User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Watch these plays and take note of the movement of the HB and ROLB:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146740&pbp_id=6051645
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146740&pbp_id=6052795
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146740&pbp_id=6054178
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146740&pbp_id=6056067 (this one is especially clear)

Notice how the ROLB completely ignores the existence of the HB. Any other time two players get anywhere near each other, they collide and slow each other down - even if they're both on the same side and thus presumably NOT trying to get in each others' way. And, yet, here the ROLB is able to share the exact same xy position as the HB and BOTH PLAYERS maintain their full speed.

Admittedly these are pass plays where the HB is running a route, not blocking - but I still have two problems with that:

One, tell me one single back in any level of play that wouldn't step in the way of a completely unblocked blitzing linebacker, even if he was supposed to be running a route.
Two, he actually was in the way of the blitzing linebacker, but that didn't even matter.

It's not like these are wimpy elusive build backs, either. This happened to my power backs and, while they don't have HUGE amounts of blocking, they havn't totally neglected the stat either. It's not like they're getting run over. BOTH players continue at full speed.

It's like the title says: they aren't causing collision checks.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Watched the replays. Josh has a 17 Blocking. He was going against a very fast, and decently agile LB. I can't see Tommy Jefferson's stats though for the other LB.

Likely though both of your backs have < 20 Blocking. And the LB's, especially Tommy, appear well built just from the Scouting bar. I'd say if you want your HB's to block 30 or more Blocking is going to be worth it.

And as you said, they are running a route so they're not going to block. Its an issue with the SIM.

Hard to say exactly. Also remember, that the dots don't count for much.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Show me any other play where two players literally run through each other's space without slowing down.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Show me any other play where two players literally run through each other's space without slowing down.


Umm... about half the plays? Collision detection isn't working the way it should. Running backs run through "holes" consisting of 5 people partially overlapping, most handoffs occur when the HB runs through the QB, linebackers occasionally run through 6 people accross the LoS, safeties & LB's frequently charge in at RB's to make what looks like a stop for no gain, but instead they get run through without a tackle attempt, and WR's don't exist on the corporeal plane unless they're throwing a block.
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
Firstly, the dots take up way more space on the screen than an actual person would on the field. Unless we think that all footballs have a 1 yard girth?

Secondly, collision detection would use, x,y co-ordinates and pathing, not sharp edges on textures. It's handle invisibly inside the sim and dots are used to represent player's approximate positions on the field. You people think you are playing CS: Source or something?

Lastly, if you ever actually watched a football game (I can only assume none of you have) then you'll see HB's fit through some very small spaces indeed. The good ones even keep running afterwards!
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Show me any other play where two players literally run through each other's space without slowing down.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145716&pbp_id=5819339

My fullback running the fuck over a Strong Safety. The Safety was actually attempting to tackle him as well and my fullback wasn't running a passing route.

There are many other plays like this. This was just a very recent one. And as I said, and others noted as well.. the Dots don't mean anything but approximations.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145716&pbp_id=5819339

My fullback running the fuck over a Strong Safety. The Safety was actually attempting to tackle him as well and my fullback wasn't running a passing route.


Yeah - he RAN OVER the SS. In the plays I show, neither player lost any speed or momentum. In the play you show, the FB plowed through the SS and the SS stops moving.

Originally posted by ratphlegm
Running backs run through "holes" consisting of 5 people partially overlapping


This is because of blocking. I'm talking about two players on opposite teams in the open field completely ignoring each others' presences.

Originally posted by hemprobot
Secondly, collision detection would use, x,y co-ordinates and pathing, not sharp edges on textures. It's handle invisibly inside the sim and dots are used to represent player's approximate positions on the field. You people think you are playing CS: Source or something?


Hey, you'll note I even referred to the players' XY position! It's like I already made your argument for you! Except you just decided to skip READING the original post and decided it'd be better to skip to the petty "OMG COUNTERSTRIKEZORS!" argument.

Even if the dots are off, the HB and ROLB should still have collided.

Originally posted by
Lastly, if you ever actually watched a football game (I can only assume none of you have) then you'll see HB's fit through some very small spaces indeed. The good ones even keep running afterwards!


Again, this is the result of blocking, and has no correlation at all to two players in the open field. Good job making more "OMGCOUNTERSTRIKEZORS!" arguments, though. They really help your position.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 09:35:53
 
hemprobot
offline
Link
 
You could easily fit 5 people in a 1 yard diameter circle which is how big those dots are. That's even before you consider that the circles are approximate and so in reality may never even get all that close anyway. It's not a bug and that would be obvious to you if you weren't a bitter retard.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hemprobot
You could easily fit 5 people in a 1 yard diameter circle which is how big those dots are.


With each person moving at a full run and moving in different directions, without colliding with each other?

Sorry, you're so full of shit I can smell you over the internet.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 12:08:07
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Dude, you got sacked. (9 times evidently) You only posted up 4 plays. So evidently the other 5 sacks were legit or you couldn;t find something to whine about on those plays.

The Dots mean nothing. They are placemarkers to give you an approximation. Your player did not do anything to try to stop the other player because he was running a route. So, absent intentional collission, the game doesn;t try to come up with accidental collisions to save you from a sack.

You lost the game. It was one game and one point loss. Deal with it.

Maybe you should rethink your offensive schemes, maybe you should look at your line, maybe you just got stuffed a few times.

It happens.

We all get over it. Its your turn.
 
ThaOutlaw
offline
Link
 
There's not going to be any collision there. Especially since the HB is running an out route. You see that all the time in the NFL, a LB will blow by a HB and the HB will run out to the flats and catch a pass.

This isn't anything close to a bug, hell it's the game working as intended.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Dude, you got sacked. (9 times evidently) You only posted up 4 plays. So evidently the other 5 sacks were legit or you couldn;t find something to whine about on those plays.


10 times, actually. 8 of them were with this bug. I only showed the most obvious of them; if I'd posted all of them, you (yes, you, the same person) would have complained about something else equally as inane and irrelevant.

Originally posted by
The Dots mean nothing. They are placemarkers to give you an approximation.


These two statements are mutually exclusive.

Either they mean nothing, or they're a representation of what happens on the field.

You can't have it both ways.

And, BTW, football players are big people. I personally am only 5'7", and my shoulders are 23 inches across. Saying "people aren't a yard wide!" is a misdirection at best. They may not be literally 36 inches wide, but large football players like linebackers and power halfbacks are going to be over two feet from shoulder to shoulder. That's a very significant portion of a yard wide.

Originally posted by
Your player did not do anything to try to stop the other player because he was running a route. So, absent intentional collission, the game doesn;t try to come up with accidental collisions to save you from a sack.


Name me a RB in any league that wouldn't at least get in the way of an unblocked blitzing linebacker that will otherwise sack the QB in less than a second's time, given that the HB and the LB are already running straight at each other. I can even show you plenty of videos of a HB that runs across the entire formation to block blitzers (Maurice Jones-Drew).

Originally posted by JDaniels127

There's not going to be any collision there. Especially since the HB is running an out route. You see that all the time in the NFL, a LB will blow by a HB and the HB will run out to the flats and catch a pass.

This isn't anything close to a bug, hell it's the game working as intended.


See above.

It doesn't matter if you're out in the flats ready to catch a ball if your quarterback is on his back seeing stars because you stepped aside to let the blitzing linebacker eat him for lunch.


This is a bug. Deal with it.
 
Link
 
the problem is that there isn't supposed to be a collision.

when a RB is on a pass pattern, then they don't pick up the blitz.

That isn't a bug. That is just the way the game is designed.

Maybe the RB should stay in if there is a bliz. Maybe the QB should dump it to the RB sooner if there is a blitz. I dunno.

But the game is playing exactly as intended.

This happens on all running plays and pass patterns as the other guy noted. The best you can do is get a faster RG so he can get over there in time or don't call this play. Run it more?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
True, my RG's don't generally have a problem pickup up the blitzer, yours at your level should have much more speed and vision that it appears he might
 
supersoul
offline
Link
 
Zural, by my count your 'bug' has been answered twice. The first time you ignored it to go off on the dot people, the second time you refer to a real football game as a reference for how GLB should be.

It's just not the way the game works right now, get over it. Maybe one day they'll put in a chip function, but it obviously hasn't happened yet.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.