User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Laying in the Team AI (Also Solves League Parity)
Page:
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
No one likes to be overwhelmed. Yet, as Team AI becomes more complex, which is amazing for experienced owners, it freezes out more and more players. If Team AI options were limited by the level the team is playing, it would make sense to the game's fiction, help train more and smarter owners, and solve the parity issue that plagues all the leagues.

Think about it. In effect, the AI HAS been phased in for most Season 1/2 owners. We master new toys every year. Yet for the Season 5 owner, they got them all at once.

Good games start simple and then branch out into more complexity as players are personally ready and have the social network within the game to help them out. GLB does this with players, whose choices for SPs become more important later, but it doesn't do it at all for owners.

The solution is to layer in the Team AI options by league. In Pro, we'd have all the latest toys, then less and less, as makes sense all the way down to BBB.

Yes, I know some of you will cry foul here. As an "AA" owner, I would lose some of my toys too.

Bort has already made sure people don't get in as owners as inappropriate levels by demoting the CPU teams after each season and not reselling at their old levels. This means, new owners are going to be BBB.

So, as a new owner, make the team something they can run ALONE. This means the very basic AI page. That makes BBB pretty much all about recruiting and general philosophy.

Then, as they advance, they are by definition surrounded with more people. You get to know other players on your team, some become coordinators. As it takes time to get more AI options, it means you probably also made more friends. Thus, you're more prepared to delegate and branch out. By the time someone has the full slate of AI, they've played at minimum five seasons and have a powerbase around them to really master the AI.

It even makes sense in the game's fiction. At BBB, players won't be Bill Belicheck. Yet, right now, they have the tools to implement his gameplans perfectly.

At the moment, I can decide if my players should be in A, AA, AA, etc. This would provide that same option to coordinators and owners. You'd get coordinators rising through the ranks, in theory. Once they master AA, even if their team doesn't go up, they might go catch on with a AAA team. Players would have resumes and coordinators could work in leagues appropriate to their own free time and level of interest. Right now, every league has to be able to plan like they're in Pro, because if you're not, you know someone else is.

What's more, the lack of crazy AI functions at lower level, would likely also make players play more to their level. For example, Level 35 LBers won't go sign in A to get 80 sacks anymore if the A Coach cannot actually design plays that get him those 80 sacks. He'll be more likely to play in his own bracket, but not actually forced to do so. He'll still be good, but players will want to achieve levels where they can be used most effectively.

Right now, we have 4000 teams going after 4000 top level players. There is only a minor difference between "A" and "Pro" in terms of player level. This would be a step to solving that and further integrate more owners into the game. It would make it far more accessible, realistic and, thus, in the end, it would actually be better for the long term growth of GLB.

Thoughts?

(EDIT: Sorry, typo in thread title... should be "Layering," not "Laying.")
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 23:58:55
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I think this is Krunchy's thread revisited.

Except this time there's an ounce of thought put forth instead of calling it 'loldot league'

+1
 
Link
 
thats a lot of stuff to go over, I'll have to get back to you
 
Link
 
I like it.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
I think this is Krunchy's thread revisited.

Except this time there's an ounce of thought put forth instead of calling it 'loldot league'

+1


LOL - Just found that thread. I think this is a bit more than that though, as you noted. His was more about having a D-Leauge+ basically. This is more of a progression system for teams.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Interesting. Let me think on this for a bit.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
So you are profiling the ability / cognizance of the owner by the league he owns a team in?

So you are saying the owners of Pro / AAA teams are either geniuses or have owned since year 1?

You are saying that expansion team owners are dull or brand new to GLB?

So a team has to be promoted out of BBB to get more of the sim's features?
If a team gets relegated do they lose team options?

The main determination factor is time spent online at GLB. Owners can spend 5 minutes or several hours a day at this.
Job and family demands count for more than GLB experience or what league a guy's team is in.

So all the new owners who get a BBB team, you are judge and jury on their grasp of the AI? You'd take it away so they don't hurt themselves?

This thread is demeaning.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of progression.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
So you are profiling the ability / cognizance of the owner by the league he owns a team in?

So you are saying the owners of Pro / AAA teams are either geniuses or have owned since year 1?

You are saying that expansion team owners are dull or brand new to GLB?

So a team has to be promoted out of BBB to get more of the sim's features?
If a team gets relegated do they lose team options?

The main determination factor is time spent online at GLB. Owners can spend 5 minutes or several hours a day at this.
Job and family demands count for more than GLB experience or what league a guy's team is in.

So all the new owners who get a BBB team, you are judge and jury on their grasp of the AI? You'd take it away so they don't hurt themselves?

This thread is demeaning.


That's quite a few words in his mouth.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus


This thread is demeaning.


Agreed.

The rules should be the same for everyone. We all pay the same amount for teams and should be afforded the same levels of enjoyment and depth.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Hmm. It would make it quite difficult to do well when you move up, since you have no experience with an AI that the rest of your league has been enjoying.
 
Lucius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by didymus
So you are profiling the ability / cognizance of the owner by the league he owns a team in?

So you are saying the owners of Pro / AAA teams are either geniuses or have owned since year 1?

You are saying that expansion team owners are dull or brand new to GLB?

So a team has to be promoted out of BBB to get more of the sim's features?
If a team gets relegated do they lose team options?

The main determination factor is time spent online at GLB. Owners can spend 5 minutes or several hours a day at this.
Job and family demands count for more than GLB experience or what league a guy's team is in.

So all the new owners who get a BBB team, you are judge and jury on their grasp of the AI? You'd take it away so they don't hurt themselves?

This thread is demeaning.


It's not demeaning. I am not saying new players CANNOT grasp it. I am saying that new players should not be forced to grasp it. It's a 32 team league. In every league, if all options are there, someone WILL grasp it and win. Thus the other players feel they have to and are quickly overwhelmed.

It's the same logic as any other MMO. There's a reason they don't give you 100 abilities in World of Warcraft on day one. It's not just to keep you paying the subscription fee (although that helps), it's to prevent you from quitting after 5 minutes.

Sure, some players will grasp the full AI. But most won't and clearly don't. And no, making it an option doesn't help. If the option is there, someone will use it and then everyone has to. It's the same flaw the makes everyone chase level 40 players.

Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by didymus



This thread is demeaning.


Agreed.

The rules should be the same for everyone. We all pay the same amount for teams and should be afforded the same levels of enjoyment and depth.


Level 1 in World of Warcraft pays $14.95, just like level 50. It's not about limiting the newbie's options, it's about making the game accessible enough that he actually sticks around to become level 50.


Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Hmm. It would make it quite difficult to do well when you move up, since you have no experience with an AI that the rest of your league has been enjoying.


This is one issue, I agree. A potential thing is to always make the next step up "visible" to the team, so they can see it and play with it, but not actually use it until they are promoted.
Last edited Nov 18, 2008 00:10:54
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
If you're really THAT intent on be a Pro team then you'll be graduating to Adv AI in no time. Also if you want to more just play the basic game then you're free to do that where others are doing the same.

This would emphasize the importance of builds, and teach basic scouting to new owners.

The gradual progression from basic --> super Adv AI would teach little at a time. THUS spreading the knowledge of how to operate them more efficiently.

Its just like any game you start. LVL 1 is always a tutorial. Don't get your panties all in a wad because you take something a little too personally.

Oh and most Pro team owners HAVE been around since Season 1.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Oh there's more. The logic that a 35 level LB will shy away from A league's because the DEF AI won't get him his sacks? By that logic, the same league's offensive AI won't be able to plan proper pass protection. It's a wash.

Oh wait, there's more. I played 2 seasons before I got my team and acted as GM prior as well. I would have been handcuffed as to what I could or couldn't try?

I am confident that nothing like this will ever be considered.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Wow, and I thought I had covered everything.

You want to make sure the owners who work hard don't achieve any additional success.


This keeps getting better.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.