User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia A Leagues > Southeast Asia A #3 > Naga vs Garuka: Who is better?
Page:
 
Daily
offline
Link
 
Thoughts?

Naga is better in my personal opinion but that's only because I own and represent a team in Naga. I've sent scrimmages to the other top 2 Garuka teams (Samarinda has already beaten Easter Island and Laser Cats) Yokohama and PCE.


Would love to see how everyone else feels.


-Daily
Last edited Nov 22, 2008 14:03:52
 
mat5592
it's here
offline
Link
 
Naga

and its spelled Garuda tbh
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
This year Naga is definetly superior. I think next year Garuda may take over as the top conference as after another restructure (Bort is going to do it each season moving CPU teams to the bottom) I forsee the top 3 of Naga at the very least moving up.

We have some awesome teams in our top third of teams, the bottom 2/3rds are pretty weak though. Garuda seems to have a stronger bottom half.
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
laser cats
 
Airhead
offline
Link
 
My team (in Naga)is doing a merger which will leave us much improved next season. This season we're getting beat by CPU teams...which sucks.
 
JET5
offline
Link
 
Naga (Zeta... or was it Alpha, now I forget) has always been better. I would have had a playoff team all 3 seasons if I had been in that conference. We've never lost a scrimmage game, and only lost one regular season game to PCE (and barely).

But Caledric is right, if not next year then the year after Garuda will be better overall as they have some good slow builds and base teams working. But it depends on how they restructure things. I was really hoping they would have shifted teams around in these two conferences this year to balance things out more. Or at least have moved either Singapore or Haiphong.

In retrospect, I wish I had lobbied to have my team moved over there. I think we'd have had a better chance to be a top 4 team than we do on this side.

-Jet
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
The way Haiphong and the Scorps have been utterly dismantling everyone I'm really starting to wish Bort would have moved us up.

I think we both could have been competitive in that league. I look at teams like Augusta and Guan and remember how well we played both (We defeated Augusta in a scrimmage this year and they did not throw the game in any way) I think we could have definitely both been play off teams up there.
 
mat5592
it's here
offline
Link
 
Yeah you and Haiphong definitely could have competed. GUFC is dominating, Skaro and Augusta are also doing very well. Even the Canes aren't doing so bad.
 
JET5
offline
Link
 
I was honestly really shocked to see Haiphong here still. Didn't they finish 15-1 last season? Or was that Taipei? I know I recall looking at the season ending stats when trying to compare the league and find the holes in my team. The thing that impressed me the most was how well they dominated both sides of the ball at the line of scrimmage (and how poorly my team did at D and 0 line). Their O-Line had a ridiculous number of pancakes.

-Jet
 
mat5592
it's here
offline
Link
 
Haiphong was 15-1, Taipei undefeated.
 
tonjappr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JET5

and only lost one regular season game to PCE (and barely).


i wouldn't classify 0-27 as barely...
 
wallyopd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tonjappr
Originally posted by JET5


and only lost one regular season game to PCE (and barely).


i wouldn't classify 0-27 as barely...


And I guess he's treating the 42-14 loss to the Canes as a win, as well as the scrimmage losses to the Gotham Comets, the Hong Kong Vipers, and the Harrisburg Heat.
 
JET5
offline
Link
 
Yes, I'm clearly mistaken and I apologize to those teams that did beat us for being a moron. I was thinking only about the pre-season scrimmages (which we lost none of) and the 1 regular season game each season. I stop looking at games after the regular season.

But, I still think we would have made the playoffs each of the first two seasons had we been in the other conference.

-Jet
 
lumpy_cat
offline
Link
 
ZETA CONFERENCE!!!!
 
Daily
offline
Link
 
Samarinda beat the folowing Zeta Teams:

Northwest Arkansas Laser Cats
Hong Kong Killers
Easter Island Terror
Yokohama Samurai Warriors
PCE Pissed Drunk Pubcrawlers


Anyone else like to challenge?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.