User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > Canada AAA #1 West Power Rankings.
Page:
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Stobie has new power rankings on last page.
Last edited May 10, 2008 08:59:54
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
like other thread, did you account for backups?
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Nope, took it straight from this.

"Roster Power Rankings: To begin with, I put every team's starting lineup in a spreadsheet. Right now, I'm looking ONLY at the level of each starter. Backups and builds are ignored (this is the primary source of error that component two will have to adjust for). CPU players are universally treated as the equivalent of a level 1 human player, regardless of the CPU's actual level. Holes in the lineup are treated as level 0. Each player is then graded against the other players at his position (WR1 and WR2 are considered separate positions, as are LOT and ROT, etc...). A player who is the highest level in the Conference at his position will be rated 100, anyone else will be linearly scaled (so if the best player were a 10, an 8 would become an 80, etc...).

Next, using the scaled player ratings, I give each team a separate rating in pass offense, rush offense, pass defense, and rush defense, using weighted averages of the players' relative importance to that aspect of the game. These are the crude formulas I'm using:

Pass Offense: (QB + (WR1 + WR2)/2 + TE/5 + (OL AVG)/2)/2.7
Rush Offense: (HB + FB/5 + (OL AVG))/2.2
Pass Defense: (CB1 + CB2 + (S AVG) + (DE AVG)*.75 + (LB AVG)/2)/4.25
Rush Defense: ((DT AVG) + (DE AVG)/2 + (LB AVG))/2.5

Then, I average the pass and run numbers together to get overall Offense and Defense rankings, and finally I average these numbers together to give the team its final Overall Power Ranking.

Adjustments: The power ranking is obviously not perfect. It will change each week as rosters change and players level up, but it also has systematic flaws that will get exposed when teams are "upset" by lower rated teams. To adjust for these upsets, any team that defeats a higher rated team (based on roster ratings AT GAME TIME) will receive an "upset bonus" equal to the difference in roster ratings. The higher rated team will receive an equal "upset penalty". These bonuses and penalties will be capped at 5-10, I'm not sure yet. Teams that are overrated in the roster ratings (because they lack depth, or their starters are poorly built and perform below their level, or because of poor game planning and tactics, or whatever other reason) will see their ranking drop, even as their roster rating remains high, as they lose games they "shouldn't" have. Underrated teams, with positive intangibles, will similarly see their ranking rise. "
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
I updated these bsed on a formula BobJoeJim was using. Just in case anyone wants to know, the original preseason rankings went like this.

Moose Jaw------ 89.56
Spokane-------- 86.03
USA------------ 85.07
Winnipeg------- 82.09
Calgary-------- 81.62
Victoria------- 80.81
Vancouver------ 79.87
Drinkin-------- 79.05
Regina--------- 78.65
St. Catherines- 77.05
South---------- 76.57
Chilliwack----- 76.28
Pittsburgh----- 73.70
Saskatoon------ 68.23
Clemson-------- 61.20
Thunder-------- 59.69

So this is not a static power ranking, it will change every game, I know it's not perfect.
Last edited May 2, 2008 09:58:32
 
raato
offline
Link
 
varmint can you add the points to the preseason ranking? It would give those of us who at the bottom a point of reference.

TIA
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Okay, also, I'm going to update it to try to account for wins & margin of victory.
 
Trogdor Jones
offline
Link
 
good job man. this looks like a pretty decent system
 
raato
offline
Link
 
The only problem I see is Thunder Bay has beaten vancouver, clemson and saskatoon and it took USA which is number 1 to return a kick late in the game to win and we are still ranked at the bottom almost.

I understand nothing is perfect, but I see this as a flaw. Thunder Bay is not as weak as it looks on paper. I guess we'll find out as the season progresses, I'll just enjoy being tied in the division for second place right now.

Dont get me wrong I love these types of rankings and I am not complaining, just trying to help refine it more.

Heck If I took these rankings to heart I would just tell my guys dont bother showing up we dont have a chance
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
Updated for Week 4. Will do east soon.
Last edited May 2, 2008 15:20:33
 
Stobie
MoD
offline
Link
 
Raato.... come now... be the underdog... you should be used to it when we were playing last season Just take care of business and prove them wrong
 
raato
offline
Link
 
Stobie I have no problem being the underdog. I was just trying to show things may not always be as they appear.

Congrats on your Win Stobie, dont look in the rearview mirror teams may be closer than they appear
 
MD
offline
Link
 
I dont see how its a flaw that someone wrote out some ranking and your team was ranked low.

We were ranked 12th and said that we werent expected to do well, in the preseason rankings.

You know what i did, i put up the message in the team forums and gave us a little incentive to win and prove others wrong. Were 3-1 right now in 3rd place and have beat some of the tougher teams in the league, lost a close one or else we would be 4-0.

Thats the fun of rankings.

Theres no flaw in them though.
 
raato
offline
Link
 
MD the flaw was that after 3 games we were still towards the bottom after winning two games and taking the #1 team at the time down to the wire. Had they not returned kickoff for a TD at the end we had held them in check.

I like the ranking and I used it as bulletin board fodder as well.

I think the biggest point I really wanted to make was levels dont quite mean as much as good builds and tactics. There is no question my team has the lowest level guys in the whole conference, but if it was all about levels, as this is calculated, then we should not even have a chance in these games, which we have proved to be wrong up to this point.

Varmint I am not bashing you so please dont think that. I am just trying to point out a flaw as I see it (READ IMHO). Others say its not a flaw because they are just looking at the raw number of what level my team is. As time goes on this will be adjusted according to wins and losses, but early in the season its not accurate and that is the point I was making.

I was on Stobies team last year and consider him a friend, what him and I are doing is just banter.

I wont address this anymore, because I dont want it to turn into a pissing match. I was trying to provide another point of view. I'll just go back to my stadium and beat my players for not practicing hard enough.
 
raato
offline
Link
 
PS Keep up the good work Varmint. This is a great thing you are doing for the league as a whole.
 
Varmintcong
offline
Link
 
I totally understand your point, and I don't mind the constructive criticism. It's because of things like that that I put in the wins and losses counting in the standings. I agree it's kind of goofy to see a 3-1 team near the bottom of the standings. But if I fuck with this thing anymore, ya'll are going to tune in to Cheaters one night and see the show's crew and my wife confronting me and my computer. Hopefully, you'll win a couple of more and jump up towards the top so I won't be a lightning rod for the Thunder Bay team.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.