User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Pass deflections not effective. : 35/65 passing, 35 PD. 17/45 21 PD
dimmy finster
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=267592

Passing seems too strong or pass deflections are not effective enough or something.

35/65 passing, 35 PD. 17/45 21 PD

It seems if you deflect 1/2 the passes, you shouldn't end up with over 50% compoletion percentage.

 
Sharrow
offline
Link
 
In that game, deflections were 80% effective (45 for 56 total) in stopping the completion. You team was 75% effective (26 for 35), the other team was 90% effective (19 for 21). So in total, about 1 out of 5 deflections were caught.

Whether this is right or not comes down to how you define a deflection I guess. If you include any time a defender touches the ball period, then maybe it's right. If you define it as any time the defender touches the ball before the offense player does, then it's not quite right.
 
mbking
offline
Link
 
were those stats for both qbs also pd total because if not stats for qb then it makes since one qb got deflected less than 50% and one more than 50%.
 
Link
 
iv seen a HUGE jump in PDs in the first scrimmage my team had...its an alarming rate of PDs

we had 4 or 5 players with 5+ PDs and one CB wiht 10 PDs.

Maybe its just todays game but could be an abboration.
 
AlbinoBlind
offline
Link
 
tell that to my CB...45 tackles 39 PDs last season, meaning he deflected down basically half the passes that came his way. (no deflected passes were caught)

I think you just got unlucky on this particular game.
 
dimmy finster
offline
Link
 
those were both teams. Both teams were messed up, not just mine.

I dno't know all of Sharrow's calculation, but let's say deflections were 80% effective.

team 1: 65 passes. 35 of those were deflected. 35 completions. Basically if deflections should be 80% effective (say 27 INC from deflections), the team went 35/38 in passing on non deflected balls. Even though they suffered 17 hurries and 3 drops. That's just crazy.


team 2: 45 passes. 21 deflected. 17 completions. 80% effective deflections = 16 INC from deflections. So 17/29. 6 drops, so that's 17/23.
Seems way too high given the gameplan (which was long passes).




So either deflections aren't effective enogu, or passing is too strong. Or something is screwy with the deflections algorithm.
Last edited Nov 7, 2008 21:17:13
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.