User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Fumbles still a problem (jumping on it early this season)
Page:
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
OK, only one game in, but I'm getting on this now as opposed to waiting. I'm not saying fumble forcing chance has been increased, but it seems something in the formula is causing fumbles TOO often.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=225016

My RB, Shizzle, had two fumbles. He has 87 strength, 40 carrying, 36 vision, 35 confidence, and 5 in cover up. If these fumbles were caused by an NT or DT, I could understand that, since they probably have highter strength and tackling compared to Shizzle's Strength and carrying. However...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1210939 -- an FS caused one.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=225016&pbp_id=1215707 -- SS caused the other.

Before people try to blame this on confidence, Shizzle had two plays, one for 4.5 yards and one for 5 yards before this. Even if someone had auta of intimidation along with other morale hitting SAs, Shizzle shouldn't have fumbled this early as a result of confidence. On the second one, his team just stopped a drive via a turnover on downs -- shouldn't that BOOST someone's confidence? Not to mention, he had a good game up to that point, running for nearly 6 YPC with 2 touchdowns.

Considering the positions that caused this and the speed they were running, I'm thinking the effect of speed on fumbles is far higher than it should be. I understand that collision speed could result in more fumbles, but wouldn't someone who knows they are about to be hit hard cover the ball up a bit? Can we please do something about fumbles before they get to be ridiculously excessive?

And to counter the argument I know I'll see -- I highly doubt adding on 8 more carrying (to softcap) would prevent these fumbles. Do you need 75 carrying to lower the rate to any sort of a realistic level? 80? More? This RB, on the team I own, fumbles less than my RB, and he has far less strength and cover up, with similar carrying: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31567 . And he fumbles less in a tougher league, to boot.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 12:20:38
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Adding 8 points to carrying will sure help though, that's an 20% increase. I wouldn't expect a HB to have carrying much over the soft-cap at your level but you must keep putting points there the keep up with the progression of the game.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Those were both big hits. Each safety had 10 yards to build up speed and hit you. Whats your agility? Could you move even slightly out of the way of those freight trains?
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Those were both big hits. Each safety had 10 yards to build up speed and hit you. Whats your agility? Could you move even slightly out of the way of those freight trains?


48 agility should have been enough to at least deflect some of the blow. But even then, wouldn't any RB that KNOWS this is coming at least cover the ball up? I'd think that speed should only really factor in like this if you're on power tackling, since I see power as running as hard as you can and nailing the guy, while wrap-up is more the "don't miss, don't get juked, just make the tackle" type setting. I don't see someone on wrap up essentially trying to battering ram a power back down. Any time they do, you should see a Brandon Jacobs truck sticking.

Maybe I should up my kicking, so that I can kick the guy in the nuts when he tries it again
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 12:51:16
 
Toric
offline
Link
 
mine had 3 in 1 game norm does not have a problem...

great agility but a 34 in carry.... great STR and 5 in cover up..

# is a bit wacky
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Bumping this. 2 more fumbles, 2 more lost. 4 fumbles in two games.

What the hell is going on here? This is seriously ridiculous -- the other RB on our team has yet to fumble, and has one less strength, 3 more carrying, and .8 more confidence. The same agility.

So why have I fumbled four times, while he hasn't fumbled? Heck, why has ANY rb fumbled 4 times in two games, and lost all of those? This really needs to get fixed.
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 14:57:47
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
probably not a bug imo, randomness
 
Beerski
offline
Link
 
Have you tried a different rushing style? That plays a role in the fumble calculation.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
40 carrying seems awful low for a powerback. I honestly don't know if that's the cause, or if there actually is a bug, but I do know that I certainly wouldn't have 40 carrying at level 36 with a powerback build.

Beerski's point is quite valid as well. If you're set to power, you're purposely trying to run over people, which means you get more solid hits. An elusive or combo back gets a lot of deflected hits and glancing blows.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
1) I also have 5 cover up, while the other back has 4.

2) I've been running on balanced since midway through last season.

3) OK, I realize some people would consider a higher carrying rating. That's cool and all. But that doesn't explain 4 fumbles to no fumbles from the other back. Sure, maybe I should fumble a bit more than another back, but 40 carrying vs, say, 48 carrying shouldn't result in a ton more fumbles.

Basically, it seems that the cover up SA is busted in some way, shape, or form. Or is a totally worthless SA, since 1 more point in it is not helping prevent fumbles at all, while 3 carrying is the difference in 0 fumbles and 4. I understand the idea of randomness being in the equation, but my RB is fumbling against a team we pretty much steamrolled, and both fumbles came in the red zone, when players didn't even have a chance to get much momentum. If we were playing really good teams, I'd be ok with this. But we beat both teams decisively. And my fumbles have been forced twice by an SS, once by an FS, and once by an LB (who my RB pretty much ran into while the LB was stationary, but my RB still fumbled). If fumbles are basically a total crapshoot that stats don't seem to have any effect on, it might be best to just avoid the carrying stat altogether. I'm sorry, but someone with only 40 strength and 40 tackling should not be causing fumbles on a back with 82 strength and 40 carrying simply because the guy has 75 speed.

I'm really beginning to believe the theory that some players are simply meant to be total duds, and that there are hidden stats that screw the randomness for some and not others.

Here's another RB of mine:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=628770

62 strength, 78 speed, 33 carrying, 1 cover up. He is often playing guys 5-10 levels above him (and even worse last season and the season before that). He has fumbled one more time in his career than Shizzle fumbled last season total. He has far less carrying, more speed, more agility, runs on combo also. Has less vision, far less confidence than Shizzle. And, as I said, plays competition far above him. Shizzle plays competition at or slightly below his level, yet fumbles far more.

There's also the case of the two RBs on my team in Oceania:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=61031
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=31567

Bet you can't guess which one has more cover up/strength/carrying! What, you can? Its the one that had less fumbles last season? Nope! Its the one with more fumbles. He has 7 more carrying, a couple more strength and another point in cover up.

Something's wrong here. Is cover-up causing more fumbles rather than less, possibly? It seems that backs with less cover up are fumbling less than those with more cover up in my very small sample.

Fumbles should be far less random and far more based on the actual stats of the player. Someone with more carrying and cover up should always fumble less than someone with less in the stats. It shouldn't be so random that a back can fumble 2 or 3 times more in a season with a bit more carrying than another RB.
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 16:45:45
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
And to defuse another argument that may be brought up:

"LOL your stamina is crap lolol" -- the team's other RB has 2 more stamina than me, and we finished today's game at the same energy.

"laff your confidence is crap" -- I have .8 confidence less than our other back.
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
To go off what Moose is saying there are some inconsistencies...the one that makes me wonder is how can a converted offensive tackle return punts and kicks without fumbling with some consistency?

Here's an example...http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=477727

I can only imagine how tedious it is to edit the code and scrips for the game but for every time a RB fumbles the ball that "return man" should cough have two or three.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
sigh, this "bitching" problem wont stop until people get 0 fumbles all season. FUMBLES HAPPEN. doesnt matter if your hit hard nor weak. if you want to bitch about it, get carrying to 100 and 10 skill points in cover up. (for RB of course) if you still get the same numbers then you can bitch at bort.

k thx lock plz

Ryan
 
zook28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
sigh, this "bitching" problem wont stop until people get 0 fumbles all season. FUMBLES HAPPEN. doesnt matter if your hit hard nor weak. if you want to bitch about it, get carrying to 100 and 10 skill points in cover up. (for RB of course) if you still get the same numbers then you can bitch at bort.

k thx lock plz

Ryan


I always "sigh" when someone responds to a thread with some sort of negative or derogatory comment. With the Madden like logic you're throwing out there..."fumbles happen" and "people won't be happy until there are zero fumbles" it's a shock that you're not an admin who is sharing your wisdom with the rest of GLB.

People post in the bugs forum to seek answers to their questions and to let the admins/GLB community know that they are experiencing a problem. They might not be bugs or not but that's not for you to decide.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
No, I'm totally ok with fumbling a realistic amount. But the absolute worst running backs in most any football league fumble 6-7 times a season. In GLB, that is more the average as opposed to the freak occurence.

But fumbling four times in two games would cause any coach to permanently bench a running back.

I don't want 0 fumbles in a game, that's rather unrealistic too. I'm after realism. Heck, I think RBs still run for too many yards. I'm just after the fumble aspect of realism right now. I really don't mind fumbling if it is realistic. This is in no way, shape or form realistic.

I'm sorry, but I'm very invested in this game, and would hate for RBs to not fumble -- my defenders wouldn't get to have nearly as much fun! But I think the large amount of fumbles from RBs currently is silly, especially considering WRs don't fumble nearly as often when they typically have lower carrying, strength and vision, and are often hit at a higher speed.

And what Zook posted is confusing too. Why don't OTs fumble much more due to a much lower carrying rating if Carrying is the key to not fumbling? Do HBs just have a ramped up chance to fumble somewhere? Is the cover up SA really buggy? Is higher carrying having a negative as opposed to positive effect?
Last edited Nov 13, 2008 19:28:34
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.