User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Serious Bug Issue: Pathing for Defense at the Goalline
Page:
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=167093&pbp_id=9569048 - what is the LOLB Tech Nine running at, the cheerleaders?

Just one example of a million that people have been complaining about (you'll notice I'm not "whining", because that is MY team scoring the TD). A VERY important issue in GLB:

When defensive players are in pursuit of ball-carriers, they seem to choose a point on the player's path that they can catch them at. Well, 100% of the time near the goalline, this point is well within the endzone. This is most apparent on outside plays in the redzone, as defensive players choose an angle which allows for a TD when they may have been able to make a tackle.

My suggestion is that the defenders run for a point in the runner's path intersects the goalline (or a line 1 yard in front), and not a point behind it.

This bug helps everyone as much as it hurts them, but in all actuality, it's simply silly from a football standpoint.

EDIT: Ya, I know. Poor example, but I'm sure people should be able to come in here with plenty of good ones, because I see this all the time.

EDIT: Another GOOD example of what I'm talking about. Watch the SS:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=204925&pbp_id=10488737

EDIT:
Originally posted by saintedix

Swiftus, you wanted "triginometry", well, here you go:

http://i473.photobucket.com/albums/rr98/saintedix/GLB/PathingExample.jpg

I went into the second example I gave to do some studying. I measured the distance the SS traveled (in pixels) from the tick when both players hit the 50 yard line to the tick just before the WR crosses the goalline. I then drew a line from the SS's initial position to his final position to get an approximation of his "range" of travel in the time it took the WR to get from the 50 to the goalline. I drew a black circle representing the area that can be traveled by the SS in this time. The yellow lines are of equal length, and the SS markers are centered on the end points of the lines. Long story short, with this visual representation, is there any doubt that Bort needs to add a cutoff point at the goalline? The SS CLEARLY has a tackle chance.

Note: The path on the left is the ACTUAL path traveled by the SS.
Last edited Oct 30, 2008 17:58:51
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Hell what was the SS thinking there? That should have been 5-10 YAC at the most if he'd been thinking.

YOu're right, that's a crappy example ...but you're also right that it happens all the time and really needs to be fixed.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
This has been brought up like a hundred times. Maybe this time it gets noticed?

I'm all for it!
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
This has been brought up like a hundred times. Maybe this time it gets noticed?

I'm all for it!


Yeah, and no matter how many times people bring it up, I don't think Bort has ever commented on it...maybe this time he'll take notice. I know people have been frustrated with this for a few seasons now.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Hehe, I posted about this a few weeks ago with the same suggestion... add a script that if a defender's pursuit angle would take him into the end zone, it instead takes him to a point along the 1 yard line where the ball carrier will pass.

Would take too long to find the replay example I used when I posted before, but it was actually a goalline run vs goalline defense, where my MLB and SS were both set to blitz, and they started in and would have easily met the HB at the 2 or 3 yard line, but when the runner got the ball, they stopped and changed their pursuit angles, moving laterally while still in the end zone and never got a tackle attempt. Yeah, "agility", but when they're having to use agility because they're doing retarded things, it's a problem with the sim.
 
Link
 
If the point where he would catch him is in the end zone though, then taking a sharper angle isn't going to change anything.

It will just make him 5 yard behind him instead of 5 yards beside him. What is the difference?
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 06:30:36
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
If the point where he would catch him is in the end zone though, then taking a sharper angle isn't going to change anything. It will just make him 5 yard behind him instead of 5 yards beside him. What is the difference?


That is true. I suppose it would be easy enough to make the cutoff point's Y axis always get set to the goalline if it's beyond it, but would it make a difference?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

If the point where he would catch him is in the end zone though, then taking a sharper angle isn't going to change anything. It will just make him 5 yard behind him instead of 5 yards beside him. What is the difference?


That is true. I suppose it would be easy enough to make the cutoff point's Y axis always get set to the goalline if it's beyond it, but would it make a difference?



.....probably like #946 on the list of things to do imo.

Especially because no one trips or just drops the ball in the sim without being touched (like could happen in real life).

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Especially because no one trips or just drops the ball in the sim without being touched (like could happen in real life).



LOL, could you imagine if they did? Random fumble or falling down for no reason - complaints would never end.

One thing I thought of that COULD happen in the sim: I guess sometimes a player might get a missed tackle from behind that slows them down, and if the other player had taken a shallower angle he could make the play.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Especially because no one trips or just drops the ball in the sim without being touched (like could happen in real life).



LOL, could you imagine if they did? Random fumble or falling down for no reason - complaints would never end.

One thing I thought of that COULD happen in the sim: I guess sometimes a player might get a missed tackle from behind that slows them down, and if the other player had taken a shallower angle he could make the play.


True.

But wouldn't he take a new angle after the player slows down? I don't know how often that is calculated.

On the other hand, the ball carrier could be forced to run into the defender's optimal route if a defender is on the opposite side (a cutback).

If it isn't hard to fix, it wouldn't be a bad idea to change the angle to the point where the runner is projected to cross the goal line, but if it could open up new glitches, then I wouldn't worry about it.

Especially when there seems to be some little bugs surrounding the end zone as it is already (see the other bug thread at the top about "running a play from the -3.5 yard line").

Did the bug about the AI reading 4th and goal at the 8 as equal to 4th and 0 get fixed? I haven't tried it since early in the season when I first noticed it. (I had it set to go for it if 4th and less than 2, but it kept going for it on any 4th and goal)
Last edited Oct 23, 2008 06:53:30
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yes, he'd recalculate the route when the player slowed down, but if he has poor agility, he'd have to slow down to turn as well.

I don't see how changing the cutoff point would introduce new problems as long as it's just for the "tackle" code. Of course, I'm working on a small amount of sleep at the moment so I might come up with something if I go think about it later.

The 4th and goal thing should work properly at this point AFAIK. I haven't seen any bug reports for quite some time on it, and I tested it several times.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


The 4th and goal thing should work properly at this point AFAIK. I haven't seen any bug reports for quite some time on it, and I tested it several times.


It is hard to get a 4th down and goal against a bad team in a meaningless game. My guys seem to keep going into the end zone.

Last edited Oct 23, 2008 07:05:05
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
That is true. I suppose it would be easy enough to make the cutoff point's Y axis always get set to the goalline if it's beyond it, but would it make a difference?


Even if it were ONLY a cosmetic difference and never changed the outcome of a play, it would at least stop these posts from happening?

Personally, I'd like to see it just for that reason. In real life a guy is gonna run as hard as he can to defend the goal line, and if he doesn't get there in time, he doesn't...but he's still defending the goal line. He's not defending 5 yards into the goal line.

So, I say if it's an easy fix make it. It doesn't hurt anything and only makes the sim look better, IMHO.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
Actually what should have happened is that there was a block in the back penalty on WR Dede Catchings on the FS so the TD should have been negated and the ball backed up from the line of scrimmage.

That's a bug that needs to be fixed because offensive players shouldn't be able to block a player any way they want to.
 
saintedix
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

If the point where he would catch him is in the end zone though, then taking a sharper angle isn't going to change anything. It will just make him 5 yard behind him instead of 5 yards beside him. What is the difference?


That is true. I suppose it would be easy enough to make the cutoff point's Y axis always get set to the goalline if it's beyond it, but would it make a difference?


Actually Bort, about 90% of the time it probably wouldn't make a difference. But there are a good deal of plays where a better route WOULD have taken the defender into a position to make a tackle. Basically, here's what I'm saying:

http://i473.photobucket.com/albums/rr98/saintedix/GLB/pathing.jpg

The red line is the route the defender takes now, allowing a TD. The green line is where he SHOULD go and attempt a diving tackle. There are limited instances where this is actually applicable, especially on pitch/sweep plays and tosses to the HB in the flat on the outside.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.