User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
After each game, I go through the play by play of the opposing offense to see how the defense I called for that particular formation is working. On at least three occasions this year, I've had plays that did not match up with my AI but they would match up in every other instance so I just ignored it. However, today I had it happen for a 4th time and since it's now obvious to me that this is not just a random anomaly I am reporting it.

I have a play call for Pro Set formation. It is set to 100% when the offense is in the Pro Set formation and is a 3-4 Cover 0. On the following play, the AI called my "base" defense which is basically the defense that gets called if no inputs match for any of my formation specific defenses. It's the last one on my list so it should seldom, if ever, get called.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4114485

I ran the exact scenario in the Tester and it came up:

Matching Input
Input Named: Pro Set

Possible Outputs
100% Pro Set (3-4 Cover 0 man)

When I test and show unmatched, I get the following:

Matching Input
Input Named: Pro Set

Possible Outputs
100% Pro Set (3-4 Cover 0 man)

Unmatched Inputs
Input Named: Long Yardage
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? No
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? Yes
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Goal Line Inside 10
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? No
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Goal Line Outside 10
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Weak I
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Strong I
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Big I
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: I-Form
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: Shotgun
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? No
Matched Receivers? Yes
Input Named: 5 WR
Matched Time Remaining? Yes
Matched Down? Yes
Matched Spot? Yes
Matched Yards to Go? Yes
Matched Score? Yes
Matched Formation? Yes
Matched Receivers? No

Please look into this. I'd hate for the wrong formation to come up at the wrong time of a key game. Fortunately, that hasn't happened yet.

And just to show that it would call the correct play every other time, here are all the Pro Set calls after that play, including a long completion from the other team:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4115080

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4117119

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4117211

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4117346

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=145008&pbp_id=4118048

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
A similar problem (though different input and output) is discussed here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1118568

I don't know why this happens, and I've not yet seen it happen to my team, but you're right that it would be terrible for it to happen at a key moment.
 
deweyy67
offline
Link
 
Happens on offense also, twice this season to me, once got us a loss. with the lead late in the fourth(4pt lead) we should have run out the clock yet we pass for an int. AI test shows only 1 output and it was run out the clock 100% run. they drive we lose. last game again up by 4pts 30 seconds left on opps 30 2nd down again run out the clock situation we kick a FG (miss) sim goes with kick game winning fg input when ai tester shows only 1 option and it is run out the clock input. without the tester i would assume i messed up an input but the tester shows the sim went with wrong one.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
I'm going to be a pain in the ass and continue to bump this until it's looked at. It's a legitimate bug, unlike 3/4th's of the stuff that gets posted in here, and I don't want it being ignored.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189


Last edited Oct 2, 2008 19:32:21
 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
had similiar type of problem with our D AI. On 5 WRs formation its either quarter or dime with no blitzing. today the D AI had the MLB blitz in dime against a 5WR formation (had cover 2), leaving one WR WIDE open and unguarded.....kinda upset because it led to a TD


edit
had a couple people check the AI also and all agreed that the play wasn't in the AI (its not a smart output).
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 20:34:36
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




That's a checkdown not a HB pass play.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
If you have QB set to never, it should never checkdown. My QB's are set to never and my RB's have not had one single pass attempt to them yet this season.

Would still like an answer on my original post.
Last edited Oct 2, 2008 22:42:20
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by islander1

I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




That's a checkdown not a HB pass play.


I know that. As Hazy mentioned, my QB not only 'was' set to never, but I had him reset it right before my Washington game Wednesday night, and it still threw to the HB out of the gun.

This bug only applies to the shotgun formation. I can guarantee it's not an AI problem. I've made some AI mistakes, but this one has been quadruple checked.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by islander1


I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




That's a checkdown not a HB pass play.


I know that. As Hazy mentioned, my QB not only 'was' set to never, but I had him reset it right before my Washington game Wednesday night, and it still threw to the HB out of the gun.

This bug only applies to the shotgun formation. I can guarantee it's not an AI problem. I've made some AI mistakes, but this one has been quadruple checked.


Doesn't matter. Even if you're set to 'never' the game may decide to pass anyways if no other pass is open. In that circumstance if your QB had scramble on..he might have ran instead.

It could be a bug but I doubt it. It's just the QB having nothing else to pass to..no one was open so it checked down.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caponesgun
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by caponesgun


Originally posted by islander1



I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




That's a checkdown not a HB pass play.


I know that. As Hazy mentioned, my QB not only 'was' set to never, but I had him reset it right before my Washington game Wednesday night, and it still threw to the HB out of the gun.

This bug only applies to the shotgun formation. I can guarantee it's not an AI problem. I've made some AI mistakes, but this one has been quadruple checked.


Doesn't matter. Even if you're set to 'never' the game may decide to pass anyways if no other pass is open. In that circumstance if your QB had scramble on..he might have ran instead.

It could be a bug but I doubt it. It's just the QB having nothing else to pass to..no one was open so it checked down.


This has never happened up until about 5 or 6 games ago.
That is the only reason I'm presenting it as a bug (thanks hazy, for letting me tag along for this one).

We've been on never dump off for quite some time - last season as well. This issue only reared its head very recently...and again, not once from any formation besides the gun.

I'd rather see the QB throw the ball out of bounds if it were really needed. It'd be better then making a 'catch' for -3 yards.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 10:55:50
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
2 more plays like this today. I-formation where I have a 3-3-5 100% output and it defaulted to my last output (like it did in the first example). The other 20+ I-formation plays were just fine.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by caponesgun

Originally posted by islander1


I am having the same problem with a different set.

Shotgun, the QB occasionally throws to the HB in the flats - even though the QB's setting is never, and Bort or any admin can confirm this within the AI.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=193766&pbp_id=3829189




That's a checkdown not a HB pass play.


I know that. As Hazy mentioned, my QB not only 'was' set to never, but I had him reset it right before my Washington game Wednesday night, and it still threw to the HB out of the gun.




Sounds like he's pulling your leg. I'd trade that liar-liar-pants-on-fire before he pulls your whole team down with his deception and incorrect individual tactics. No way it's a bug.





You know what, the Wolfpack could sure use another QB...
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
The halfback pass happened tonight from the I.

Situation: 3rd and 7, must get a first down to keep the chances of winning alive.
QB setting: never dump pass to the HB.

End result: You guessed it - high quality default sim fail.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=144987&pbp_id=4648947

Oh yeah, the WR3 was wide ass open, and the QB threw across the grain to the HB, rather then 'dumping' off to the FB three yards away from him - which again should never happen to begin with.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 21:39:58
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Well to be fair, the WR only appears to be wide open because the CB jumps to the HB as soon as the pass is thrown. If you look at the positioning of the CB when the pass is actually thrown, he's covering the WR closely.

But still, if you have it set to never, I'm not sure why it's dumping off, although I did notice you had a 15 yard completion to Chaiken earlier in the game.

I really would like an answer on this. It's happened 7 times this season now... it has to be a bug.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.