User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Doc_Nilla
offline
Link
 
Unless I'm reading the play description wrong, shouldn't this be a safety?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=264576&pbp_id=174324

9:02 1st & 10 on OWN 3
Gabriel Michaelson rush[forced fumble: Inigo Patinkin], fumbled , recovered by E-roc Dizzle, 0 yds (touchback)

 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Not a Safety because the ball was advanced beyond the goal line before the fumble and it was the fumble which brought the ball back into the endzone prior to recovery. Pretty unlucky though.
 
Kathris
offline
Link
 
Yes, its a safety, otherwise teams on their goalline would always intentionally fumble it back to someone in their endzone to bring the ball out to the 20.
 
Sharrow
offline
Link
 
The only way this is a touchback is if the defender had control of the ball and HE fumbled it into the endzone where the QB recovered it.
 
sportskidd
offline
Link
 
NO SAFTEY

the fumble was batted into the endzone by the defense and the QB fell on it to retain possesion for his team

the ball was not brought into the endzone by the offense it was brought into the endzone by the defense

NO SAFTEY

pretty unlucky
 
creeker22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sharrow
The only way this is a touchback is if the defender had control of the ball and HE fumbled it into the endzone where the QB recovered it.


This is what I think happened. It was a change of possesion and therefore the offense recovered the second fumble and got the touchback
 
Doc_Nilla
offline
Link
 
If batting the ball is in the sim, I can understand it being a touchback. If there had been a change of possession, a second "recovered by/fumbled" section would be listed in the play description.
 
Riggs_Inator
offline
Link
 
Uhhhh... irl that's a safety unless the defense picks up the ball then fumbles it into the end zone. Or knocks it into the end zone. I saw no indication of the ball being hit by the defender. I've seen the ball warp into a players hand on a fumble with nobody nearby.
 
mortalq2
offline
Link
 
Unless the defense had possession of the ball its a safety, this was brought up last season, hopefully it gets fixed soon.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
That's a bugged play. They actually retained possession at the 20 after the touch back. If it wasn't a safety it should have been spotted on the 1 yard line instead they got a first down on the deal and advanced 20 yards.
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Yes it's a bug or something bort screwed the coding up on for proof of the rule look at Tony Romo vs. the Eagles earlier this year.
Last edited Nov 7, 2008 18:56:50
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.