User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
I have purposely set the offensive gameplan so that it never throws a short pass to the HB or FB. They are set as zero as pass receivers in the generic tactics page, they never have short pass plays scripted for them, the QB was set to "never" on dump pass, and the auto adjust was off. Yet these four plays were all called last game:

FB Flare - Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5326639


HB Flat – Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5327127

HB Flat – Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5327768

HB Flat - Short Pass
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=142695&pbp_id=5328250

On a couple of those there were scripted short plays to the TE and WR, but never for the HB. It seems like every time a short pass is called, even if it's specified to the TE or WR, the HB may be called as the primary receiver anyway. I assume the little orange arrow on the play schemes recently posted signify the primary receiver.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
First one, he was about to get sacked so it's pretty logical imo
 
MD
offline
Link
 
Is it possible your QB said he set it to Never but maybe forgot or didnt want to? Because all you can do is take his word but you cant see his settings.
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
Well, that's true, I just have his word. But I specifically asked him after the game, he said he had it set to never as requested, and he has no reason to lie. We were going to lose regardless. The opposite, in fact, since now that the computer is going to call short passes to the HB and FB regardless of my settings, I'll have to script a lot fewer short passes to the TE and WR.

That the QB was about to be sacked shouldn't matter, unless there's an alterntive definition to 'never' that I don't quite grok.
 
jeffgarcia
offline
Link
 
It's a good thing that the QB overrode his hidden "stupid" setting imo
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
While I appreciate how good it is that stupidity isn't precisely binary, the original point lies somewhere else.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rekcuf
While I appreciate how good it is that stupidity isn't precisely binary, the original point lies somewhere else.


This OP is right. I've experienced the same thing in my games. A brand new phenomena as of about 2 weeks ago. Last game for me alone there were 8 unwanted halfback/fullback passes from a QB set to NEVER. It was against a gutted team, too.

However, I think I know what is happening - I'll know for sure potentially tonight.

I've developed a theory in lieu of zero response from the 'crack' admin support staff. If I am right, then it's a matter of bad code/AI. We'll see. I'll be sure to post about it in a couple days if I determine I'm right based on the next couple games.
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
Excellent. Any insight you could give would be greatly appreciated.
 
djhoffman99
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I've seen it too and it started a couple of weeks ago.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
If your AI calls for a short pass to a TE or a short pass to a WR it just means they are the primary target. It does not necessarily mean the ball is going to the WR/TE. A lot of short plays involve having a HB or FB as a receiver and generally they are deemed open by the QB. Unfortunately not many HB/FBs have high enough catching to catch the ball "on the run" and a LB or safety just mows them down for a short gain or loss.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rekcuf
Excellent. Any insight you could give would be greatly appreciated.


Well, for starters, Thorn isn't sure what to make of it. He is passing it along to Bort.
However, I had ZERO 'back passes tonight. One game, but still. Here is the hypothesis:

If you utilize basic settings for pass distance distribution (and I do), AND you have anything on short passing, then you leave yourself open to random halfback passes.
even though your QB has it set to never throw them

I had been utilizing short passing more this season because, quite honestly, passing in general has sucked this season. So I was trying to go a little more west coast.

I think, as of now, that this is a bug caused by the tactics settings for throw distances is overriding the QB's never throw to the HB.

Example: shotgun formation, 3 WR and 1 HB. the 3 WR don't run short routes - so wa-lah, a nice 3 yard loss on a screen pass to the HB.
Last edited Oct 7, 2008 20:17:09
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
If your AI calls for a short pass to a TE or a short pass to a WR it just means they are the primary target. It does not necessarily mean the ball is going to the WR/TE. A lot of short plays involve having a HB or FB as a receiver and generally they are deemed open by the QB. Unfortunately not many HB/FBs have high enough catching to catch the ball "on the run" and a LB or safety just mows them down for a short gain or loss.


You're missing the point.
 
djhoffman99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
If your AI calls for a short pass to a TE or a short pass to a WR it just means they are the primary target. It does not necessarily mean the ball is going to the WR/TE. A lot of short plays involve having a HB or FB as a receiver and generally they are deemed open by the QB. Unfortunately not many HB/FBs have high enough catching to catch the ball "on the run" and a LB or safety just mows them down for a short gain or loss.


In this game http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=141723 we were playing the worst team in the league so I zeroed out all short passing. Despite that, the HBs still got 10 receptions. It may not be a bug, I'd just like to understand why.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I would like to know what the AI considers a "dump" pass for the purposes of the QB tactic. Is it anything after primary receiver or on some of these plays the RB the #2 or #3 read. That might make a difference on whether on not the settings "work"
 
rekcuf
offline
Link
 
I understand that Mat, but if those flare patterns are all for the back to be hanging out around the line of scrimmage, wouldn't those be considered dump passes? If the QB is set to never throw dump passes, shouldn't he either force a throw further downfield or eat the ball rather than checkdown? Even worse, as Islander notes, those plays all look like the back is the primary receiver if that's what the orange arrow means.

It's a good theory Islander, and it may be true. But some of those passes were situationally called as short to the TE or WR and didn't use the basic settings. They used the advanced AI.

dj, you should double check with your QB to make sure he has dump pass set to 'never.'
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.