User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 West Power Rankings
Page:
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL RANKINGS - 4/29
1. Saskatoon Raiders (1-0, 87.1)
2. Mt. Oread Hawk Stars (1-0, 86.3)
3. Thunder Bay Storm (1-0, 84.5)
4. Niagara Knights (1-0, 81.8)
5. Yukon Gold Rush (1-0, 81.3)
6. Blacksburg Ballers (0-1, 79.5)
7. Mooresville Anglers (0-1, 76.1)
8. Forumopolis Fighting Llamas (1-0, 74.1)
9. Moose Knuckle Island Sofa Kings (1-0, 71.4)
10. TSW Titans (0-1, 69.6)
11. North American NDL'ers (0-1, 67.9)
12. Sudbury Spurs (0-1, 67.4)
13. Phoenixville Kings (1-0, 64.2)
14. Chilliwack Devils (0-1, 63.4)
15. Abbotsford Miners (0-1, 53.0)
16. Ottawa Chiefs (0-1, 33.7)

I have to use these rankings to determine upset credits, rather than pre-game 1 rankings like I normally would. According to this though, there were no game 1 upsets, so I would like to point out that my power rankings correctly predicted the winner of ALL SIXTEEN games in Canada AAA #2. Of course with my team as an underdog in game 2 I'm hoping that trend doesn't continue in full...

I would also like to point out, to anyone attempting to compare teams across conferences, that my rankings for the West are 100% independent of my rankings for the East. The teams in the West are comparing their starting lineup to the highest level starters IN THE WEST, while the East teams are compared to the highest level starters IN THE EAST.

For comparison, though, here are the comparative "highest level player" rosters that teams in each conference get compared to at the moment:

Pos..West..East
QB....13...14
HB....12...14
FB....12...12
WR1...12...12
WR2...13...12
TE....14...14
C.....12...13
LOT...14...13
ROT...13...11
LG....12...12
RG....13...12
NT....13...11
DT....12...11
LE....13...13
RE....12...12
MLB...13...12
ROLB..12...12
LOLB..15...13
CB1...13...11
CB2...11...10
FS....13...11
SS....13...12

K.....12...12
P.....11...12

The West has an edge at more positions, but the East has an edge at the two individual positions which most heavily affect a team's rating. All told, some teams would probably grade higher in the East, and others would grade higher in the West, depending on their respective strengths and weaknesses. I will say though that to experiment I swapped top teams, and that the Yetis, #1 in the East at 87.0, grade as an 85.0 when compared to teams 2-16 in the West, while the Raiders go from 87.1 in the West to an 88.7 in the East, so a team from the West is probably slightly stronger than an equivalently ranted team from the East.
Last edited Apr 29, 2008 05:27:33
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Thank you for taking the time to do it. Great write up.
 
redskins0756
offline
Link
 
Great write-up.
 
ajblobaum
offline
Link
 
The significant edge that the Hawk Stars have in the West is our considerable depth on both lines, at LB, and at HB. This should not be discounted in the power rankings. When we sub in one of our reserves, the drop off is not nearly as severe.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ajblobaum
The significant edge that the Hawk Stars have in the West is our considerable depth on both lines, at LB, and at HB. This should not be discounted in the power rankings. When we sub in one of our reserves, the drop off is not nearly as severe.


It won't be discounted as soon as you've used your depth to defeat a team ranked higher than you. Your ranking is based on a combination of your starting lineup strength, AND any upsets you've been involved with.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
Originally posted by ajblobaum

The significant edge that the Hawk Stars have in the West is our considerable depth on both lines, at LB, and at HB. This should not be discounted in the power rankings. When we sub in one of our reserves, the drop off is not nearly as severe.


It won't be discounted as soon as you've used your depth to defeat a team ranked higher than you. Your ranking is based on a combination of your starting lineup strength, AND any upsets you've been involved with.


Hey BJJ, get back to work, all this "ranking" is taking you away from our filmroom, I'm gonna have to change that lock
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ajblobaum
The significant edge that the Hawk Stars have in the West is our considerable depth on both lines, at LB, and at HB. This should not be discounted in the power rankings. When we sub in one of our reserves, the drop off is not nearly as severe.


Hmm, if you feel like you're being underrated because the power rankings ignore a "significant edge" of yours, you should try not to lose to teams rated 18.4 points lower than you...
 
flaredog
offline
Link
 
We'll bounce back though.
 
Booboo Laaug
offline
Link
 
Thanks for taking the time to do this, BJJ.
 
ajblobaum
offline
Link
 
That last game was brutal. Not much else to say.
 
DominicanLou
offline
Link
 
excellent write up, but I'll still like to see how the season progresses with low lvl/cpu backups and the new stamina rules, I think many tough teams will be entering the games below 90 or above w/o any training.
 
Xiidaen
offline
Link
 
Nice write up -- we'll see how it pans out over the season -- lots of games to play.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL RANKINGS 5/1

The NDL'ers victory over Mt. Oread earned major upset credit, as did Sudbury's tie game with Thunder Bay, so the rankings will be shaken up a bit by that.

1. Saskatoon Raiders (2-0, 89.5)
2. Mt. Oread Hawk Stars (1-1, 85.6 [91.9 - 6.3 upset adjustment])
3. Thunder Bay Storm (1-0-1, 83.7 [86.8 - 3.1 upset adjustment])
4. Yukon Gold Rush (2-0, 85.1)
5. Blacksburg Ballers (1-1, 81.8)
6. North American NDL'ers (1-1, 80.0 [73.7 + 6.3 upset adjustment])
7. Mooresville Anglers (1-1, 78.9)
8. Forumopolis Fighting Llamas (1-1, 76.2)
9. Sudbury Spurs (0-1-1, 75.5 [72.4 + 3.1 upset adjustment])
10. Moose Knuckle Island Sofa Kings (2-0, 75.0)
11. TSW Titans (0-2, 72.8)
12. Chilliwack Devils (1-1, 68.7)
13. Phoenixville Kings (1-1, 65.4)
14. Abbotsford Miners (0-2, 58.9)
15. Ottawa Chiefs (0-2, 42.4)
16. San Francisco Sucka Free's (1-1, 37.9)
 
Gwildar
offline
Link
 
Well, after todays matches, with moose knuckle and saskatoon losing, that leaves yukon as the sole undefeated team remaining.

Forumopolis turned in an upset against Thunder Bay, which should shake the rankings up a little bit. As we have learned, SF will probably be at the bottom for the rest of the season.

Mooresville toppled Saskatoon rather handily, so i expect their stock will rise to reflect this.
 
snoodmonger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gwildar
Well, after todays matches, with moose knuckle and saskatoon losing, that leaves yukon as the sole undefeated team remaining.

Forumopolis turned in an upset against Thunder Bay, which should shake the rankings up a little bit. As we have learned, SF will probably be at the bottom for the rest of the season.

Mooresville toppled Saskatoon rather handily, so i expect their stock will rise to reflect this.



The Mooresville win was very impressive.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.