User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Offensive AI is not working properly
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
2 teams I GM for had games today. In both I had it set up where whe ran plays off tackle on 1st down, but everything was either outside handoff or pass. It was not generic outside and it was not outside pitch. It was outside handoff.

In both games we ran pitch plays when we should not have. After seeing first game I went back and double checked offensive AI for the other team. I made 100% sure there was no pitches it was set for 60% strong I outside handoff HB right. 20% a specific pass play and 20% an inside rush play. There are plays in playbook matching all these settings.

We were still pitching the ball on 1st down.

Fortunately it didn't matter in either game. The first team would have lost even without the pitch plays that were stopped for a loss basically every time because our offensive line was outmatched on that side. The other game didn't matter because they couldn't stop the pitch any better than the HB OT.

Also, in the first game, we were going for it on 4th down at times when the settings were to punt. When situation was tested, output was punt.


While the outcome of the games was not affected, why do we have the AI if the CPU is not going to follow it.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 15:06:51
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Game 2 - first down
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231351&pbp_id=3542731

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=231351&pbp_id=3542647

There are more examples


Game 1 - first down
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=251282&pbp_id=3376065

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=251282&pbp_id=3376449
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Can someone think of why this would happen?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Am I going to have to take strong I pitches completely out of the playbook, even though there are games and situations where I want to use them?

Will taking them out of the playbook completely prevent the team from using them?
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 17:26:05
 
mortalq2
offline
Link
 
More than likely you have a setting wrong as opposed to it being a bug. Have someone else check your AI, another pair of eyes will help find the problem.
 
jstevens
offline
Link
 
no problem with your settings. i had passes ran for all game my last game. within the first drive we ran twice & the CPU decided to put a WR in at HB for goalline plays...the game is messing up not you.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mortalq2
More than likely you have a setting wrong as opposed to it being a bug. Have someone else check your AI, another pair of eyes will help find the problem.



I've had another set of eyes check it out on both teams. Plus, after first game I made sure that I had (right) in the directional settings so that the CPU wasn't confused between the advanced AI setting of Outside Rush - handoff and the basic AI run direction settings since there is no outside rush - handoff to the left out of strong I.

There is also a "Test Offense AI" setting

Matching Input
Input Named: 1st down - Strong I


Possible Outputs
20% Med TE (pass)
60% HB OT (outside_run_off_tackle)
20% HB inside left (inside_run)


 
Craw33
offline
Link
 
Do you have your playbook activated? Not the Offensive AI the Playbook...When you go and look at the offensive playbook do you have an X next to the title of the playbook?
That is the only thing I can come up with...Hope it helps.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by craw33
Do you have your playbook activated? Not the Offensive AI the Playbook...When you go and look at the offensive playbook do you have an X next to the title of the playbook?
That is the only thing I can come up with...Hope it helps.


playbook is activated for both teams.

It wasn't a factor in W/L for the 2 games today, although I like to think the score would have been closer in the loss and offense would have had more plays.

For another team I GM for, this would be a complete disaster as we have power backs who don't have ability to get to the edge. For that team pitches would be a death nail.

 
Craw33
offline
Link
 
Only thing I can think of then would be to test all different types of scenarios in the AI Tester and make sure no play shows up as Run/Pass or Pass/Run.

I would definitely run the exact scenario of the play you went for 4th down on and see what that brings up...My team did that a few games ago and when I ran it through the AI Test it showed my Output which was supposed to be Punt had mysteriously changed to a Random playcall...And since punt is at the top of my AI it ran whatever it wanted all game.

You should check out this thread if you haven't seen it already http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1432615
This might be what you are experiencing...Hope this helps.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Used exact scenario. 1st quarter. 610 seconds left. Opponents 33. trailing by 3.

Matching Input
Input Named: 1st down - Strong I


Possible Outputs
20% Med TE (pass)
60% HB OT (outside_run_off_tackle)
20% HB inside left (inside_run)

Test and show unmatched

Matching Input
Input Named: 1st down - Strong I


Possible Outputs
20% Med TE (pass)
60% HB OT (outside_run_off_tackle)
20% HB inside left (inside_run)


Unmatched Inputs
Input Named: 3rd and 0-1
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 2nd and 0-2
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 4th and 1+ own territory
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? No
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 4th and 1+ FG range
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Go For it
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 4th down, out of FG Range
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? No
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 4th down, FG range
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Within the 5
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? No
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Backed into Own Goal
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? No
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Third and Long
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Third And Medium
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Third & 2 - 3.5
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Third & 1-2
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: Third & less than 1
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 2nd and 10+
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 2nd 8-10
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 2nd and 5-8
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Input Named: 2nd and 0-5
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? No
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Special Sit? Yes
Matched My Timeouts? Yes
Matched Opp Timeouts? Yes
 
OUTLAW77
offline
Link
 
The AI is still hit and miss,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,It doesnt work half the TIME
 
Craw33
offline
Link
 
One last question...Your first down Strong I Input is every play set up to run out of the strong I? If so, I think that is your problem. There is no inside run left out of the Strong I...So it will pick the next closest thing, which would be one of two plays HB Outside Weak (Strong I) and Pitch Weak (Strong I).

EDIT: There is one Strong I Inside Run Left...Which is HB Dive Weak Strong I...So I don't know what would be wrong. Best Of Luck
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 19:46:14
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
anyone know what is causing this?
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
wonder how long it takes to get a comment from someone in authority.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.