User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Pass deflection + incomplete pass + missed tackle?
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
6:58 2nd & 2 OPP 18.5 Spear Chucker pass to T'Won Jitterbug over the middle [missed tackle: Asparagus Jackson] [deflected by Cory Matthews] (incomplete)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=179207&pbp_id=4657663

I'm at a bit of a loss on this play. When I read the line I assumed someone nearly sacked the QB but missed and he got the pass off. But clearly the LB gets nowhere near the QB. So exactly what tackle does the LB miss? If the receiver gains possession enough for a tackle attempt, then knocking the ball free should be a fumble; if the ball is still being juggled and gets broken up, the attempt to hit the receiver is either pass interference (if it happens before the ball gets there) or nothing (if it happens in the middle). Is this a GLB order of operations thing?
 
otmalize
offline
Link
 
You know looking at the replay without consulting the tag line...

It *looks* like the LB (Jackson) actually deflected the pass, which the receiver picked up and started running and was tackled by the CB (Matthews)

There is *NO WAY* that Matthews deflected the pass.

 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
I agree. And this was a pretty important play too, because they failed to convert on third, kicked a field goal, and lost by four points. I just can't figure out what the simulator is trying to tell us happened.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I've posted about this "event" before and seen others do so without getting any response from mods. I'm with you completely on the logic issue of the play, Gabrosin, either it's an incomplete pass and no missed tackle, or it's a missed tackle and a fumble.

In the grand scheme of GLB issues, though, this is really unimportant. I imagine it would be hard for the sim to ignore these "missed tackles" because it counts them based on the tackle-roll result, and the guy failed his roll so it's counted as a miss, even though it later decides the receiver didn't catch it.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I could be wrong but, it looks to me like the LB spun around and dove missing the WR. The CB then broke up the play.

I have seen similar posts about this very issue. If there was no catch. There was nobody to tackle. Thus no way to miss a tackle. IMO

I also doubt it will be addressed soon as I have seen this before in the bugs section.

 
Gabrosin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
I've posted about this "event" before and seen others do so without getting any response from mods. I'm with you completely on the logic issue of the play, Gabrosin, either it's an incomplete pass and no missed tackle, or it's a missed tackle and a fumble.

In the grand scheme of GLB issues, though, this is really unimportant. I imagine it would be hard for the sim to ignore these "missed tackles" because it counts them based on the tackle-roll result, and the guy failed his roll so it's counted as a miss, even though it later decides the receiver didn't catch it.


I don't particularly care about the statistics of it... I'm just wondering if something weird is happening to turn a completion into an incompletion. As otmalize noted, it certainly looks like the ball is deflected first, then caught... then the receiver moves about a yard... then the play ends with a tackle.

But you're right, there are far more important bugs out there. Just so long as someone has noted it for future study :-)
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.