User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Time to fix LB routing
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Two seasons ago Bort put in a "fix" to linebacker pathing so the offenses could run the ball decently. He had the linebackers start a running play at about a 45 deg angle away from the line of scrimmage, before a vision check could possibly let them recognize a running play.

He was also talking about delaying linebackers on blitzes this season.

How about if we combine both problems and fix them in a way that linebackers are still performing and doing the things they would normally do in a football game.

This is what I propose.

Make linebacker's first steps directly controlled by the player settings. After 3 or 4 ticks, they get a vision check to see if they recognize the play.

The following are examples of what each setting would do.

Run focus - A linebacker set on run focus automatically starts towards the line of scrimmage at the snap, and after the third tick, he gets a vision check to see if he recognizes the play. If it is a run, he is already in a wonderful position to make the play, and he gets a bonus to his tackle chance, but if it is a pass, and he is in coverage, he starts out either in contact with a lineman, or possibly well behind the player he is covering, and he gets a penalty on his pass coverage.

If the linebacker is on pass focus, he starts off the line of scrimmage at a shallow angle (much like his motion now) until he gets his vision check when he can react to the run, or pass. If it is a pass, he gets a bonus on his pass coverage, but if it is a run his tackle chance goes down slightly.

If the linebacker is in balanced, he stands still for the three ticks, until he gets the vision check, then he reacts. He gains neither a bonus nor penalty to his tackle or pass coverage, and plays normally.

That way, the offense gets a chance to rip up a defense that is going all run by passing on them, or running on a passing defense, without all these hokey pathing issues that don't even remotely resemble normal tactics.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
By the way, in case you read this Bort, you answered the previous post I had up last season and said you would look at it, so I dropped it, but I haven't seen any comments or posts about plans to further look at it, so I thought I'd try again.

PinTBC
 
McBlaze
offline
Link
 
I like this a lot
 
Link
 
having the balanced guy stand still is kind of a penalty to run plays though, thats the only thing I disagree on, the balanced linebacker should have some sort of movement, maybe if he's on outside lb he can make his way towards his man assignment or something but if he just stands there before his vision check he is going to be out of position of his gap assignment
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
having the balanced guy stand still is kind of a penalty to run plays though, thats the only thing I disagree on, the balanced linebacker should have some sort of movement, maybe if he's on outside lb he can make his way towards his man assignment or something but if he just stands there before his vision check he is going to be out of position of his gap assignment


Ahh, but the DC actually has some control over where he is standing. In another words, in a 4-3 standard, the linebackers start over their gaps, and standing still would only actually keep them in their spot for a bit. When you shift them though, it could get difficult to easily cover all the gaps, which still isn't bad.

Oh! and it is supposed to be a slight penalty on a run play to play balanced. It is also supposed to be a slight penalty on passing plays.

It just gnaws at me the current action of linebackers on my 3-4 defense.

PinTBC
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 18:56:29
 
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC


Oh! and it is supposed to be a slight penalty on a run play to play balanced. It is also supposed to be a slight penalty on passing plays.



no there is no bonus or penalty, not a slight penalty, you react as normal, wheras being on pass focus you react faster to pass plays and slower to run plays, and vice veras for the run focus setting
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
You act like Bort hasn't been trying to fix the pathing. LOL.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
You act like Bort hasn't been trying to fix the pathing. LOL.


You act like he has. lol
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
You act like Bort hasn't been trying to fix the pathing. LOL.


Actually about 2 seasons ago, he put the current pathing in on purpose because linebackers were crashing the lines and destroying the running lanes. The problem I have with it, is that it simply isn't what linebackers are supposed to do, AND it really screws with a 3-4 defense which is predicated on linebacker pressure.

Originally posted by
no there is no bonus or penalty, not a slight penalty, you react as normal, wheras being on pass focus you react faster to pass plays and slower to run plays, and vice veras for the run focus setting


Fair enough, then I phrased it poorly. Against a run, the bonus would be if the linebacker were actually set to a run focus, his bonus is that he starts forward at the snap, and gains a small increase in tackle, with a decrease in pass coverage. The balanced would be normal, no movement in either direction at the start until he gets his vision check, with no bonus or penalty on pass coverage or tackle. The Pass would be the penalty, because he is moving backwards at the snap looking to get into the passing lanes, and receives a bonus in pass coverage and a slight penalty in tackle.

Right now, the linebacker hightails it for the hills on running plays, so simply not moving is a huge improvement. Blitzes etc would still over ride his starting motion, so it could be over ridden.

PinTBC
 
Link
 
fair enough, you get one free bump, but like any good smack dealer the next one will cost you
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Heh,

Thanks for the bump. I wish the search function still worked so you could find Bort posting in here. Without that, the next best thing would be to talk to people about it, but people are too concerned with other things.

I'd love to have people discuss this and poke holes in it.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Thought I'd bump this as I noticed a second thread on the same issue.

Any comments from above?

PinTBC
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Thought I'd bump this as I noticed a second thread on the same issue.

Any comments from above?

PinTBC


So someone made a thread on the same thing. So you decided to bump your own thread so that you could have two threads on the same issue?

Tell me where that starts to make sense from a community standpoint.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by PinTBC

Thought I'd bump this as I noticed a second thread on the same issue.

Any comments from above?

PinTBC


So someone made a thread on the same thing. So you decided to bump your own thread so that you could have two threads on the same issue?

Tell me where that starts to make sense from a community standpoint.


Why are you even here, from a community standpoint?

/bump
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Iceman16
Originally posted by PinTBC

Thought I'd bump this as I noticed a second thread on the same issue.

Any comments from above?

PinTBC


So someone made a thread on the same thing. So you decided to bump your own thread so that you could have two threads on the same issue?

Tell me where that starts to make sense from a community standpoint.



"But Mr. Roboto--what about the children?"

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.