.


Based on what would have been "pre-season" rankings, it went

Wall
OOTP
Hamilton
Springfield
Bushwood
Ottawa
...

So there has been some movement.


A lot of the movement *could be attributed to boosting, but I'm too lazy to run the math. Still, I'm a little uneasy w/ the system, but whatever you say.
 
mari0k
offline
Link
 
So its either us (Hamilton) or Wall....argh )
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.