User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A Brand New Owners and Players Association Idea - Please respond
robelder
offline
Link
 
So I've been trying to come up with a way to see ideas be better organized and also to separate the ideas of owners and players so that each group can have a united voice instead of a mixed voice. Let's be honest each has a different perspective that is worth being viewed as one voice for owners and another voice for players.

Another issue that I would like to see happen with these two associations is better communication with Bort in a way that is organized.

Here is what I'm proposing.
- I would like to see 2 forums created. One that only owners can post in and one for all players.
- I would like to see open discussion in each forum about an agenda of the most important ideas for the future and changes to the game. It would be debate format with no one in charge. Every post would be the representation of the individual owner or player.
- I would like to see the ability added to the top of this forum to create polls to find out what the majority feels about different issues like revenue sharing, gutting, promotions, new features, etc.
- I would also like to see 3 people elected to be leaders of each organization. These leaders would not be decision makers in any way, they would just have a few responsibilities. They would create the polls based on discussions that have been taking place and they would help organize the best and most important questions that owners or players are having with the game and send them to Bort who would then make more of a formal response to each group.

The big problems I see is lack of communication on why somethings are happening and others aren't. I also see a lot of disorganization of great ideas that could easily happen. Finally, I think we need to separate the polls and suggestions of owners and players. Both are completely important, but on many issues it would be awesome to know if the 75% of owners feel this way where as 46% of players feel that way.

So what changes would need to happen?
- We need separate sub forums. (Easy)
- We need a way to create polls. (Polls are already created, we just may need an admin tool created that only allows a few people to create polls.)
- We need to elect 3 people.

The last is the hardest, but could be done by first starting a thread that people can be nominated. Then start a thread where each person writes in their vote.

Does this mean that our votes are automatically going to change the game? No, those decisions are Bort's, but it does give him valuable information to consider when making his decision. It also allows everyone to see what the rest of GLB owners or players think compared to our own personal view.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
New Suggestions from the thread:
- 3 forums instead of two - One for players, one for owners, and one for owners who have players so owners can't sabotage the players only votes. (Krunchy)
Last edited Oct 1, 2008 10:34:50
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Owners have players too. They get a say in both, but player-only agents only have a voice in one? Is that right or would both be mutually exclusive?
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
I don't really want to see either. As an owner, I make sure my guys are happy and if not let them go. As a player, I make sure I sign with teams I trust and go into situations I know will work. I've been on bad teams, played out my contract and left. Should there be admin intervention if an owner try's to hold a player hostage? Yes, there should be. Do I want others making decisions for me in a game I play for fun? No.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Owners have players too. They get a say in both, but player-only agents only have a voice in one? Is that right or would both be mutually exclusive?


They would get a voice in both, but the issues would be different for owners and players. Player issues would be more focused on bad owners or contracts or other issues like that, maybe some game play. Players out number owners dramatically currently so their voice would be louder anyway, and good owners will side with players a majority of the time if they are being reasonable. Bad owners are not the majority of votes on this game. They are too small of a percentage. But it would allow us to see some issues answered from a players perspective vs. owners which should be enlightening. You could always subtract the owners vote from the players vote to see what the player only crowd thinks.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigdawg_56
I don't really want to see either. As an owner, I make sure my guys are happy and if not let them go. As a player, I make sure I sign with teams I trust and go into situations I know will work. I've been on bad teams, played out my contract and left. Should there be admin intervention if an owner try's to hold a player hostage? Yes, there should be. Do I want others making decisions for me in a game I play for fun? No.


People already have a voice to Bort in the suggestion thread as it stands and they are making decisions about your game or influencing Bort. The problem with the current format is that the loudest people get seen and heard the most and may be the minority. With this format you can join a discussion to further the agenda of the owners if you chose and if not just wait till the poll comes out. It only takes a few seconds to read and vote. Or you don't have to vote if you don't care at all. Votes are decisions being made, they just give Bort a representation of how owners feel on certain subjects and allows him to proceed and makes decisions taking in account the opinions of specific groups.
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by robelder
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Owners have players too. They get a say in both, but player-only agents only have a voice in one? Is that right or would both be mutually exclusive?


They would get a voice in both.


And that to you sounds fair?
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
We obviously need a third forum - Players Belonging to Owners.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Originally posted by robelder

Originally posted by kretchfoop


Owners have players too. They get a say in both, but player-only agents only have a voice in one? Is that right or would both be mutually exclusive?


They would get a voice in both.


And that to you sounds fair?


Can I get an amen?
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
Originally posted by robelder

Originally posted by kretchfoop


Owners have players too. They get a say in both, but player-only agents only have a voice in one? Is that right or would both be mutually exclusive?


They would get a voice in both.


And that to you sounds fair?


Like I said before you can subtract can take the owners poll and subtract that from any player poll and get a good representation.

I think owners have players and should have some opinion.

I'm not talking about an organization that deals with contract disputes at all. I'm talking about 2 organizations that communicate ideas back and get answers to questions back in forth about the game with Bort.
 
robelder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
We obviously need a third forum - Players Belonging to Owners.


Great idea!!!! Players only, Owners, and Players/Owners.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.