User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
THis play says there was an interception, returned for 15 yards then fumbled, when actually it was a deflected pass, what the heck is up with that!? Gave the other team a free first down even though they really missed the pass! There was no return as the play says, and no fumble!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=164744&pbp_id=5455682

That sucks!
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 18:16:42
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
link? lol

EDIT: Oh cool, you added it. Good work.
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 18:17:11
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
link? lol

EDIT: Oh cool, you added it. Good work.


Sup European defector
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
Originally posted by caponesgun

The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!


nah. just a little bug. Should say 15 yard catch (not return). I noticed it does that also when 2 fumbles on same play. It gets mixed up who is on offense and who is on defense. It also says -0 yard return. That is the fumble yards.

It was a catch, a fumble, a recovery, then the guy who made the recovery fumbled.
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 18:28:16
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by ilracefan

Originally posted by caponesgun


The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!


nah. just a little bug. Should say 15 yard catch (not return). I noticed it does that also when 2 fumbles on same play. It gets mixed up who is on offense and who is on defense. It also says -0 yard return. That is the fumble yards.

It was a catch, a fumble, a recovery, then the guy who made the recovery fumbled.


BUT READ THE PBP, IT SAYS THE INTERCEPTION WAS RETURNED 15 YARDS!!! Look at the play and read the PBP before posting PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!

There was no Int. and NO RETURN AT ALL, and there was no fumble!! This was a deflected pass! Even if the WR caught the pass (which you can plainly see he didn't), it should say it was a deflected pass not Intercepted and returned for 15 yards, then fumbled and the fumble returned for 0 yards!
Last edited Oct 6, 2008 18:35:39
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by ilracefan


Originally posted by caponesgun



The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!


nah. just a little bug. Should say 15 yard catch (not return). I noticed it does that also when 2 fumbles on same play. It gets mixed up who is on offense and who is on defense. It also says -0 yard return. That is the fumble yards.

It was a catch, a fumble, a recovery, then the guy who made the recovery fumbled.


BUT READ THE PBP, IT SAYS THE INTERCEPTION WAS RETURNED 15 YARDS!!! Look at the play and read the PBP before posting PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!

There was no Int. and NO RETURN AT ALL, and there was no fumble!! This was a deflected pass! Even if the WR caught the pass (which you can plainly see he didn't), it should say it was a deflected pass not Intercepted and returned for 15 yards, then fumbled and the fumble returned for 0 yards!


No it doesn't. It shows there was a 15 yard completion then a fumble. The wording of the PBP on the play is bad. But the play itself is fine. Catch, fumble, recover, fumble, recover, first down is the correct order and event sequence.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Looks to me like the play was:

Interception-Ali Vietch
forced fumble by Golden receiver
fumble recovery by Marty McFly.

The description in the PBP is incorrect, but the result is perfectly fine.

 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by ilracefan

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by ilracefan



Originally posted by caponesgun




The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!


nah. just a little bug. Should say 15 yard catch (not return). I noticed it does that also when 2 fumbles on same play. It gets mixed up who is on offense and who is on defense. It also says -0 yard return. That is the fumble yards.

It was a catch, a fumble, a recovery, then the guy who made the recovery fumbled.


BUT READ THE PBP, IT SAYS THE INTERCEPTION WAS RETURNED 15 YARDS!!! Look at the play and read the PBP before posting PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!

There was no Int. and NO RETURN AT ALL, and there was no fumble!! This was a deflected pass! Even if the WR caught the pass (which you can plainly see he didn't), it should say it was a deflected pass not Intercepted and returned for 15 yards, then fumbled and the fumble returned for 0 yards!


No it doesn't. It shows there was a 15 yard completion then a fumble. The wording of the PBP on the play is bad. But the play itself is fine. Catch, fumble, recover, fumble, recover, first down is the correct order and event sequence.


"intercepted by Ali Veitch (15 yd return)" is exactly WORD FOR WORD what the PBP says!! Don't tell me it doesn't say there is a return, when it DOES!! IF it should say 15 yard reception fine, but it hits our CB bounces back IMMEDIATELY a few yards then a WR picks it up.
 
Little Dragon
offline
Link
 
Don Knight pass to 'Marty' McFly, hurried by Kyle Koepkey, up the left side intercepted by Ali Veitch (15 yd return)[forced fumble: 'Golden' Receiver], fumbled , recovered by 'Marty' McFly (-0 yd return) [tackle: Street Broderick]
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by ilracefan


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Originally posted by ilracefan




Originally posted by caponesgun





The CPU intercepted that, got hit by the WR and fumbled it and the original offense team recovered it. Happens in the NFL as the CBs aren't used to carrying the ball

The dots are too big and too close together to truly show you that play. Not a bug


It says the Interception was returned for 15 yards, the pass was deflected not returned at all, the other team got a 14 yard gain on an INCOMPLETE pass!! No interception, and no fumble!!


nah. just a little bug. Should say 15 yard catch (not return). I noticed it does that also when 2 fumbles on same play. It gets mixed up who is on offense and who is on defense. It also says -0 yard return. That is the fumble yards.

It was a catch, a fumble, a recovery, then the guy who made the recovery fumbled.


BUT READ THE PBP, IT SAYS THE INTERCEPTION WAS RETURNED 15 YARDS!!! Look at the play and read the PBP before posting PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!

There was no Int. and NO RETURN AT ALL, and there was no fumble!! This was a deflected pass! Even if the WR caught the pass (which you can plainly see he didn't), it should say it was a deflected pass not Intercepted and returned for 15 yards, then fumbled and the fumble returned for 0 yards!


No it doesn't. It shows there was a 15 yard completion then a fumble. The wording of the PBP on the play is bad. But the play itself is fine. Catch, fumble, recover, fumble, recover, first down is the correct order and event sequence.


"intercepted by Ali Veitch (15 yd return)" is exactly WORD FOR WORD what the PBP says!! Don't tell me it doesn't say there is a return, when it DOES!! IF it should say 15 yard reception fine, but it hits our CB bounces back IMMEDIATELY a few yards then a WR picks it up.


lol...hysterics ftw!

The wording is wrong, it does not describe the play correctly. I suspect there is some sort of buffer in the code for type of turnover (strTOTYPE="interception") and a separate unrelated variable for the distance...(intTORETURN=15) and when there are multiple turnovers on a play, things get confused on the PBP description as some of these variables get assigned values at one point in the play, then are not overwritten, or overwritten incorrectly, later in the play.

Chill out ... the result of the play is correct, everything worked out fine.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Basically, the "15 yard return" is supposed to refer to the length of the fumble return...but since there were multiple turnovers, the game can't figure out the correct value, and ends up calculating distance from the original line of scrimmage.

Should read "Int for 0 yards returned, fumble for 0 yards returned, total yardage on play- 15 yards."

At least that's my guess.
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Looks to me like the play was:

Interception-Ali Vietch
forced fumble by Golden receiver
fumble recovery by Marty McFly.

The description in the PBP is incorrect, but the result is perfectly fine.



So the interception was made 15 yards downfield, not returned 15 yards, and the fumble went 1 yard back upfield was recovered and had no return, for a total gain of 14 yards.

I'll accept that, but it still could use a tweak at some point in time to avoid confusion.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I find it interesting that on this play, the CB was considered to have control of the ball and fumbled in the span of about two-tenths of a second, while on other plays, offensive guys will "catch" the ball, hold it long enough for someone to "miss a tackle" and then have it "deflected" out of their hands for an incompletion.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.