User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Europe West AAA League > Europe West AAA #1 > Important News Regarding Promotion to WEPL
Page:
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Rules for promotions to fill the spots of sold teams:
Since we've got to fill the slots of sold teams that will be vacated at the end of this season, promotion order will be sorted by the following criteria and season stats, in order, amongst the eligible teams in the 2 leagues below them:

1. Number of playoff victories
2. Number of playoff games participated in (this covers the first round losers over the non playoff teams)
3. Postseason scrimmage wins (not friendlies)
4. Postseason scrimmage ties (not friendlies)
5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)
11. Regular season wins
12. Regular season ties
13. Regular season points scored
14. Regular season points against (lower is better)
15. Random selection.

This makes it so we end up going down through the rounds, and the playoff scrimmage games vs the other league end up counting as to whether you can get promoted or not, assuming there are teams above you to take their place.


WEPL is expecting to have Two teams removed via this new system, 1 Alpha and 1 Zeta, so please be aware that you are playing for additional Play Off spots this Season.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 19:16:38
 
Indy_Clark
offline
Link
 
Thanks Mike, appreciate the post
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Just to get this right, is it total team career playoff victories or just this year?

This is important. Picture this:

Ravens have 3 playoff losses. If they get to the final this year and lose it they will be 2-4 in p/o wins and losses. (0-3 from previous years and 2-1 this year)

Compare them with Ice & Fire who have been to the playoffs twice, 3-0 (not counting the Div game win) and 2-1 for a total record of 5-1. Even if we lose the first round, we'd be at 5-2 at worst.

In that case, we'd have a free card for the Pros if the Ravens got to & lost the final. Not sure that's fair. (and this excludes the results & records of other teams of course)

And does the playoffs count the Div final?
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 03:03:50
 
Narkle
offline
Link
 
That system looks pretty stupid anyway, so whatever.
 
Rix2Sam
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arya Stark
Just to get this right, is it total team career playoff victories or just this year?

This is important. Picture this:

Ravens have 3 playoff losses. If they get to the final this year and lose it they will be 2-4 in p/o wins and losses. (0-3 from previous years and 2-1 this year)

Compare them with Ice & Fire who have been to the playoffs twice, 3-0 (not counting the Div game win) and 2-1 for a total record of 5-1. Even if we lose the first round, we'd be at 5-2 at worst.

In that case, we'd have a free card for the Pros if the Ravens got to & lost the final. Not sure that's fair. (and this excludes the results & records of other teams of course)

And does the playoffs count the Div final?


I strongly suspect it's just this year.
 
thelanger
offline
Link
 
It has to be just this year.

Otherwise it would be nonsense!



@ Arya: We always count that Div game win!
6-1 in the Playoffs

Plus that win vs GRDs with the 8 50 yard FGs counts for 2!
7-1
 
Sonic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thelanger
It has to be just this year.

Otherwise it would be nonsense!



@ Arya: We always count that Div game win!
6-1 in the Playoffs

Plus that win vs GRDs with the 8 50 yard FGs counts for 2!
7-1


I hear that those with that kind of points tally only get to play in the African Pro leagues.
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Rules for promotions to fill the spots of sold teams:
Since we've got to fill the slots of sold teams that will be vacated at the end of this season, promotion order will be sorted by the following criteria and season stats, in order, amongst the eligible teams in the 2 leagues below them:

1. Number of playoff victories
2. Number of playoff games participated in (this covers the first round losers over the non playoff teams)
3. Postseason scrimmage wins (not friendlies)
4. Postseason scrimmage ties (not friendlies)
5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)
11. Regular season wins
12. Regular season ties
13. Regular season points scored
14. Regular season points against (lower is better)
15. Random selection.

This makes it so we end up going down through the rounds, and the playoff scrimmage games vs the other league end up counting as to whether you can get promoted or not, assuming there are teams above you to take their place.



Actually it's not obvious, which is why i asked the question. Why make the first tiebreaker being the number of play off victories?

If that was the case, you'd just compare the two losing conf finalists and skip criteria #1 & #2.

Even if you start the list with the final league standings and go 1 & 2 etc etc, you'd still just hit the losing finalists each time. It's only at criteria 3 when there's the possibility of having a difference which will happen ANYWAY as the losing finalists scrimmage against each other. Essentially what this list says if it's this season only is:

2x Conf champs Autopromote
If 1x extra slot, the winner of final scrimmage game between losing finalists goes up and that's only if you are not sticking strictly to Alpha/Zeta eligability
If 2x extra slots, one each conf., the losers of the Conf. finals both go up.

No need for criteria after that.
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 06:27:09
 
thelanger
offline
Link
 
There's a need for criteria after that if theres more than 2 people getting demoted above them maybe?
 
Sonic
offline
Link
 
It's probably to differentiate between teams that have a similar record.
 
Narkle
offline
Link
 
It's probably because they decided they needed a system that was approaching the NFL tie breakers in obtuseness.
 
Beerski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thelanger
There's a need for criteria after that if theres more than 2 people getting demoted above them maybe?


Yup, that's the reason. Promotion is set up like this:

Team 1: Winner of Conference Championship
Team 2: Loser of Conference Championship
Team 3: Loser of 2nd Round with better record in final scrimmage game
-->If tied, then goes to playoff point differential, then to last scrimmage game point differential
Team 4: Other loser of 2nd Round

It's set up to keep going down the list until enough teams are promoted to replace gutted teams that are being demoted.
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Narkle
It's probably because they decided they needed a system that was approaching the NFL tie breakers in obtuseness.


Nah, Beerski, I'm going with Narkle's explaination.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Yeah in a few of the other Regions you have leagues losing up to 7 teams from a League, so verious tiebreakers were needed.

For your league you have...

WEPL, losing 2 teams per Conference via relegation.
Additional expected to be losing 2 teams via sellbacks.

Total positions available = 6 (Expected)

AAA#1 - Promoting two Conference Champions.
AAA#2 - Promoting two Conference Champions.

AAA#1 Conference runners up face off in final scrimmage game to see who finishes 3rd and 4th in the league.

AAA#2 Conference runners up face off in final Scrimmage game to see who finishes 3rd and 4th in the league.

The 3rd place teams from AAA#1 and AAA#2 are ranked by the Avg points difference in their play off games, so which ever has the biggest margin of victory is ranked as the first prospective Promotee via restructuring.

The same happens for the 4th placed teams. (and all teams that lose in the play offs.)

So for example;

Promoted (Automatically)

1st AAA#1 Champion (+100 points in playoffs)
2nd AAA#2 Champion (+50 points in playoffs)
3rd AAA#1 Runner up (+70 points in playoffs)
4th AAA#2 Runner Up (+60 points in playoffs)
----------------
Prospective Promotion Via restructuring

AAA#1 Alpha Runner up beats AAA#1 Zeta Runner up.
AAA#2 Zeta Runner up beats AAA#2 Alpha Runner up.

5th AAA#1 Alpha Runner up (+50 points in playoffs, + 20 points in post season scrimmage.)
6th AAA#2 Zeta Runner up (+50 points in playoffs, + 10 points in post season scrimmage)

Hope that clears things up (yeah right)


My main point here is that when your knocked out of the Play offs, you are still possibly playing for a promotion spot, and its likely to be post season scrimmages and margin of victory that decides things.

So dont dick about with tactics or put defense on offense etc and then complain about it later, basically.
Last edited Oct 16, 2008 13:04:27
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Its likely to be post season scrimmages and margin of victory that decides things.

So dont dick about with tactics or put defense on offense etc and then complain about it later, basically.


Who, us?

Edit: thanks!

Last edited Oct 17, 2008 01:57:30
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.