User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Dammit, the 3-4 outside linebacker pathing is still hosed
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
OK, I've posted this in the BUG section previously, and got a few owners that also posted the same problems, but apparently never managed to get the attention of anyone who might have Bort take a peek.

I also previously sent this to support who had the suggestion that I post in the suggestions forum for some reason??

I'm trying again. This pathing is almost the exact same pathing issue that Bort believed he fixed last season. In the 3-4 defense, the outside linebackers 'peel' off the line of scrimmage on running plays at about a 45 degree angle. This is NOT the correct movement for the outside linebacker in a 3-4 for ANY play. They work correctly on pass plays, ie they pick their man and cover him, but on running plays they leave the corners of the 3-4 wide open.

On running plays however (specially if the defense is in Cover 1 which I would really like to run, but it is starting to look like I cannot), the outside linebackers SHOULD move upfield slightly and square in. Their job is to protect against sweeps, pitches, and runs off tackle. Here are a few examples of what I am talking about...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=160517&pbp_id=4844278

That play was a rush up the middle, and the two outside linebackers looked like they were trying to cover a WR for some reason. The backfield coverage in that instance is cover 1 with man underneath and the WR is the CB's man, so even if they somehow got confused on every single running play, they would be trying to cover the wrong man!

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=160517&pbp_id=4844415

Another one where the RB simply runs through the hole the Linebacker is SUPPOSED to be filling.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=160517&pbp_id=4845774

Here is another one, it actually looks like the strongside linebacker is afraid of the TE. He chases him almost 6 yards downfield trying to block him.

There are many more examples of this problem in pretty much every single game that team has played. I've been hoping that the problem wasn't ignored, but it looks like it has been so far.

There are reasons very few people are running the 3-4, and the pathing of the outside linebackers is certainly one reason it sucks.

I would love to have a discourse on this, as I've tried a bunch of things trying to fix this problem, but nothing I've tried has fully fixed it.

Please get your basic SIM working correctly before you start cobbling on a bunch of extra stuff, or you will never be able to fix it.

PinTBC
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 15:50:48
 
Greenday4537
offline
Link
 
It looks like the LBs have a pass focus, not a run focus. That'd explain why they drop back into coverage. Also, nothing looks wrong to me. They move to the outside like outside linebackers are supposed to do. The SS or FS, depending on the side, is supposed to come into the gap to make the play.
 
nightstar289
offline
Link
 
1. Ask the LBs what focus they are on. It looks like they were on pass focus, so that's probably why
2. Check the AI. Is the play focus for the output on run, balanced, pass, or basic settings?

IMHO, not a bug
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nightstar289
1. Ask the LBs what focus they are on. It looks like they were on pass focus, so that's probably why
2. Check the AI. Is the play focus for the output on run, balanced, pass, or basic settings?

IMHO, not a bug


if you set focus to run, this should not happen. But it does.

I can promise you that if your ROLB has run focus he will still do this stupidity by default AI in this. In fact, I'm pretty sure it happens in the 4-3 also (cover 1).

The only way to avoid this is forcing him to blitz every play needed, which is nothing but a cover up for incorrect code.
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 16:11:11
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Just for further information, in the games this season, our outside linebackers have been on Pass, and Balanced, and Run. They perform the same maneuver no matter the setting.

The last time I posted asking about this they had been set on Balanced for that game, and performed the exact same way.

I agree that the linebackers in the plays I posted look like they are on pass focus BUT, on passing plays the strong side linebacker steps forward into the TE (his man) and covers him very well, SO if this were in fact a problem with pass setting, he should at the very least step towards the man he is supposed to be covering, not waltz off after the damned WR. OH, the Weak side linebacker on pass plays does a fantastic job shadowing the HB his guy, so again if the problem were a pass setting versus a run setting, then they should at least be going towards the correct guy!

I know for a FACT that team does NOT run zone.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
The Defensive settings for the plays I pasted was set on Run stack the box more...

As I said, this isn't the first time I've seen this, I've tried quite a few things to stop this. The only thing I've seen that stops it is to blitz both outside linebackers, but that leave the TE and HB wide open, and anyone trying to do that on their defense deserves to get burned.

PinTBC
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
1.
The problem is the "build-in" drop back of all LBs on run plays. Bort explained that: if the LBs stay or even take a read step towards the line, all run plays are shut down immediately.

2.
Run or Pass focus in the individual tactics determines just the time needed to recognize the play. So a run focus will make them recognize and turn a bit faster.

3.
Run, Balanced or Pass focus in the defense AI determines just the spot the LB starts out from. So run focus starts the build-in drop back from a spot closer to the line - so he doesn't drop that far back from the line and got a better chance to read the play even faster (less distance).

4.
The common "work around" the build-in drop back is to give the LBs higher vision (60+) and to have them play on run focus. That way, the drop back is held down to 1-3 yards sometimes. Another way is to blitz the LB you want to stay in his place.
But it sure is just a rather poor way counter what is build-in.

5.
Blitzing the LOLB and ROLB shouldn't result in the TE or HB uncovered during pass plays. I'm not too sure about the 3-4, but a 4-3 cover 1 will assign the SS and LOLB to cover the TE and the MLB to cover the HB. So you can blitz both OLBs without leaving a receiver uncovered.
But why would you blitz the LOLBs? To get him blocked, you might just let him perform their drop back move. The TE will be chasing your LOLB anyway.
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 16:44:24
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
1.
The problem is the "build-in" drop back of all LBs on run plays. Bort explained that: if the LBs stay or even take a read step towards the line, all run plays are shut down immediately.


All the way back to the WR1 on run focus? Consistently with 50 vision?

Originally posted by RAPB
2.
Run or Pass focus in the individual tactics determines just the time needed to recognize the play. So a run focus will make them recognize and turn a bit faster.


Not just this. run focus within the playbook AI itself means the defenders start closer to the line of scrimmage, thus in theory reducing this issue. Except it doesn't.

I've got linebackers who are on run focus in a run based AI playcall bouncing 5 yards back in the 3-4 cover 1 especially, far moreso then the inside linebackers do. I am absolutely convinced the AI is making him think he should be double covering the WR at times (in 2 WR sets)
Last edited Oct 4, 2008 16:48:27
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by RAPB

1.
The problem is the "build-in" drop back of all LBs on run plays. Bort explained that: if the LBs stay or even take a read step towards the line, all run plays are shut down immediately.


All the way back to the WR1 on run focus? Consistently with 50 vision?


You don't get it. The play is programmed like

- start moving backwards and to the outside right from the start
- as the guy recognizes it's run, stop and make him turn

So no matter what vision the guy has, he'll alwaysstart the backwards movement.

And 50 vision is not much. Check the open LB build in the build thread:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141826&pbp_id=4499694

He's playing LOLB here. See him stop the build-in drop back way earlier.

Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by RAPB

2.
Run or Pass focus in the individual tactics determines just the time needed to recognize the play. So a run focus will make them recognize and turn a bit faster.


Not just this. run focus within the playbook AI itself means the defenders start closer to the line of scrimmage, thus in theory reducing this issue. Except it doesn't.


Nr. 2 is about individual settings, nr. 3 about the playbook. And it does reduce the issue, yet doesn't stop it.

Read above again: the play has the build-in drop back as first move.

Originally posted by islander1

I've got linebackers who are on run focus in a run based AI playcall bouncing 5 yards back in the 3-4 cover 1 especially, far moreso then the inside linebackers do. I am absolutely convinced the AI is making him think he should be double covering the WR at times (in 2 WR sets)


Read above again: the play has the build-in drop back as first move. They do not think anything, but perform the drop back move until their vision makes them recognize it's a run. Plain and simple.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
no swearing in thread title, lock ban
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
1.
The problem is the "build-in" drop back of all LBs on run plays. Bort explained that: if the LBs stay or even take a read step towards the line, all run plays are shut down immediately.


If this is true, then this makes the 3-4 defense almost useless as the outside linebackers are by the design of that particular set responsible to stop off tackle and sweep plays. With their current pathing, they cannot even remotely be available to do this. The 4-3 ends up having a huge advantage as their DEs can be used to set the edge, as they don't run for the hills on the snap of the ball.

By the way, I have never seen Bort make that statement, but then again, neither he nor any moderator stopped by the previous thread. Would you mind linking that? If that is how he is opening up the running game, it is simply a poor design. Hell it is worse than a poor design.

Originally posted by RAPB
2.
Run or Pass focus in the individual tactics determines just the time needed to recognize the play. So a run focus will make them recognize and turn a bit faster.


Again, where is this documented? I've read multiple descriptions of what the focus does. It used to make them take their first step toward the line of scrimmage, now you believe it only helps them recognize a run play better.

Originally posted by RAPB
3.
Run, Balanced or Pass focus in the defense AI determines just the spot the LB starts out from. So run focus starts the build-in drop back from a spot closer to the line - so he doesn't drop that far back from the line and got a better chance to read the play even faster (less distance).

4.
The common "work around" the build-in drop back is to give the LBs higher vision (60+) and to have them play on run focus. That way, the drop back is held down to 1-3 yards sometimes. Another way is to blitz the LB you want to stay in his place.
But it sure is just a rather poor way counter what is build-in.


So now that linebacker needs to have a 60+ strength, 60+ agility, 50+ speed, and a 60+ visions just to play an outside linebacker spot? That is a foolish way to fix the inadequacies of the design of the running game. Bort seems brighter than that. He has already taken steps to weaken tackling which should help alot, he has also lessened the ability to get off blocks in the running game, it is less than intelligent to force the defensive players to remove themselves from the play for no reason to help the offense.

It is even worse that if what you say is true, there wasn't some kind of general announcement explaining exactly what the intent was. Had I seen one, I would have been all over it. The 3-4 as designed is weak enough without completely ripping its balls out.

Originally posted by RAPB
5.
Blitzing the LOLB and ROLB shouldn't result in the TE or HB uncovered during pass plays. I'm not too sure about the 3-4, but a 4-3 cover 1 will assign the SS and LOLB to cover the TE and the MLB to cover the HB. So you can blitz both OLBs without leaving a receiver uncovered.
But why would you blitz the LOLBs? To get him blocked, you might just let him perform their drop back move. The TE will be chasing your LOLB anyway.


In the 3-4 the right outside linebacker covers the halfback, the left outside linebacker covers the TE. I would prefer not to blitz the outside linebackers, but if my choice is to just have them run in and tie up the TE at the line of scrimmage and MAYBE get involved with the run, versus run 6 or 7 yards downfield so the Halfback can simply run through the hole they just freaking left, I guess I might have to start blitzing as stupid as it sounds.

I hope to hell someone pops in and says you are wrong, because if you are correct, then the idea that this is even remotely a football sim is false.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
no swearing in thread title, lock ban


Bite me, and either contribute to the discussion or shut up.

PinTBC
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
RAPB: I do get it. My team defense kicks ass in a pretty legitimate league (the half thats not gutted, of course). I understand what I'm doing well, and utilize a playbook that's from all indications rather extensive. About 20 pages and 100 or so individual input/output pairs.

I undertsand how it works. However, there is a tangible difference between the drop back of the ROLB and that of the MLB, and they have near equal vision when in the same exact play. This phenomena is consistent, play in and out, within the same scenario set.
I understand that, even with run emphasis, the linebacker will initially step backwards a little. That's what they are supposed to do.

(edit: My point with the play emphasis is this. If I had the playcall set to 'pass' instead of run, I'd expect the ROLB to back up further - and be more inclined to potentially follow the WR for a longer period of time. It'd also be more difficult, within a 'pass' distance setting, to have a successful vision roll to recognize a run play - because he's physically further away.

However, what I am saying is that he backs up effectively the same distance whether he's in run or pass AI playcalls. He follows the WR for several yards one way or the other. This isn't me arguing he shouldn't "back up initially" at all. It's me saying a bug exists when the MLB backs up 2 yards everytime on the same play, yet the ROLB backs up 4 to 5 : end edit).

However...when using run emphasis they start closer to the line of scrimmage then in a balanced scenario. If you haven't noticed this, then that's not my fault. They are closer to the line of scrimmage, so the vision check should be easier to make. Not saying he should make it every time, but what I am seeing is very similar to the OP's claim. The ROLB never recognizes the run even 3 yards away from it - he's too busy pathing outward towards the WR for some stupid reason regardless.

Additionally, there is a crap ton in this game that is undocumented and unexplained. Again, standard operating procedure around here (to date).



Last edited Oct 4, 2008 17:55:36
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Also, Wilcox has 5 more vision then the linebacker in question on my team.

Big whoop?

My LOLB has the same vision, and he does the same thing. I see this bug far more in the 3-4 sets then the 4-3, however.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC

If this is true, then this makes the 3-4 defense almost useless as the outside linebackers are by the design of that particular set responsible to stop off tackle and sweep plays. With their current pathing, they cannot even remotely be available to do this. The 4-3 ends up having a huge advantage as their DEs can be used to set the edge, as they don't run for the hills on the snap of the ball.

By the way, I have never seen Bort make that statement, but then again, neither he nor any moderator stopped by the previous thread. Would you mind linking that? If that is how he is opening up the running game, it is simply a poor design. Hell it is worse than a poor design.


It was in a discussion early in season 4 about the drop back of the LBs. In this discussion (maybe BUG forum), Bort explained the issue and the solution was a less radical drop-back.

It's no big deal on pitch plays though, for the OLBs usually make it back to the runner before he even crosses the LOS. But off tackle plays and inside runs are really hardly to stop by the LBs right now.

Originally posted by PinTBC

Again, where is this documented? I've read multiple descriptions of what the focus does. It used to make them take their first step toward the line of scrimmage, now you believe it only helps them recognize a run play better.


Hm... I don't know about pass plays and the first step. But I did a lot of research lately on stopping the inside / off tackle run - and I've NEVER seen a LB make a readstep toward the line on run plays. What's recognizable: Safeties are turning WAY earlier and sometimes even make a pre-snap read. And I noticed that too by our LBs (though it's hard to tell, for they work on their attributes all the time).

Originally posted by PinTBC

So now that linebacker needs to have a 60+ strength, 60+ agility, 50+ speed, and a 60+ visions just to play an outside linebacker spot? That is a foolish way to fix the inadequacies of the design of the running game. Bort seems brighter than that. He has already taken steps to weaken tackling which should help alot, he has also lessened the ability to get off blocks in the running game, it is less than intelligent to force the defensive players to remove themselves from the play for no reason to help the offense.

It is even worse that if what you say is true, there wasn't some kind of general announcement explaining exactly what the intent was. Had I seen one, I would have been all over it. The 3-4 as designed is weak enough without completely ripping its balls out.


It's more like: IF the LBs do their job and watch the run first, the run is totally shut down (averages are pretty low already). So noone would run anymore - this getting the game out of balance.

While I can understand the importance of balance, the way it is done is wrong i.m.h.o. (because it's not realistic). And it becomes a problem if a team focusses on the run entirely. A average of 3.5 yards a carry is not good, but if there's no play below 2.5 it's a TD machine - just go for it on all 4 downs (see the USA Pro Championship in season 4 - especially the Detroit Demon Lions game - almost 100% inside rush).

So this is kind of a package deal: Whoever asks for different LB behavior has to bring up a great solution to find a balance: some runs to be stopped for loss, most in the 3-6 yd range and some 8+.

b.t.w.: I'd head for a 40+ strength, 50 tackling, 60+ agility, 65+ speed and 60+ vision OLB. 60 strength and 50 speed is more the MLB/ILB build.


Originally posted by PinTBC

In the 3-4 the right outside linebacker covers the halfback, the left outside linebacker covers the TE. I would prefer not to blitz the outside linebackers, but if my choice is to just have them run in and tie up the TE at the line of scrimmage and MAYBE get involved with the run, versus run 6 or 7 yards downfield so the Halfback can simply run through the hole they just freaking left, I guess I might have to start blitzing as stupid as it sounds.

I hope to hell someone pops in and says you are wrong, because if you are correct, then the idea that this is even remotely a football sim is false.


So who do the ILBs cover?

Anyway... no hard feelings please. Let's work to get this a better simulation. I'm all for it, but understand the issue of having a somewhat successful running game too. So instead of getting upset - maybe we'll find a solution that provides both realistic LB pathing and successful run blocking/pathing?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.