User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Snaza
offline
Link
 
I looked back about 4 days in multiple Forums and couldn't find this thread. Sorry.

But after this http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=217864&pbp_id=5310248
I just don't understand how it can't still be a major discussion.
How did we NOT call a TO and kick a FG there.
And don't give me lame answers like they tried to get a snap off or something. That makes no sense as the sim doesn't think that way.

1st half TO's and Defensive TO's are lacking. And if I'd have seen the previous forum I'd have had a lot to suggest.

In ANY game, no matter how up or down you are in the 1st half. If you're down to 5 seconds w/ a TO left, you call it and kick the FG. Guaranteed.
You go for the endzone usually if you're from midfield to the goal. Using your TO's only in the last minute on offense. Why? Because you don't want to give the other team the ball back WITH time on the clock.
Same rule applies to the 2nd half with a lead, or when you're about to take the lead.

And the defense. Don't get me started. If we stuff them on 1st down. I'm calling a TO! We now have a great shot at getting the ball back. 2nd down, another TO. And now 3rd down, and if we stop them, our 3rd TO gives us the ball back.
Not hard. Hard to get the yardage right, but maybe that can all be user input.

There's inputs in the AI about running play when you have so many TO's. But that's really bashing your head against the wall.
It would be much more beneficial to be able to tell your AI under what circumstances you want to call your TO's.

I'm all for the universal TO's though. As long as they make sense.
And in a fairly close game with 30 seconds left... there's no reason we wouldn't have called the TO and kicked it (in GLB world).

Thanks for listening to my rant/suggestion/hopeful fix

PS - I understand this could be in the Suggestion or Bug forum, I just picked the one most likely to get a good discussion going.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 16:51:01
 
hummus
offline
Link
 
Yea we've had games where the other team was driving with the lead w/ less than 2 minutes in play... no TOs ever get called.

I'm really surprised there is still a problem w/ TOs actually... the logic is not complicated and a programmer like Bort should be able to crank it out in <30 minutes.
Last edited Nov 24, 2008 19:00:55
 
mastawoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hummus
Yea we've had games where the other team was driving with the lead w/ less than 2 minutes in play... no TOs ever get called.

I'm really surprised there is still a problem w/ TOs actually... the logic is not complicated and a programmer like Bort should be able to crank it out in <30 minutes.


Agreed. Timeouts are absolutely ridiculous. How could it have been implemented if it doesn't work?
 
supgreg
offline
Link
 
It should be able to be added to the AI, basic or advanced.
 
raiderdav
offline
Link
 
Bort has asked for a logic tree of how you'd want Timeouts to be called. Put one together and post it rather than complaining.

 
mastawoo
offline
Link
 
No offense, bud, but do you know how ridiculous that sounds?
 
Cowboys101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mastawoo
No offense, bud, but do you know how ridiculous that sounds?


 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
It can't be THAT easy, the EA games still don't have it right.

It does need to be fixed though.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.