User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > World Championship Playoff vs. Champions' League
Page:
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I'd like to bring this back to the forefront since this appears to have fallen by the wayside.

I would prefer a 3-round playoff of the champions of the Pro Leagues from each of the 8 regions to crown a world champion. This would take place on days 42-46 after the playoffs or in the preseason using the previous year's standings.

Format: Either of the following
- Geographical: 1st round: USA vs. Canada, S. America vs. Africa, W. Europe vs. E. Europe, SE Asia vs. Oceania; Semifinal: USA/Can vs. SA/Afr, WE/EE vs. SEA/Oc. Glorify this by giving a trophy name for the regional round, e.g. Magellan Cup (SA vs Afr), Cook Trophy (SEA vs Oc), etc. to be displayed in the team's case (beyond a scrimmage brag right).
- Seeding: Rank teams 1-8 based on either overall rating, point difference, combined overall rating of opponents, or average level

Pros:
- We know who the best in the world is, and just in case a trophy isn't enough, it makes winning the regional championship even more worthwhile.
- It makes winning promotion up the pyramid from AAA to the Pro Leagues more worthwhile.
- Makes competition between regions sanctioned and official.

Cons:
- Takes away from the offseason time so world champions wouldn't begin their signings until day 46.
- Also would not work for contracts which end on Day 40, but would increase incentive to retain players.

Changes which would be needed:
- consideration for end-on-day 40 contracts for teams who make the tournament, e.g. 5-day short term or automatically extend them until championship is over
- consideration for players to be signed after day 40 during World Championship push (allow new signings to compete?)
- 1 more day of offseason (make up with 1 less day of preseason?)

Reasons for a top World League
- More thorough competition (play against all teams)
- No adjustment of offseason

Reasons against a top World League
- Promotion/relegation from Regions: worse teams will stay in a World League while better teams will make the drop if regions are to be kept.
- Removes teams from competing in their regions
- Maintaining competitive balance, e.g. if a team guts/sells (rare, but does happen at that high level)

Originally posted by Bort
W have thought of this idea before, and I think it would work best if we could do the whole tourney sim in one day. In order to do that, we'd need to have some sort of future tactics scheduler. However, if it were done in one day, a lot of the cons go out the window.

End on day 40 contracts definitely throw a wrench into the works, though. Many team rosters explode on day 41, including champions.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by DrkSandman
^ This is exactly what I figured would make this tough.

Bort, would it be at all possible to have a seperate server at some point for things like this, and also for off-season friendlies? So your updates are not having to be put on hold or everying having to be done in one day?

Maybe some sort of roster freeze on Day 40, where current rosters are frozen onto this seperate server, and we can have tournaments or friendlies in the off-season to keep players active.
Hrm, I don't know if that would work, at least off the top of my head. Players and teams need to be consistent for a proper database structure, and we'd want the final data to go onto the live site.

Depending on the size of the tourney, it might be possible to run it all at the end of day 40 as well. There's 4 available hours before the end of the day.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by geturembedder
So this means you are leaning towards the tourney rather than 16 team league?
We've been leaning that way ever since we came up with the champions league idea back in season 2 and everyone freaked out about it.


It appears something has come of this idea: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2081864
Last edited Feb 16, 2009 00:45:24
 
ProfessionalKop
Gangstalicious
offline
Link
 
hmm i like it.
 
Link
 
I like it and the con you mentioned isn't really a con so much as it's realistic, the pats and the giants had to wait to get started with there offseason shit compared to every other team in the league
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I bet Fight Club from Africa Pro would win
 
JRice80
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I bet Fight Club from Africa Pro would win


wouldn't doubt it with all of the owner's that thebigcali has ripped off in trades. he's lucky he didn't get perma-banned for that.
 
jprietman
offline
Link
 
the 3 round playoff sounds great

the champions league sounds horrible
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I just don't see a way to properly implement an entire league of it. It would be too difficult to process promotion/relegation if it wasn't done alongside the regular season, and doing that would cause some insanity for owners dealing with twice the amount of games. That's why I favored the 3-round playoff.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
I like the playoff idea.
 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
-1
Like you said if a player has a contract that expires on day 40 then he wouldn't be able to participate in it. So you wont truly find out who the best team is.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
My stance is that the offseason is already too long. When you consider the fact that the bad teams are probably not AS invested in the game as the good teams, you are risking losing their interest a lot more. Thjs means higher levels of team turnover and increased parity problems.

If you do not make the playoffs, you are already sitting around for about 20 days and 6 or so of those you do NOTHING.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
My stance is that the offseason is already too long. When you consider the fact that the bad teams are probably not AS invested in the game as the good teams, you are risking losing their interest a lot more. Thjs means higher levels of team turnover and increased parity problems.

If you do not make the playoffs, you are already sitting around for about 20 days and 6 or so of those you do NOTHING.


This
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I'm not in favor of extending the offseason, if that's what you're implying. Perhaps it could go in along with the preseason scrimmages from day -6 to day -2. You wouldn't get the players whose contracts ended on Day 40, but it's all the more incentive to re-sign them. It's not that likely that you'd want to leave a Pro League team that won its championship for more money or a better team, is it?
 
SKADOODLE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I'm not in favor of extending the offseason, if that's what you're implying. Perhaps it could go in along with the preseason scrimmages from day -6 to day -2. You wouldn't get the players whose contracts ended on Day 40, but it's all the more incentive to re-sign them. It's not that likely that you'd want to leave a Pro League team that won its championship for more money or a better team, is it?


Not likely that starters would but I garuntee others will leave.
Last edited Nov 9, 2008 22:55:36
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Well, yeah. But if you want to be the world champion, you'd better have some sort of incentive in place to keep your top difference-makers there: a good, friendly team environment, lots of money, and so on. If you can't hold on to your best players, maybe you don't deserve to be world champion.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Maybe add an exception for players whose on teams contesting the world championship whose contracts end on Day 40?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.