User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #2 > Canada AAA#2 East Power Rankings
Page:
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
I have developed a 100% mathematical (and therefore theoretically unbiased) power ranking system that I will be using to rank our Conference on a game-by-game basis. The official pre-season rankings won't be released until tonight after training and to hopefully include as many offseason boosts as possible, for optimal accuracy. In the meantime though, I want to use this post to fully disclose the formula. If you don't care, that's fair, this will definitely be tl;dr, so just enjoy the rankings when they come out. For the mathematically inclined though, enjoy:

The system has two components. One component is a power ranking based on the current starting lineup which I will explain first. The preseason rankings will be based entirely on this factor. The second component will an adjustment based on actual game results, that should hopefully, over time, account for errors in the roster rankings.

Roster Power Rankings: To begin with, I put every team's starting lineup in a spreadsheet. Right now, I'm looking ONLY at the level of each starter. Backups and builds are ignored (this is the primary source of error that component two will have to adjust for). CPU players are universally treated as the equivalent of a level 1 human player, regardless of the CPU's actual level. Holes in the lineup are treated as level 0. Each player is then graded against the other players at his position (WR1 and WR2 are considered separate positions, as are LOT and ROT, etc...). A player who is the highest level in the Conference at his position will be rated 100, anyone else will be linearly scaled (so if the best player were a 10, an 8 would become an 80, etc...).

Next, using the scaled player ratings, I give each team a separate rating in pass offense, rush offense, pass defense, and rush defense, using weighted averages of the players' relative importance to that aspect of the game. These are the crude formulas I'm using:

Pass Offense: (QB + (WR1 + WR2)/2 + TE/5 + (OL AVG)/2)/2.7
Rush Offense: (HB + FB/5 + (OL AVG))/2.2
Pass Defense: (CB1 + CB2 + (S AVG) + (DE AVG)*.75 + (LB AVG)/2)/4.25
Rush Defense: ((DT AVG) + (DE AVG)/2 + (LB AVG))/2.5

Then, I average the pass and run numbers together to get overall Offense and Defense rankings, and finally I average these numbers together to give the team its final Overall Power Ranking.

Adjustments: The power ranking is obviously not perfect. It will change each week as rosters change and players level up, but it also has systematic flaws that will get exposed when teams are "upset" by lower rated teams. To adjust for these upsets, any team that defeats a higher rated team (based on roster ratings AT GAME TIME) will receive an "upset bonus" equal to the difference in roster ratings. The higher rated team will receive an equal "upset penalty". These bonuses and penalties will be capped at 5-10, I'm not sure yet. Teams that are overrated in the roster ratings (because they lack depth, or their starters are poorly built and perform below their level, or because of poor game planning and tactics, or whatever other reason) will see their ranking drop, even as their roster rating remains high, as they lose games they "shouldn't" have. Underrated teams, with positive intangibles, will similarly see their ranking rise.
 
Link
 
Congrats BJJ, you've sucessfully sucked all the fun out of Power rankings
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
OFFICIAL PRESEASON POWER RANKINGS

Upset bonuses for game 1 will be based off of these rankings:

1. Arctic Bay Yetis (TOT: 85.5, OFF: 85.1, DEF: 85.9)
A level 12 QB and a pair of level 11 WRs, as well as the best LOT in the league, give the Yetis the best passing offense out there while the rushing attack ranks #2. With 15 starters at level 10+ and none lower than level 8, this is the best starting lineup in the conference. The offense ranks #2, defense #1.

2. Niagara Jeanhorns (TOT: 80.9, OFF: 81.0, DEF: 80.7)
The Jeanhorns grade as the third best defense in the conference, anchored by a very strong defensive line. Offensively the #3 passing attack and #4 rushing attack combine to rank 4th in the league.

3. Iqaluit Packers (TOT: 80.7, OFF: 78.3, DEF: 83.1)
This is the second best defense, and with level 9 and 11 DTs and 3 LBs at 10+, is the best run defense in the conference.

4. West Texas Widowermakers (TOT: 80.3, OFF: 82.7, DEF: 77.9)
A level 12 HB and 3 level 12 offensive linemen compose the second best rushing offense in the conference. Excellent cornerbacks and defensive ends give them the second best pass defense in the league as well, but the run defense grades lower with level 7 defensive tackles and two level 7 linebackers.

5. Reading Redskins (TOT: 79.3, OFF: 85.8, DEF: 75.7)
High powered offense and questionable defense proved successful for the Redskins in the second half of last season, and will be the formula they turn to again. Edd Everest is the best QB in the league, though his help isn't quite as good as what the Yetis offer so the pass offense grades second in the conference while a level 14 HB leads the best rushing attack. Defensively though, five players below level 8 knock the ratings down quite a bit.

6. The Usual Suspects (TOT: 75.1, OFF: 74.5, DEF: 75.7)
The Suspects show a noticeable drop off from the teams ahead of them, but the squad is solid.

7. Dallas Desparados (TOT: 75.0, OFF: 73.1, DEF: 76.9)
Dallas is home to the third best pass defense in the conference.

8. Ottawa Bills (TOT: 73.5, OFF: 71.2, DEF: 75.8)
And the fourth best pass defense is in Ottawa.

9. Brown Trout (TOT: 72.2, OFF: 70.5, DEF: 73.9)
Being the deepest team in the league last year had a downside, the starters got less plays and it shows when you compare starting lineups. The Trout will have to rely on depth again if they want to get back to the Conference Title Game.

10. Hudson Howlers (TOT: 64.1, OFF: 56.9, DEF: 71.2)
The Howlers are the last team that looks to be a legitimate playoff contender. This rating is getting dragged down by a level 4 HB, but they are otherwise not rated too far behind the top 9.

11. Vancouver Darksiders (TOT: 49.1, OFF: 52.8, DEF: 45.5)
With two CPU starters and only four human players at level 8+, the Darksiders aren't much of a contender, but they still have a solid enough team that they probably aren't in danger of relegation.

12. Ottawa Ambassadors (TOT: 43.1, OFF: 35.9, DEF: 50.2)
Only two CPUs, but only two level 8+ humans.

13. Halifax United (TOT: 34.0, OFF: 31.9, DEF: 36.1)
A solid core of six level 8+ humans could become a much better team if the 12 CPU starters are cleared out.

14: Sparta Mustangs (TOT: 31.6, OFF: 31.5, DEF: 31.7)
Sparta has enough talent that could possibly move up another spot if they filled out their depth chart

15. Niagra Falls Cascade (TOT: 30.8, OFF: 36.4, DEF: 25.2)
Only 7 CPU starters, but the vast majority of the humans are level 4 or below.

16: Iowa Blackhawks (TOT: 30.0, OFF: 45.2, DEF: 14.8)
The offense shows good promise, but so far the defense contains only two human players.
Last edited Apr 27, 2008 04:36:09
 
Link
 
Looks about right.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Congrats BJJ, you've sucessfully sucked all the fun out of Power rankings


I try! I'm used to doing college football power rankings, where all I have to go on is wins, losses, and scores. Getting to incorporate "player level" makes me giddy, lol. Math FTW!
 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
only boosted 1 player so far. no need for firsy few games i think

plus you may have underestimated TEs and FBs considering our TE finished TOP in recieved tds and my FB got 5 rushing TDs last season.

But a really good job, im not saying it is bad im just sugesting ways of improving it.
Last edited Apr 26, 2008 18:16:45
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrTea
only boosted 1 player so far. no need for firsy few games i think

plus you may have underestimated TEs and FBs considering our TE finished TOP in recieved tds and my FB got 5 rushing TDs last season.

But a really good job, im not saying it is bad im just sugesting ways of improving it.


Yeah, good point. The formulas are certainly crude and improvable. I may tweak those a bit down the line, but for now I think I'm gonna stick with these flawed ones and hope the upset adjustments overcome the flaws. TEs are tricky because some TEs really help the pass game, and some really help the run game, but few do both, so any formula will over or under rate the TE in one of those two areas...

As for boosting, of course if you've only boosted once you're in a better position than a team that grades the same as you but has boosted 2-3 times already.
 
MiniHusk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BobJoeJim
UNOFFICIAL PRESEASON POWER RANKINGS

1. Arctic Bay Yetis (TOT: 84.2, OFF: 86.4, DEF: 81.9)
A level 12 QB and a pair of level 11 WRs, as well as the best LOT in the league, give the Yetis the best passing offense out there while the rushing attack ranks #2. With 12 starters at level 10+ and only one starter lower than level 8 (a level 7 CB), this is the best starting lineup in the league.

You might want to rethink this. We are running a 4-3. The Lv7 player is a backup LB listed as a RILB in a 3-4.

 
TesT
offline
Link
 
The Yetis also have the best CB in the league.
 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TesT
The Yetis also have the best CB in the league.


on what grounds
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MiniHusk
Originally posted by BobJoeJim

UNOFFICIAL PRESEASON POWER RANKINGS

1. Arctic Bay Yetis (TOT: 84.2, OFF: 86.4, DEF: 81.9)
A level 12 QB and a pair of level 11 WRs, as well as the best LOT in the league, give the Yetis the best passing offense out there while the rushing attack ranks #2. With 12 starters at level 10+ and only one starter lower than level 8 (a level 7 CB), this is the best starting lineup in the league.

You might want to rethink this. We are running a 4-3. The Lv7 player is a backup LB listed as a RILB in a 3-4.



Yeah I see that. Fix your roster, it's screwing up my spreadsheet! It just takes the first 11 defensive players listed in your depth chart, assuming you can't start more than that. If you have the ILB spots filled in it screws with things
 
KingDan23
offline
Link
 
BJJ I am so glad we have you in our league, fantastic job once again mate.
 
TesT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrTea
Originally posted by TesT

The Yetis also have the best CB in the league.


on what grounds


Big Sexxxy is pretty much a beast wherever he goes.

113 tackles, 4 INTs, 2 FF, and 27 PD in 13 games last season in the USA Pros. I can't wait to get my hands on the n00bs in this league!


 
MrTea
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TesT
Originally posted by MrTea

Originally posted by TesT


The Yetis also have the best CB in the league.


on what grounds


Big Sexxxy is pretty much a beast wherever he goes.

113 tackles, 4 INTs, 2 FF, and 27 PD in 13 games last season in the USA Pros. I can't wait to get my hands on the n00bs in this league!




right i eat my words lol

 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
TODAY'S GAMES - PREDICTIONS

Halifax United @ Ottawa Bills (-17)
The Bills look to battle for a playoff spot, while Halifax will be battling just to avoid relegation. Ottawa is favored by 17 at home.

Dallas Desparados @ Arctic Bay Yetis (-6)
The Yetis are the consensus number one team in the league, but today's game against a playoff caliber foe will go a long way toward indicating how big the gap is between them and the teams chasing them. Yetis by 6.

Brown Trout (-13) @ Vancouver Darksiders
A mismatch on paper, but Vancouver is at home. We'll see what they can do as 13 point underdogs.

Iqaluit Packers (-1) @ The Usual Suspects
Game of the week. Iqaluit looks better on paper, but the gap isn't huge and the Suspects are at home. This is a major shakeup game.

Hudson Howlers (-6) @ Sparta Mustangs
If Hudson wants to be considered as a legitimate playoff contender, it would behoove them to open with a blowout of the relatively weak Mustangs. We'll see if they can do so.

Ottawa Ambassadors @ Reading Redskins (-13)
Reading should have no trouble in this game, especially playing at home.

Niagra Falls Cascade @ West Texas Widowermakers (-21)
This game will probably get ugly fast. Niagra is just outmatched.

Iowa Blackhawks @ Niagara Jeanhorns (-27)
What can I say? The second best team at home against the worst team? The scoreboard operators better be prepared.

These spreads are totally just for fun, and not too deeply thought out, but if you come across this post in the next couple hours, before the games sim, feel free to make your picks
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.