User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Dump To Gates
offline
Link
 
There was a play during our game today when our defense forced a fumble in the end zone, and it looks as if the offense recovered, and instead of giving us a safety, it was a touchback, and they then started at the 20. They then went on a long drive and got a field goal. Here is the link

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1658510

It also says 111 yards on the play, and could have cost us the game. Didn't know where to post this, but I figured it was a bug.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
The only plausible explanation is that the ball was recovered by the defense in the field of play and then fumbled out of the endzone. I realize that that is not shown in the replay nor described in the play-by-play, but that is the only way to get that result. And it is possible, unlikely but possible.
 
Dump To Gates
offline
Link
 
Isn't there a rule on fumbling the ball forward in the NFL? Or is that only if the fumbling team regains control?
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
What you are thinking of is fumbling the ball out of bounds and forwards. If you fumble out of bounds, the offense retains the ball. It used to be, you would retain the ball where it went out of bounds. Somebody started exploiting that to gain extra yards when near the sidelines. If you fumble to ball forwards and it remains in play, you are just taking your chances. Also, I don't think you are allowed to purposefully advance a fumbled ball by batting it, but that rule may not be important anymore since there are no longer prohibitions on who can recover a fumble and run with it.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I think that is definatley a bug. Notice that for that play, Boston is labeled as offense even though all the players on offense are clearly Hockey's.
Last edited May 1, 2008 14:47:04
 
Dump To Gates
offline
Link
 
I noticed that on a couple plays during this game that happened.
This play also. It might be a fumble thing when the offense recovers the ball?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1659082
 
bluesguy07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dump To Gates
Isn't there a rule on fumbling the ball forward in the NFL? Or is that only if the fumbling team regains control?


I think that only applies to the offense. The only person that can advance the ball on a fumble is the person who initially fumbles it, I believe.
 
jrg42
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bluesguy07
Originally posted by Dump To Gates

Isn't there a rule on fumbling the ball forward in the NFL? Or is that only if the fumbling team regains control?


I think that only applies to the offense. The only person that can advance the ball on a fumble is the person who initially fumbles it, I believe.


I think that rule only applies to last couple of minutes of the game. Most of the time you can up the ball and run with it no matter who you are.
 
peugas
offline
Link
 
This is definitely a bug. The only way that it is a safety, is if the fumbled ball goes out of the endzone, is picked up by a defensive player, and then he fumbles, and the ball goes out of bounds at the endzone. But I gues that if that would happened, it would be written that the defensive player recovered the fumble.

I guess my team paid the refs...
 
Meat Wagon
offline
Link
 
I've thought about this a little and I can't see any situation that doesn't result in a defensive touchdown or safety. I know the simulation view isn't exact, but thinking about similar situations in NFL games I believe they are safeties. And if not, what sense does it make to give them a first down after they essentially fumble in the backfield?
 
willmon52
offline
Link
 
it also says 111 yds for returning
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.