User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
I have noticed that several of the top teams in here don't have their current rosters signed past day 1 of season 6.

13-1 Skaro Daleks: 1 of 47 players (he is signed to day 8 of season 6)

14-0 Taipei Dragons: 9 of 42 players

12-2 Guangzhou United Fight Club: 1 of 40 players

Is this a financial strategy to save money during the season or is there something I'm missing?

There is a lot I don't know about this game so I was wondering if there was a benefit I didn't know about for signing short term contracts vs long term contracts.
 
jay4roch
offline
Link
 
I would think that it would be to save money. Dakota has several players that have agreed to resign, but we are waiting until the end of the season to resign them. I haven't done the math to figure out what the difference will be for our bottom line, but I imagine that it is somewhat significant.
 
wallyopd
offline
Link
 
I would think it would actually be more expensive in the long run. Since the minimum contract amount goes up as you level, long-term deals can lock in guys at a much lower rate.
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Wally is correct. Long term contracts save money, but short term contracts attract better players because of lower risk.

Also, short term contracts act as a signal to the market. For example, Groucho is a great owner, so he can offer shorter contracts with the expectation that people will like playing for him and re-sign with his team. Another owner I know (in Western Europe) treats his players like trash, so he only offers 2-3 season contracts with the expectation that people will leave as soon as their contract expires. This also allows short term contract to pull in better players.

Skaro had this same policy last season, and only lost a handful of players, and they were easily replaced on the FA market. Then again, if Skaro didn't make the playoffs, we probably would have lost 10-15 guys. So it's a risk.

Note: I don't do any recruiting or roster management for Skaro, so I'm not speaking as a GM, just as a player.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 07:39:25
 
OSUmike03
offline
Link
 
It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.
 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


I guess that depends on if you are a owner, or an agent. What is good for one isn't necessarily the best for the other.
 
OSUmike03
offline
Link
 
Anyone who plays this as a "agent" would have to be bored out of their mind. I play this as a owner/coach. I care about my team. I'd much rather be on a playoff team every year then to have a ton of money thrown my way. It's not like my fake players have familes to feed.
 
wallyopd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


I don't have any insight beyond being a player on the team, but Skaro's finances seem pretty solid.
 
matta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


Well if you can't get past the primary issue and see the ancillary impact of such a decision, then yeah, it must look pretty stupid. It must be fun to have such a myopic view of life.

 
jonw9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
Anyone who plays this as a "agent" would have to be bored out of their mind. I play this as a owner/coach. I care about my team. I'd much rather be on a playoff team every year then to have a ton of money thrown my way. It's not like my fake players have familes to feed.


No, but there are player here complaining that there isn't enough "bling" available.

I am an agent only, and I am not bored out of my mind (except during the off-season). I have a vested interest in making the team better. But their short term contracts aren't costing me anything.
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by OSUmike03

It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


Well if you can't get past the primary issue and see the ancillary impact of such a decision, then yeah, it must look pretty stupid. It must be fun to have such a myopic view of life.



'Atta matta!
 
OSUmike03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by OSUmike03

It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


Well if you can't get past the primary issue and see the ancillary impact of such a decision, then yeah, it must look pretty stupid. It must be fun to have such a myopic view of life.



We'll see who's team is in better shape in 3 seasons. We'll probably have a completed stadium with plenty of revenue while still making the playoffs year in and year out.

Signing committed players early does nothing but good things for the team as a whole. Waiting to sign people, you have to throw more money at them, you have to pray they aren't jerks who will comlpain all the time, and it can hurt your chemistry and morale.

Basically...we are taking the Rays approach, while you are taking the Yankees approach.

How's that working for them?
 
GOLee
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSUmike03
Originally posted by matta

Originally posted by OSUmike03


It isn't a strategy. They are just really stupid, if you ask me. That costs you a ton of money in the long run.


Well if you can't get past the primary issue and see the ancillary impact of such a decision, then yeah, it must look pretty stupid. It must be fun to have such a myopic view of life.



We'll see who's team is in better shape in 3 seasons. We'll probably have a completed stadium with plenty of revenue while still making the playoffs year in and year out.

Signing committed players early does nothing but good things for the team as a whole. Waiting to sign people, you have to throw more money at them, you have to pray they aren't jerks who will comlpain all the time, and it can hurt your chemistry and morale.

Basically...we are taking the Rays approach, while you are taking the Yankees approach.

How's that working for them?

Agents and players don't go inactive in the MLB. They don't ever boost either, or have custom-equipment, or stop boosting and lose interest in their sport for that matter.

Apples to oranges.
 
OSUmike03
offline
Link
 
It's not really apples to oranges. Your reasoning is the exact point I made. Constantly bringing in new people give you MORE of a chance to find guys that are gonna not boost, cry about playing time, or go inactive. There's less of a chance for that to happen if you are keeping the same team year after year.

I'm just saying....it would SEEM more likely to be setting up for both financial and team problems if you only play things year by year, bringing in all new talent, and all that stuff.

I'm sure there are teams out there in GLB-land that do it every year and are successful. But I bet there are more that do it the other way and are successful as well.
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
I can see both sides of the argument. I have went for the long term investment in hopes to save salary and keep the team as a unit. But yesterday I get a PM from a guy who is taking over the account of a guy on my team. The account being taken over has 2 players on my team locked up for 2 more season. Well this new guy wants me to release them so he can retire them.

so GOLee has a good point when he says people loose interest or things change after 40 days.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.