User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > CB's Engage in blocks, when HB is long behind them
Page:
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Can't say I've noticed before, but by the same token that probably means I'm just ignorant

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141984&pbp_id=8431887

Just wondering what the logic is of the CB's, as one of the last lines of defence they basically stay "tied up" until it's too late to begin pursuit. Wouldn't be so bad if they were the wrong side of the WR, but the replays basically give the impression that the WR's are trying to catch a piggyback.

Obviously there's no way of knowing which way they're facing, but it seems that the game engine doesn't "recognise" differentiate between engaging in blocking assignments, vs pursuing a man already heading downfield through the middle ground.

An issue others have experienced, or just a symptom of not having 99 strength CB's?
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
I've noticed this before and its a major issue, IMO...it would take a crappy player indeed to continue being blocked (yet apparently not pancaked) when all they have to do is turn 180 degrees and the play is "over there", ready to be pursued.

Sure, that takes a few steps, but the game is very unrealistic in this regard, leading to some longer runs and YACs than really make sense.

Good job OP, though I don't think the example you gave really illustrates the problem...wish I had time to dig through old games, but the problem you described certainly looks like a bug to me.
Last edited Oct 17, 2008 16:01:07
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
This was brought to Borts attention several weeks ago, in a HB Pathing/Blocking assignments thread.

I'll try to find it, but the general problems raised were...

* Players still engaged in blocks when the ball carrier is behind them, often for long periods of time. (AKA 'Suction Blocks')

* CBs should know that when they are downfield and the WR tries to block them it is a run play. (Football logic) At which point they are told to take an angle to cover the endzone, not neccessarily make the tackle.

* WRs with less than 10 in Strength and Blocking each are maintaining blocks on DBs with over 35 strength, consistently.

* WRs are able to 'block' more than one player in the open field.

Bort saw it, and was active in the thread, his general replies were... (Not quotes and just from my memory!)

- He doesnt like the blocking as it is, particularly 'Suction Blocks' and actually thinks all blocks are engaged for too long. But didnt want to make sacks any easier.

Three solutions were offered, either making WRs less adept at blocking or decrease the chance of the WR ENGAGING a block at all.
Or finally, have slightly different scripts for OL vs DL blocking and 'Open field blocking'.

The third Idea was most realistic and suitable, the more open space their is, the easier it is to avoid a block happening, as DB vs WR happen in the open field this should help the issues without increasing sacks.

After discussion, reducing blocking was not going to work, as currently there is no need to add to strength or blocking at all for a WR to make a effective block.
The bias For the WR is atleast 20 SP (A 10 Strength + 10 Blocking WR will hold a block on a 40 Strength SS every time.)

The idea of decreasing the chance to Engage the block was ok, but not exactly perfect and a clumsy workaround at best, subject to too much RNG.

bort Agreed that having CBs get off blocks earlier or avoid completely being blocked needed looking at, discussion was about which attributes were most logical.
Vision (Football knowledge) for knowing better than getting caught in a block downfield?
Agility to be able to avoid the block in the open field (Had problems with BLs getting free in run game.
Strength to break the block, doesnt make a difference at the moment, and most felt that it should do.

Bort also Wanted to be sure that WRs with decent strength and Blocking could still be effective at blocking weaker players.

The last I heard Bort was going to think about ways to get WRs built to block to be successful, without having the problems we have now of any WR being able to make a block.

My final suggestion was (Roughly)

1 Make adjustment to Maximum Block Length based on available space.
2 Make WR strength + blocking need to be at least 75% of DB strength in order to avoid being pancaked.
3 Include the velocity of any additional influences on the Block mechanism, (If WR is blocking a CB and a SS runs into the CBs back the calculations should account for this extra force, to stop WRs stack blocking DBS.)

These should leave the Interior blocking as it is now, which while not great, seems the best we can hope for.
but it stops outside runs gaining a TD because a 10 strength WR blocks a Cb and a SS at one time.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
How about momentum as an element of blocking for WR's? Presumably as a WR accelerates they should "hit" and therefore block better. In comparison a CB attempting to "exit" the area should be able to break the block better - perhaps as a modified agility value once "engaged"?

Of course, completely avoiding the engagement would be better still.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
I don't understand any of this. The WRs on my team that have poor Str/Blocking are consistently bad at holding blocks. The ones that are strong/better blockers hold better. I can watch pbp and know who was doing the blocking just by watching the result (and then confirm my intuition by looking at the actual list of players for a play).
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 13:01:54
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Ok, let me say that I understand the problem with suction (i.e., nondirectional blocking. Or blocking that ignores the proper facing of the player - essentially holding.)

However, I do not see WRs with terrible Str/Blocking being good blockers, ever.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
I don't understand any of this. The WRs on my team that have poor Str/Blocking are consistently bad at holding blocks. The ones that are strong/better blockers hold better. I can watch pbp and know who was doing the blocking just by watching the result (and then confirm my intuition by looking at the actual list of players for a play).


This is definitely my experience as well. The "suction" blocks are a bit much at times, however.
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 14:50:58
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
OK here is the first example I can find to illustrate, where I know all the builds involved.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141543&pbp_id=6995293 :

WR1 (Jon Horton) holds a block for 5 Seconds, his Blocking is 10 and Strength 13.
CB1 has only 23 Strength.

I am happy that in a equal match up the WR holds his block.

But should it really be for 5 seconds?
And continue when the CB only needs to turn around to pursue the ball carrier?

I have never ever seen this WR miss a Block, fail to hold a block or be pancaked, and he has blocked SSs and LBs.

Hell I have seen WRs on ST blocking DTs!
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
I'm sure I can find better The GRD runs a fine line in WR's maintaining blocks, so much so we invested in custom equipment Concrete Shoes.

We've seen less since pitch plays went out of vogue.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
And continue when the CB only needs to turn around to pursue the ball carrier?


This is the biggest problem, IMO.

Don't enough of rest of matchup to say. IMO, 20 Str and 13 Str are both pretty much 0. That WR have good Agility?
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Agility and speed were about equal as well.

CB had better Vision, WR better Catching

Basic point is regardless of the level of the attributes (10 vs 10 or 100 vs 100) in a even match up should one side always have the supreme advantage?

But the examples that I mean are when that WR is blocking DBs and LB with 48+ Strength.
Last edited Oct 18, 2008 18:08:28
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Good job OP, though I don't think the example you gave really illustrates the problem...wish I had time to dig through old games, but the problem you described certainly looks like a bug to me.


Well, it does.

Watch Elm Renfro (CB2) he's inside the WR and heading into the midfield to get the HB...but gets pulled (or for some reason turns) to engage in a block with the WR and stays there until the HB is long gone.

On the other side Bongo is less clear of the WR but is making clear progress into the middle to chase down the HB (or at least pursue the play).

Wouldn't even be so bad if we saw the CB's pancaked, or taken out of the play with a block - but they're just tangled with from behind.

It's either offensive holding, or silly AI.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Can't say I've noticed before, but by the same token that probably means I'm just ignorant

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141984&pbp_id=8431887

Just wondering what the logic is of the CB's, as one of the last lines of defence they basically stay "tied up" until it's too late to begin pursuit. Wouldn't be so bad if they were the wrong side of the WR, but the replays basically give the impression that the WR's are trying to catch a piggyback.

Obviously there's no way of knowing which way they're facing, but it seems that the game engine doesn't "recognise" differentiate between engaging in blocking assignments, vs pursuing a man already heading downfield through the middle ground.

An issue others have experienced, or just a symptom of not having 99 strength CB's?


This is tied to the CB vision issue I've mentioned earlier. CB's have no particular sense of direction. My issue is that they shouldn't get faked out when they're facing away from the QB. Your issue is that they shouldn't continue to remain engaged in blocks. But both result from the fact that they have no sense of which direction they're facing.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure if it's directional facing, but certainly they seem to make odd reads that reults in them engaging in blocks instead of pursuing their target despite the WR's clearly posing absolutely no threat as it's obviously a run at the point when they're snared.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Agility and speed were about equal as well.

CB had better Vision, WR better Catching

Basic point is regardless of the level of the attributes (10 vs 10 or 100 vs 100) in a even match up should one side always have the supreme advantage?

But the examples that I mean are when that WR is blocking DBs and LB with 48+ Strength.


I think in even match-ups blocking's generally going to win, ya.

I haven't really seen WRs doing much to my LBs or big DBs.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.