User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #1 > Pro Bowl/End of Season Awards
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
I was just wondering if anyone has been doing the Pro Bowl and end of season awards for AA#1. If no one has, I'd be willing to volunteer to compile the votes/numbers on whatever system we decide to use.

If it were up to me we'd use something similar to this: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1218134

Only there are some acknowledged errors in his system. I made a spread sheet with some small altercations are tried out the formula at all the positions and it seems to work nicely.

Since voter activity in these types of things is generally non-existent it may be better to go with an impartial system.

If your all up for it I'd love to take control of the pro bowl and end of season awards for the league.

----

Just a small taste after 5 games(higher number is better):

QB
Chuck DaDuck - 264.59888
Brady Montana - 220.75242
Olav Gursky - 187.51864
Wyatt Parker - 206.57028

HB
Dean Hamilton - 191.48
Louis Riel - 144.12

WR
Dirty Hairy - 152.16
Vinicius Kaminski - 149.04

FB
Jason Lemieux - 150.2
Jiggs Johnson - 93.36

TE
Encyclopedia Britannica - 51.44
Trey Toren - 117.12

DE
Angry Blackman - 146.5
Matt Evans - 147

DT
Madd Sacker - 41
Cam Powell - 38

LB
Desmond James - 97
Corwin Amber - 60.5

CB
Jason ONeal - 92.25
Boog Evans - 73
Manabu Yukimitsu - 81

KR
Silver Bojangles - 63.9130434782609
Jake Adams - 49.4761904761905

PR
Speedy Beefman - 176.830508474576
Silver Bojangles - 128.990566037736
Jason Lemieux - 118.333333333333

These are not the leaders at any positions by any means(other than QB, RB and WR, which are pretty accurate for the leaders), I just selected a few random players to test out the formulas.

Some of the formulas need a bit of tweaking, but that will come as the season progresses.

Any interest in this?
 
crawlins
offline
Link
 
Wow...looks pretty good to me...thanks.
 
Chefnastee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crawlins
Wow...looks pretty good to me...thanks.


pfft....crawlins saw his QB on the list and stopped!
 
crawlins
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chefnastee
Originally posted by crawlins

Wow...looks pretty good to me...thanks.


pfft....crawlins saw his QB on the list and stopped!


Oh...there were others?
 
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
Haha. Some of the formulas still need work, overvaluing certain things, like PATS and undervaluing others.

I made a typo for the formula with CBs, it should have looked like this:

Manabu Yukimitsu - 114
Boog Evans - 100
Jason ONeal - 104.25
 
Link
 
i'm with it. this is the best idea i've seen in this forum yet. the voting system is a pain in the ass.
 
Todd Toddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nik.jd.aitken

CB
Jason ONeal - 92.25
Boog Evans - 73
Manabu Yukimitsu - 81


is that only for CBs or for DBs in general?

oh and btw, i really like the idea!

 
Nik Aitken
offline
Link
 
The same formula applies, for SS and FS, I was just to lazy to reenter the stats those positions.

They'll be there on the actual team.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.