User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > COVER 2 ZONE ERROR & COVER 0 MAN ERROR!!! NEEDS ADDRESSING!!!
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
Ok, we lost our game today, due to these 2 BS TDs...

First 2 plays, Cover 2 - Zone Underneath Coverage against a 3WR set.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180871&pbp_id=3326123
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180871&pbp_id=3326746

In reality, if the 4 LBs are going into a zone to cover the inside, the CB SHOULD 100% of the time stay with his MAN assignment in the WR...both times he goes inside (FOR NO REASON) and we get beat deep.

Cover 0 - ALL MAN

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180871&pbp_id=3327172

FS/LB/SS ALL COVER the TE??? So now my CB is left on an island alone with the WR???

WHEN YOU DO COVER 0 BORT, the Safties STAY in their SPOTS, then they DOUBLE the OUTSIDE WRs...the CBs should be covering the 3 WRs and the TE.

The 3 players who should be doubled are, WR#1/WR#2/TE.

Only 1 WR is doubled, and the least threat the TE gets tripled???
Last edited Sep 29, 2008 09:41:58
 
DrunkenLemur
offline
Link
 
I've noticed a lot of assignment problems - I think the best way to fix this would be to upgrade the defensive AI with the ability to pick who each cb is assigned too.. e.g. CB1vWR1 CB2vWR2, etc.. this would also allow for CB1vTE if you know that's who they design 3rd down and mediums for, etc.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I agree with you about the cover 0.

But that's standard cover 2 zone. OLBs get the flats, CBs get the area between the ILB and OLB.
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
But he didnt really run the the flat, and WHY would my CB with 40+ VIS, say to himself. "oh i'll leave this WR wide open to go cover a guy who is covered by 2LBS"

It doesnt make logical sense, i see it in the cowboys d, they have their CBs cover their WR assignment and the LBs take away everything in the middle with a zone.

That is what I wanted, I got burned bad 2 times because of this error.

And for 2/3 of those plays to go for scores makes it even worse, we should have won that game, yet sim takes it away from us.
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
IT IS a sim error because LOOK:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=180871&pbp_id=3323882

SAME EXACT PLAY, the CB takes the WR this time, and the LBs cover the middle and pass the #3WR off to the FS, who still screws up but 16.5YRDS is better than 6PTS...

Unless both times he got pump faked, but then that is BS and i THOUGHT Bort fixed that.
 
Link
 
Perhaps the players are missing assignments from time to time?
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
There is another thread entitled "This is Bullsh*t" on this page that talks about the same thing. I was involved in a game where this happened 3 times. I'm just waiting on the DC to give me the exact outputs that we run versus certain formations.

There is certainly something weird going on here.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
I'm not sure why you play 3-4 base defense vs. 2 wideouts in the first 2 examples, it would help alot more to play a 3-3-5
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
it is just 1 formation that got called I usually play a 4-2-5 or 4-1-6 but that play was 20% chance and it got called 3 times lol
 
NotRippedYet
offline
Link
 
There's also problems with Cover 1 and the single back and pro-set formations. If you blitz 1 LB there is still enough coverage to go around, yet the remaining LB moves to double teams leaving the back open every single time.
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
Like the one guy a few posts above me said having a CB1 - WR1 like setting would help SO MUCH!

Then my cover 0s would work bettter is shutting the the passing game on a high end WR.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
main problem with the cover 2 from the OP is that there aren't enough CB. This sim isn't robust enough to handle the option of running base defense against 3 WR yet.

in the cover 0 example in the OP it looks like the CB just got faked out/beat by the WR/QB. I definitely understand the frustration of the triple coverage of the TE... But, anybody with experience in this game knows that's likely to happen.
 
A-Wad
offline
Link
 
Ok but basic LOGIC in anything is if #1 is supposed to cover #1, #1 doesnt decide on its own that #2 is what it wants instead.

IMO #1 shouldn't even have an OPTION or any knowledge that #2 exists in coverage standpoint.

It seems like the CB has a mind of its own, and in a coded game, that shouldn't happen because you tell the game what is wrong and what is right. It doesnt get to decide its own fate we tell it its fate.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
The basic logic in that play is correct, it just makes no sense using 'football logic'.

In terms of your Cover 2 problem you are absolutely right in saying that the CBs should have Man coverage assignments in that situation.

However in a Cover 2 the CB is never, ever, in a Man assignment.

Cover 2 dictates that the CB is in a Zone coverage system, and you put 1 CB vs 2 WRs in a zone scheme.

The result there is you are asking the CB to make a decision about what he is going to do, you have lost all control.

The Sim simply does what you ask of it.

You wanted a 34 with LBs in Zones, and the safeties splitting the field, leaving a 1 vs 2 coverage to the outside.

There are still lots of play calls where the sim is not robust enough to make a 'Football Logic' decision.

Remember that on Defense, plays are not really designed individually to compliment themselves, like on Offense.

If there were a change needed its to seperate the Safeties behaviour from the CBs behaviour.

Coverage Shells dont allow the fredom to create solid Defenses, whats needed is a way to introduce Safety responsibility irrespective of CB assignments.

For example Cover 2 is actually a 'Half field coverage' or 1/2
Cover 4 is actually a 'Qurter field coverage' or 1/4.

Some of the best defenses use 1/4 1/4 1/2 coverage, where one side of the field is in Cover 4, and the other side is in Cover 2.

Allowing the DCs to independantly chose if their CBs play Man or Zone (Short/Med/Deep) and then each safety to play Cover 1,2,3 or 4 would result in no more 'Unknown' coverage types.

Whatever we throw at the Sim, it would have a reference point.

No more unexplained behaviour, beyond broken coverages and pump fakes.



 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.