User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bort's new offensive playcalling is messed up
Link
 
The ability to create specialized offensive sets has the sim all out of whack. Scoring is way, way up because of it. It's another step towards this football simulator not simulating football.

GLB has started to simulate basketball scores more than football scores.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Defense is definitely at the point of aggravating, but there isn't much we can do at this point.
 
jcb1018
offline
Link
 

We just played last night . I went in and took out all the run right plays from our active playbook except for 3 . 2 outside 1 inside and kept 9 to the left. We ran 45 times and all to the middle right and right. even if you flipped a coin 45 times you would get one to make you go left i would think. The team I played ran 4 left 4 middle 4 right or close to that.I realize I could go in and create run left playes but find it crazy the game in its own randomness would not run left 1 out of 45 with 9 plays left to chose and ran all 45 with 3 !! This is why offense teams have to have 300 inputs to try and get something to work. We won 100 to nothing against a very week team but still find it very odd
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jcb1018

We just played last night . I went in and took out all the run right plays from our active playbook except for 3 . 2 outside 1 inside and kept 9 to the left. We ran 45 times and all to the middle right and right. even if you flipped a coin 45 times you would get one to make you go left i would think. The team I played ran 4 left 4 middle 4 right or close to that.I realize I could go in and create run left playes but find it crazy the game in its own randomness would not run left 1 out of 45 with 9 plays left to chose and ran all 45 with 3 !! This is why offense teams have to have 300 inputs to try and get something to work. We won 100 to nothing against a very week team but still find it very odd


You may want to have a closer look at your offensive AI
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by jcb1018


We just played last night . I went in and took out all the run right plays from our active playbook except for 3 . 2 outside 1 inside and kept 9 to the left. We ran 45 times and all to the middle right and right. even if you flipped a coin 45 times you would get one to make you go left i would think. The team I played ran 4 left 4 middle 4 right or close to that.I realize I could go in and create run left playes but find it crazy the game in its own randomness would not run left 1 out of 45 with 9 plays left to chose and ran all 45 with 3 !! This is why offense teams have to have 300 inputs to try and get something to work. We won 100 to nothing against a very week team but still find it very odd


You may want to have a closer look at your offensive AI


I agree with the above statement
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
The ability to create specialized offensive sets has the sim all out of whack. Scoring is way, way up because of it. It's another step towards this football simulator not simulating football.

GLB has started to simulate basketball scores more than football scores.


Bort needs to add a read bonus for the defense if the offense is running the same play over and over again, or the same set of plays. However, if the offense is running a number of plays out of the same formation, or is running a huge playbook, there shouldn't be a bonus.

I'd like to see linebackers stop dropping automatically, as mentioned in another thread -- they should move based on their settings + play settings, and then have a vision/confidence check to determine how quickly they read the play and how quickly and confidently they react to it.

Finally, defenses need to be able to adjust based on what players are in the game. Power back in -- stack the line. Rushing QB in? Stack the line cover 0. HB in the FB slot? Guard against the FB run. FB in the HB slot? Play the pass. This is how teams react in real football and it should be no diff here.

Add any or all of these, and the game will move back into balance.
 
jcb1018
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by jcb1018



We just played last night . I went in and took out all the run right plays from our active playbook except for 3 . 2 outside 1 inside and kept 9 to the left. We ran 45 times and all to the middle right and right. even if you flipped a coin 45 times you would get one to make you go left i would think. The team I played ran 4 left 4 middle 4 right or close to that.I realize I could go in and create run left playes but find it crazy the game in its own randomness would not run left 1 out of 45 with 9 plays left to chose and ran all 45 with 3 !! This is why offense teams have to have 300 inputs to try and get something to work. We won 100 to nothing against a very week team but still find it very odd


You may want to have a closer look at your offensive AI


I agree with the above statement


O k I run first down hb run outside random formation basic settings 35 % and similar and went in deleted all but 3 run plays to the right so what would i change? with the play book x and same for 2 nd down inside and outside random basic settings so how or why would it not run 1 play to left out of 45 plays
 
Mike1709
offline
Link
 
Are you stipulating the play run to the left in the output, if not it will go to basic settings for run direction and you may have that at or close to 100% right
 
jcb1018
offline
Link
 
Even if I am not using basic AI the direction there effects direction for a run in Ai and the new playbook plays?? If so you are the man because I never adjusted that and it was 100% but never though the basic mattered since I have ran left before we were able to pick direction. I hope you solved this for me and if so thanks a lot!
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jcb1018
Even if I am not using basic AI the direction there effects direction for a run in Ai and the new playbook plays?? If so you are the man because I never adjusted that and it was 100% but never though the basic mattered since I have ran left before we were able to pick direction. I hope you solved this for me and if so thanks a lot!


Yes, because you probably had the "run direction" set to "use basic settings".

This complaint isn't valid... taking a look at the pro leagues, most of the scores in competitive games look like good football scores - maybe not good NFL scores, but the scores could easily be from NCAA games.

I think this mostly shows that DCs are still adjusting to having to *gasp* do actual work and scouting and stuff, rather than just setting 1 to 3 money outputs for each offensive formation and sitting back and collecting trophies. Once DCs have refreshed their memories on how to view an opponent's past games, scout their tendencies, and adjust to counter, we should see scores gradually come down.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.